The Review of Korean Studies
- Apply for Authority
- P-ISSN1229-0076
- E-ISSN2773-9351
- SCOPUS, ESCI
ISSN : 1229-0076
Anticommunism and the National Identity of Korea in the Contemporary Era: With a Special Focus on the USAMGIK and Syngman Rhee Government Periods
- Downloaded
- Viewed
Abstract
The national identity of the Korean people is the result of shared experiences during Korea’s modern and contemporary history. In this regard, anticommunism, which greatly influenced society following the birth of the Republic of Korea, was closely related to the identity of the Republic of Korea. In general, the national identity tends to be identified with ethnic identity. In the case of Korea, which found itself under the unique environment characterized by the division of the nation into two Koreas, the identity of the political system has greatly influenced the formation of the national identity. This study focuses on the formation of the identity of the political system, and in particular on the anticommunism that is regarded as having exercised the greatest influence on the formation of the identity of the political system. Previous studies have exhibited a tendency to overemphasize the negative impact which anticommunism had on liberal democratic values and political development, while overlooking a periodic situation that was characterized by the advent of the Cold War order and the uniqueness of the North-South Korean relationship. Anticommunism, which is based on communal principles, has in some ways had a negative impact on liberal democracy, under which individual freedom is regarded as being of great importance. However, viewed from the standpoint of national security, anticommunism ironically can also be regarded as having served as a bulwark that protected liberal democracy. The Republic of Korea could not have achieved its current levels of economic prosperity and political democratization if it had not served as an anticommunism bulwark that protected its system from the political attacks of the communists. Consequently, it was inevitable for the Republic of Korea, which found itself confronted by North Korea, to opt for the ‘necessary evil’ of anticommunism.
- keywords
- anticommunism, national identity, liberal democracy, communism. AMG, Syngman Rhee government, Korean politics, 반공주의, 국가정체성, 자유민주주의, 공산주의, 미군정, 이승만 정부, 한국정치
Reference
An, Cheol-hyeon. 2009. Upgrade teukgang Hanguk hyeondae jeongchisa [Upgraded Special Lectures on the History of Korean Contemporary Politics]. Seoul: Saeroun Saramdeul.
An, Jae-seong. 2009. Park Heon-yeong pyeongjeon [The biography of Park Heon-yeong]. Seoul: Silcheon Munhaksa.
Baek, Un-seon. 1995. Yi Seungman jeonggwon leadershipui giwongwa jawon [The origin and sources of the leadership of the Syngman Rhee regime]. In Kim, Ho-jin et al., 1995.
Byeon, Dong-myeong. 2007. Je il gonghwaguk chogiui gukga boanbeop jejeonggwa gaejeong [The enactment and amendment of National Security Act during the early stage of the First Republic]. Minju Juuiwa Ingwon (The May 18th Institute of Chonnam National University) 7 (1) [Democracy and Human Rights 7 (1)] : 85-121.
Choe, Hee-sik. 2010. Yi Seungman jeongbu sigiui hanil gwangye: hanmiil naengjeon jeollyagui burhyeop hwaeumgwa hanil gwangyeui jeongche [Korea-Japan relations during the Syngman Rhee government: The disharmony in the Korea-U.S.-Japan Cold War strategy and the true character of Korea-Japan relations]. In Lee, Chang-hun et al., 2010.
Gang, Gyeong-geun. 2006. Heonbeopgwa gukga jeongcheseong [The constitution and the national identity]. Jayu Minju Yeongu (Liberal Democracy Association) 1 (1) [Journal of Liberal Democracy 1 (1)]:75-88.
Gang, In-cheol. 2007. Hangugui gaesingyowa bangong juui [Korean Protestant churches and anticommunism]. Seoul: Jungsim.
Gang, Jeong-in et al. 2009. Hanguk jeongchiui inyeomgwa sasang [The ideological and philosophical elements of Korean politics]. Seoul: Humanitas Book.
Gong, Im-sun. 2010. Scandalgwa bangong gukga juui [Scandals and anticommunist nationalism]. Seoul: LP Publishing.
Han, Bae-ho. 2008. Jayureul hyanghan isip segi Hanguk jeongchisa [The history of Korean politics in the 20th century: Toward freedom]. Seoul: Iljogak.
Han, Seung-ju. 1981. Je il gonghwagugui yusan [The legacy of the First Republic of Korea]. Jin, Deok-gyu et al. 1950 nyeondaeui insik [The perception of the 1950s]. Seoul: Hangilsa.
Hyeondae Sasang Yeonguhoe. 2009. Bandaeseui bimil, geu ilgeureojin chosang [Secrets of the antinational Group, the twisted portrait]. Seoul: Inyeongsa.
Jin, Deok-gyu et al. 1981. 1950 nyeondaeui insik [The perception of the 1950s]. Seoul: Hangilsa.
Jo, Guk. 1988. Hanguk geunhyeondaesa eseoui sasang tongjebeop [Ideological control in Korean modern and contemporary history]. Yeoksa Bipyeong 1 (3): 319-348.
Jo, Hyeon-yeon. 2000. Hanguk hyeondae jeongchiui angmong: Gukga pongnyeok [The nightmare of Korean contemporary politics: State violence]. Seoul: Chaeksesang.
Jo, Jun-hyeon. 2006a. Gukga boanbeop wiban sageon [The violation of the National Security Act]. National Archives of Korea. http://contents.archives.go.kr/next/content/listSubjectDescription.do?id=000961 (accessed July 29, 2011).
Jo, Jun-hyeon. 2006b. Gukga boanbeop jegaejeong [The amendment of the National Security Act]. National Archives of Korea. http://contents.archives.go.kr/next/content/listSubjectDescription.do?id=000946 accedssed July 29, 2011).
Kim, Il-yeong. 2004. Geongukgwa buguk: Hyeondae hanguksa gangui [The establishment of a prosperous country and nation: Lecutures on contemporary Korean history]. Seoul: Saenggakui namu.
Kim, Il-yeong. 1999. Yi Seungman jeongbueseoui oegyo jeongchaekgwa gungnae jeongchi: Bukjin banil jeongchaekgwa gungnae jeongchi gyeongjewaui yeongyeseong [The linkage between foreign policy and domestic politics in Rhee government: The relationship between the march north & anti-Japan policy and the domestic political economy]. Gukje Jeongchi Nonchong (The Korean Association of International Studies) 39 (3) [Korean Journal of International Relations 39 (3)]: 243-262.
Kim, Hyeon-u. 2000. Hanguk jeongdang tonghap undongsa [The history of the Korean political party integration movement]. Seoul: Eulyu Munhwasa.
Kim, Ho-jin et al. 1995. Hanguk hyeondae jeongchisa [The history of Korean contemporary politics]. Seoul: Beopmunsa.
Kim, Myeong-seop. 2011. Hanguk hyeondaesa insigui saeroun ‘jinbo’ reul wihan seongchal: Segyesa jeok maengnaghwa wa ‘banbangong’ juuiui geukbok [Reflections on the new ‘progressiveness’ in the perceptions of Korean contemporary history: The connection with global history and overcoming of ‘anti-anticommunism’]. Hangugui hyeondae sahak mueosi munjeinga? [Korean contemporary history, what are the problems?]. Academic conference to celebrate the foundation of the Association for Contemporary Korean History. May 20.
Kim, Un-tae et al. 1989. Hanguk jeongchiron [Korean politics]. Seoul: Pakyoungsa.
Kim, Yeong-myeong. 2006. Hangugui jeongchi byeondong [Korea’s political shifts]. Seoul: Eulyu Munhwasa.
Kim, Yong-uk. 2000. Migunjeonggwa jungdo minjok seryeogui jwaui tonghap undong [The left-right integration movement promoted by the AMG and the centrist nationalist group]. In Han, Bae-ho et al. Hanguk hyeondae jeongchiron I [Korean contemporary political theory I]. Seoul: Oreum.
Kwon, Hee-young. 2011. Forum: Hanguk hyeondaesaui umjigilsu eomneun jinsil [Forum: The unmovable truth in Korean contemporary history]. Munhwa Ilbo, May 13. http://www.munhwa.com/news/view.html? no=2011051301033937191003 (accessed May 20, 2011).
Lee, Chang-hun et al., eds. 2010. Hanguk geun·hyeondae jeongchiwa ilbon II: Haebang hu [Korean modern-contemporary politics and Japan II: After liberation]. Seoul: Seonin.
Lee, Ho-jin and In-seop Gang. 1988. Igeosi gukhoeda [This is the National Assembly]. Seoul: Samsung Publishing.
Lee, Na-mi. 2011. Hangugui bosuwa sugu: Inyeomui yeoksa [Conservatism and reactionism: The history of ideology]. Seoul: Jiseongsa.
Lee, Wan-beom. 2004. 1950 nyeondae huban hanguk jeongchisa yeongu: Yi Seungman jeongbu mollak gwajeongeseo ireonan boanbeop padongeul jungsimeuro [Korean politics during the late 1950s: With a special focus on the amendment of the National Security Act during the collapse process of the Syngman Rhee regime]. In Jeong-in, Se-jung Kim, Il-yeong Kim et al., 2004.
Mun, Jeong-in, Se-jung Kim, Il-yeong Kim et al. 2004. 1950 nyeondae Hanguksaui jaejomyeong [A new look at Korean history in the 1950s]. Seoul: Seonin.
National Committee for Investigation of the Truth about the Jeju April 3 Incident, The. 2003. Jeju 4·3 sageon jinsang josa bogoseo [Report on the investigation of the truth about the Jeju April 3rd Incident]. Seoul: Seonin.
National History Compilation Committee of Republic of Korea, The. 1990. Hanguk geunhyeondaesa sajeon [A dictionary of Korean modern and contemporary history]. Seoul: Garam Gihwik.
Oh, Myeong-ho. 1999. Hanguk hyeondae jeongchisaui ihae [Understanding the history of Korean contemporary politics]. Seoul: Oreum.
Park, Gwang-ju. 2010. Hanguk jeongchi: Jeongaewa jeonmang [Korean politics: development and future outlook]. Seoul: Hanul.
Park, Myeong-rim. 1995. Hanguk jeonjaeng: Sigak, iron, bangbeop, haeseogui munje [The Korean War: Problems related to the prevailing viewpoints, theories, methodology, and interpretation]. In Kim, Ho-jin et al., 1995.
Park, Won-sun. 1997 and 1992. Gukga boanbeop yeongu. [A study on the National Security Act]. 2 vols. Seoul: Yeoksa Bipyeongsa.
Rhee, Syngman. 1949. Je sa junyeon gwangbokjeol gyeongchuksa [Congratulatory speech given to mark the 4th anniversary of independence]. August 15. http://ko.wikisource.org/wiki/%EC%A0%9C4%EC%A3%BC%EB%85%84_%EA%B4%91%EB%B3%B5%EC%A0%88_%EA%B2%BD%EC%B6%95%EC%82%AC.
Rhee, Syngman. 1951. Je yuk junyeon gwangbokjeol gyeongchuksa [Congratulatory speech given to mark the 6th anniversary of Independence]. August 15. http://ko.wikisource.org/wiki/%EC%A0%9C6%EC%A3%BC%EB%85%84_%EA%B4%91%EB%B3%B5%EC%A0%88_%EA%B2%BD%EC%B6%95%EC%82%AC.
Rhee, Syngman. 1952a. Je yi dae daetongnyeong chwiimsa [Inaugural address on the occasion of the commencement of a 2nd term]. August 15. http://ko.wikisource.org/wiki/%EC%A0%9C2%EB%8C%80_%EB%8C%80%ED%95%9C%EB%AF%BC%EA%B5%AD_%EB%8C%80%ED%86%B5%EB%A0%B9_%EC%B7%A8%EC%9E%84%EC%82%AC.
Rhee, Syngman. 1952b. Je chil junyeon gwangbokjeol gyeongchuksa [Congratulatory Speech given to mark the 7th anniversary of Independence]. August 15. http://ko.wikisource.org/wiki/%EC%A0%9C7%EC%A3%BC%EB%85%84_%EA%B4%91%EB%B3%B5%EC%A0%88_%EA%B2%BD%EC%B6%95%EC%82%AC.
Wikipedia, s.v. “Jayu minjujuui” [Liberal democracy]. http://ko.wikipedia.org/wiki/%EC%9E%90%EC%9C%A0%EB%AF%BC%EC%A3%BC%EC%A3%BC%EC%9D%98 (accessed July 29, 2011).
Yang, Dong-an. 2004. Daehan Minguk jeongcheseongeun heonbeop·bangong· hanmi dongmaeng [The identity of the Republic of Korea is composed of the constitutional law, anticommunism, and the Korea-U.S. alliance]. Jayu Gongnon (Korea Freedom Federation) (September).
Yang, Yeong-jo. 2007. Jeju 4·3 sageon [The Jeju April 3rd Incident]. National Archives of Korea. http://contents.archives.go.kr/next/content/listSubject Description.do?id=006329 (accessed July 29, 2011).
Yu, Dong-yeol. 2011. Bukhanui daenam jeollyak silche [The true nature of North Korea’s strategy toward South Korea]. Oh, Il-whan et al. Hogukgwa bohun [The defense of the fatherland and patriots and veterans]. Korea Education and Research Institute for Patriots & Veterans.
- Downloaded
- Viewed
- 0KCI Citations
- 0WOS Citations