The Review of Korean Studies
- P-ISSN1229-0076
- E-ISSN2773-9351
- SCOPUS, ESCI
ISSN : 1229-0076
Comparison of the Periodization Methodologies of the Korean Bronze Age and the Japanese Yayoi Period
Abstract
In this article, I will examine the research history of subdivision/periodization of Korea’s Bronze Age and Japan’s Yayoi period and compare the methodologies of the two countries. The subdivisions of the Korean Bronze Age and the Japanese Yayoi period are similar in that they set changes in pottery as the basis, but show clear differences in their contents. The subdivision of the Korean Bronze Age set at first the changes in metalware and later the changes in pottery as the standard. However, after the concept of “types” was introduced, cultural epochs became the standard. Of course, periodization is initially done using material culture including pottery, followed by cultural interpretations of other archaeological aspects. However, it can be seen as a methodological limitation. The subdivision of the Japanese Yayoi period, however, used changes in pottery as the standard since the formation of Japanese archaeology. Whether good or bad, it is said to be the most important characteristic of Japanese archaeology. Of course, the idea is that classification is not simply based on changes in pottery form but includes changes in pottery types under the concept of “model,” but is limited in its actual application.
- keywords
- Bronze Age, Yayoi period, periodization, type, pottery
Reference
An, Jaeho. 2000. Hanguknongyeonsahoiui seongrip. Hanguk gogohakbo 43:41-66.
Bae, Jinseong. 2005. Geomdanri yuhyeongui seonglip. Hanguk sangosahakbo 48:5-28.
Cheon, Seonhaeng. 2005. Hanbando doldaemuntogiui hyeonseonggwa jeongae. Hanguk gogohakbo 57:61-97.
Cheon, Seonhaeng. 2008. Mumuntogisidaeui jogi seoljeonggwa siganjeok beomwi. Hanguk cheongdonggihakbo 1:4-27.
Do, Yuho, and Gideok Hwang. 1957. Jitapli yujeok balgul josa jungganbogo 2. Munhwa yusan, no. 6.
Gogohak∙Minsokhak yeonguso. 1961. Jitamni wonsi yujeok balgulnogo je 8 jip. P’y̆ongyang: Gwahakwon chulpansa.
Ha, Insu. 1989. Yeongnamjibang dandomayeontogie daehan singochal. M.A. thesis, Pusan National University.
Hamada, Kousaku. 1919. Yayoisikidokikeisikibunruisyuseizuroku. In Kyototeikokudaigaku bungakubu koukogakukenkyusitsu houkoku 6, ed. Hamada Kousaku, 6-48. Kyoto: Kyototeigokudaigaku..
Hamada, Kousaku. 1922. Tsuron Koukogaku. Tokyo: Daitoukaku.
Huziguchi, Kenzi. 1986. Cyosenmumondoki to yayoidoki. In Yayoibunka no kenkyu 3. Yayoidoki, ed. Sahara. Makoto, 147-162. Tokyo: Yuuzankaku.
Huzita, Ryousaku. 1942. Cyosennosekizidai. Touyosikouza 1:43-139.
Huzita, Saburo, and Hiroaki Matsumoto. 1989. Yamatochiiki. In Yayoidoki no yousiki to hennen Kinkihen Ⅰ, ed. Terazawa Kaoru, 147-99. Tokyo: Mokujisya.
Izumi, Takura. 1991. Yayoizidaiwaitsuhazimattaka. In Souten Nihonnorekisi ①, ed. Suzuki Kimio, 44-72. Tokyo: Sinzinbutsuoraisya.
Jeon, Yeongrae. 1977. Hangukcheongdonggimunhwaui gyebowa pyeonnyeon. Jeonbukyujeokjosabogo 7:4-88.
Jeong, Handeok. 1999. Hunamriyuhyeong hyeonseonggwajeong jaegeomtoe daehan torong. Hoseo gogohak 1:99-101.
Kim, Gwonjung. 2005. Yeongseojiyeok cheongdonggisidae jugeojiui pyeonnyeon mit seonggyok. In Gwangwonjiyeokui cheongdonggimunhwa, ed. Gangwongogohakhoi, 111-44. Chuncheon: Gangwongogohakhoi.
Kim, Hansik. 2006. Gyeonggijiyeok yeoksamdong yuhyeongui jeonlib gwajeon. In Seoulgyeonggijiyeok cheongdonggimunhwaui yuhyeonggwa byoncheon, ed. Seoul Gyeonggi gogohakhoi, 7-37. Seoul: Seoul Gyeonggi gogohakhoi.
Kim, Jansuk. 2008. Mumuntokisidae jogi seoljeonron jaego. Hanguk gogohakbo 69:94-115.
Kim, Jaeyun. 2004. Hanbando gakmokdoldaemuntogiui pyeonnyeongwa gyebo. Hanguk sangosahakbo 46:31-69.
Kim, Jeonghak. 1972. Seidoukizidai. In Kankokun no koukogaku, ed. Kim Jeonghak, 68-105. Tokyo: Kawadesinsya.
Kim, Wonryong. 1964. Hanguk munhwaui gogohakjeok yeongu. Hanguk munhwa sadaegye 1:1-30.
Kim, Wonryong. 1973. Hanguk gogohakgaeseol 1 pan. Seoul: Iljisa.
Kim, Wonryong. 1986. Hanguk gogohakgaeseol 3 pan. Seoul: Iljisa.
Kobayasi, Tatsuo. 1989. Jomondoki no yousiki to keisiki to katasiki. In Jomondokidaikan 4. Kouki, Banki, Zokujoumon, ed. Kobayasi Tatsuo, 248-57. Tokyo: Shogakukan.
Kobayasi, Yukio. 1943. Yamato karako yayoi iseki no kenkyu Kyototeikokudaigaku bungakubu koukogaku kenkyusitsu houkoku 16. Kyoto: Rinsensyoten.
Kobayasi, Yukio. 1959. Keisiki∙Keiskigakuteki kenkyuhou. In Zukai Koukogakuziten, ed. Mizuno Seiichi, 296-97. Tokyo: Sougansinsya.
Kobayasi, Yukio. 1971. Ronsyu Nihonbunkanokigen Koukogaku. Tokyo: Heibonsya.
Kobayasi, Yukio, and Morimoto Rokuzi. 1939. Yayoisikidoki syusei zuroku. Osaka: Tokyokoukogakukai.
Kosugi, Yasushi. 1995. Dokikeisiki to dokikatasiki. Sundaisigaku 94:58-130.
Lee, Baekgyu. 1974. Gyeonggido mumuntogi, majeseokgi. Gogohak 3:53-129.
Lee, Cheonggyu. 1988. Namhangibang mumuntogi munhwa jeongaewa gongryeoltogi munhwaui wichi. Hanguk sangosahakbo 1:37-92.
Lee, Hongjong. 1996. Cheongdonggisahoiui togiwa jugeo. Seoul:Seogyeongchulpansa.
Lee, Seongju. 1992. Sinseokigisidae. In Hangukseonsagogohaksa, ed. Choi Mongryong, 77-168. Seoul: Kachi.
Lim, Byeontae. 1969. Hangangyuyeok mumuntogiui yeongdae. In Ihongjikbaksahoigabginyeom hanguksaninchong, ed. Ihongjikbaksahoigabginyeom nonmunjibganhaengeuiwonhoi, 88-109. Seoul: Singumunhwasa.
Lim, Byeontae. 1992. Hanguk cheongdonggisidai yeongueui oneulgwa naiil. Seonsamunhwa 1:18-29.
Maida, Souziro. 1896. Yaoisiki doki (Kaitsukadoki ni nitte usude no mono) hatken ni tsukete. Tokyozinruigakuzatsi 11(122).
Morimoto, Rokuzi. 1933. Yayoisikidokizusyu. Tokyo: Tokyokoukogakukai.
Morimoto, Rokuzi. 1935. Yayoisikidoki ni okeru nisya-Yousiki youso tanni kettei no mondai. Koukogaku 5(1).
Morioka, Hideto. 1989. Gyoseki to sono ronten. In Yayoidoki no yousiki to hennen Kinkihen Ⅰ, ed. Terazawa Kaoru, 3-26. Tokyo: Mokujisya.
Nakayama, Heiziro. 1917. Kyusyuhokubu ni okeru sensi gensi ryouziki cyukan kikan no ibutsu ni tsuite. Koukogakuzatsi 7(10).
Park, Jinil. 2008. Jeomtodaetogi, gurigo cheongdonggisidaewa chogicheolgisidae. Hanguk cheongdonggihakbo 1:84-114.
Sahara, Makoto. 1959. Yayoisiki doki seisaku ni kansuru nisan no kousatsu. Watasitachinokoukogaku 20:2-11.
Sahara, Makoto. 1975. Nougyonokaisitokaikyusyakainokeisei. In Iwanamikouza Nihonsi 1, ed. Sahara makoto, 113-182. Tokyo: Iwanamikouza.
Sugihara, Sousuke. 1960. Nougyo no hatsei to bunka no hengaku. In Sekai koukogaku daikei 2, ed. Asano Kiyosi, 136-53. Tokyo: Heibionsya.
Suzuki, Tokuo. 2008. Keisikigakutekihouho ③. In Zyoumonzidainokoukogaku rekisonomonosasi, ed. Kousugi Yasuo, 72-85. Tokyo: Douseisya.
Terasawa, Kaoru. 1989. Kakutiikinoheikoukankei∙Kaisetsu. In Yayoidoki no yousiki to hennen Kinkihen Ⅰ, ed. Terazawa Kaoru, 322-27. Tokyo: Mokuhisya.
Tsuboi, Syogoro. 1889. Teikokudaigaku no rinchi ni kaijuka no konseki ari. Tokyogakugeizatsi 6(91).
Tsude, Hiroshi. 1974. Kohunsyutsugenkizenyano syudankankei: Yodogawa suikeio cyusinni. Koukogakukenkyu 20(4).
Yawata, Ichiro. 1928. Minamisakugunnokoukogakutekikenkyu. Tokyo: Okasyoin.
Yi, Kisung. 2006. Ikoukiniokerukannichihikaku. Cyosenkodaikenkyu 7:1-19.
Yi, Kisung. 2008a. Ilbon jyomong∙yayoi jeonhwangiui seoki byeonhwa. Hanguk sangosahakbo 59:21-49.
Yi, Kisung. 2008b. Ilbon jyomong yayoi jeonhwangiui yeonggu bangbeobronui geomto. Gogohak 7(1).
Yi, Kisung. 2008c. Seoulgyeonggijiyeok mumuntogisidae jeon∙junggiui seokigi yangsang. In Seoul Gyeonggi mumuntogimunhwaui heureum, ed. Seoul Gyeonggi gogohakhoi, 107-25. Seoul: Seoul Gyeonggigo gohakhoi.
Yun, Mubyeong. 1972. Hanguk cheongdongyumului yeonggu. Baeksanhakbo 12:59-134.
- Downloaded
- Viewed
- 0KCI Citations
- 0WOS Citations