The Review of Korean Studies
- P-ISSN1229-0076
- E-ISSN2773-9351
- SCOPUS, ESCI
ISSN : 1229-0076
The Guan Yu Cult and Joseon-Qing Visions of State Legitimacy, 1882-1894
Abstract
The Joseon Guan Yu cult was a staple of informal and popular Korean histories written in the first half of the twentieth century. In these highly critical and often mocking accounts, the cult comes to signify an irrational refusal of the modern typical of the perceived Joseon failure to cope with the realities of global imperialism. The Guan Yu cult, however, was more than this. Qing military officers deployed to Seoul from 1882 to 1885 presented plaques to Joseon Guan Yu temples which, through the lens of the Guan Yu faith, located the legitimacy of the Joseon state in its submission of tribute to the Qing court. King Gojong composed ritual and stele texts that shared the Qing officers’ faith in Guan Yu but interpreted his divine interventions in Joseon affairs not as the product of Joseon loyalty to Qing but rather of the inherent legitimacy of the Joseon state and throne. The seriousness with which the Joseon throne took the Guan Yu cult is apparent in the controversy at court in 1893 concerning the punishment of an official who publicly condemned lavish state support for the cult. The facile dismissals of colonial-period histories obscure the fact that the cult was one arena wherein Joseon and Qing understandings of Joseon state legitimacy and the nature of the Joseon-Qing relationship clashed at time when the two states were engaged in an often tense process of redefining their relations in a rapidly changing geopolitical environment.
- keywords
- Guan Yu, Joseon, Qing, legitimacy, state cult
Reference
An, Hyoje. 1927. Supa jip [The Collected Works of Supa An Hyoje]. N.P.: Gosanjae.
An, Hyoje . 2008. Gugyeok Supa jip [Korean Translation of the Collected Works of Supa An Hyoje]. Translated by Junwon Bak and Jaeju Nam. Gyeongju: Sinji seowon.
Bak, Judae. 1980. Na-am surok [The Miscellaneous Chronicles of Na-am Bak Judae]. Reprinted edition. Seoul: Guksa pyeongchan wiwonhoe.
Ban, Gu. (111) 1996. Hanshu: Song Jingyou kanben [Book of Han: Song Jingyou, Facsimile Edition]. Taibei: Shangwu yinshuguan.
Chen, Shou. (c. 280) 1977. Xinjiao Sanguo zhi zhu [Annotated Record of the Three Kingdoms]. Newly edited. Taibei: Shijie shuju.
Chien, Frederick F. 1967. The Opening of Korea: A Study of Chinese Diplomacy. Hamden, CT: The Shoestring Press.
Cook, Harold F. 1972. Korea’s 1884 Incident. Seoul: Royal Asiatic Society, Korea Branch.
Gim, Jiyeong. 2016. “Joseon hugi Gwanwang-myo hyangyu ui du yangsang” [Two Aspects of the Meaning of the Guan Yu Temples in the Late Joseon Period]. Gyujanggak 49: 501-31.
Gim, Jongga. (1912) 1972. Sok tonggam gangmok [Eastern Mirror Chronicle, Continued]. Namwon: Namwon hyanggyo.
Gim, Pyeongeop. 1928. Jeungbo Daedong ginyeon [Expanded Edition of the Chronicle of the Great East]. Gyeongseong: Cheonggu chulpan.
Gim, Taegyeong. (1918) 2006. Daedongsa [History of the Great East]. Reprinted edition. Andong: Hangukhak jinheungwon.
Gim, Taegyeong. 1922. Hanguk yeokdae sosa [A Brief History of Korea]. Nantong: Hanlin heilin shuju.
Gim, Uihwan. 1974. “Supa An Hyoje ui saengae wa sasang” [The Life and Thought of Supa An Hyoje]. In Uheon Jeong Junghwan baksa hwallyeok ginyeom nonmun jip [Commemorative Essay Collection in Honor of the Sixtieth Birthday of Dr. Uheon Jeong Junghwan], 287-311. Busan: Uheon Jeong Junghwan baksa hwallyeok ginyeom nonmun jip ganhaeng wiwonhoe.
Gim, Yonghak. 1928. Daedong sagang [Historical Chronicle of the Great East]. Seoul: Daedong sagang sa.
Gojong. (1919) 1999. Gojong munjip: juyeon jip [The Literary Anthology of King Gojong: The Collected Works of Juyeon]. Reprinted edition. Seongnam: Hanguk jeongsin munhwa yeonguwon.
Gojong Sunjong sillok [Veritable Records of Kings Gojong and Sunjong]. (1935) 1986. Reprinted edition. Seoul: Tamgudang.
Guksa pyeonchan wiwonhoe, ed. 1971. Donghangnan girok [Records of the Donghak Rebellion]. Seoul: Guksa pyeonchan wiwonhoe., ed. 1980.
Guksa pyeonchan wiwonhoe, ed. 1980. Yongho hallok [The Trivial Record of Yongho]. Seoul: Guksa pyeonchan wiwonhoe.
Han, Jongsu. 2003. “Joseon hugi Sukjong-dae Gwanwang-myo chije ui seonggyeok” [The Character of Sacrificial Rites at the Guan Yu Temples during the Late-Joseon Reign of King Sukjong]. MA diss., Chung-Ang University.
Hong, Yungi. 2018. “Joseon Gojong ‘Bungmyo myojeong bi’ bimun ui Gwan Yu gwallyeon girok gwa Mo Jonggang pyeongbon Samguk yeonui” [Records Related to Guan Yu in the “Northern Temple Courtyard Stele” by King Gojong of Joseon and Mao Zhonggang’s Edition of Romance of the Three Kingdoms]. Jungguk eomun nonchong 90: 99-129.
Hong, Yunsik, ed. 1987. Seoul geumseongmun daegwan [Overview of Seoul Epigraphy]. Seoul: Seoul teukbyeol-si.
Hwang, Hyeon. (1910) 1971. Maecheon yarok [Maecheon’s Informal History]. Reprinted edition. Seoul: Guksa pyeonchan wiwonhoe.
Jang, Dobin. 1945. Hanguk mallyeon sa [The History of the Declining Years of the Han Empire]. Gyeongseong: Deokheung seorim.
Jang, Gyeonghui, ed. 2012. Dong Gwanwang-myo sojang yumul gicho haksul josa bogoseo [Report on the Preliminary Scholarly Survey of Objects Held in the Eastern Guan Yu Temple]. Seoul: Jongno gucheong.
Jeong, Gyo. (1913) 1974. Hanmal gyenyeonsa [History of the Late Han Empire]. Seoul: Guksa pyeonchan wiwonhoe.
Jo, Seongyun. 2013. “Imo gullan” [The Military Rebellion of 1882]. In Hanguksa [The History of Korea], edited by Guksa pyeonchan wiwonhoe. Gwacheon: Guksa pyeonchan wiwonhoe.
Jo, Wongyo. 2017. “Gungnip bangmulgwan sojang ‘Bungmyo myojeong bi’ e daehayeo” [On the “Northern Temple Courtyard Stele” Held in the Korean National Museum]. Kyureiteo wa ui daehwa 572: 1-4.
Kim, Dalchoong. 1972. “Korea’s Quest for Reform and Diplomacy in the 1880’s.” PhD diss., Tufts University.
Lewis, Mark. 2007. The Early Chinese Empires: Qin and Han. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Lu, Buwei. (c. 239 BCE) 2000. The Annals of Lu Buwei: A Complete Translation and Study. Translated by John Knoblock and Jeffrey Riegel. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Ruan, Yuan, ed. (1815) 1983. Shisanjing zhushu [The Thirteen Classics, Annotated]. Beijing: Zhonghua shuju chuban.
Seungjeongwon ilgi [Daily Record of the Royal Secretariat]. (1623-1910) 1967-1968. Seoul: Guksa pyeongchan wiwonhoe.
Sin, Yongha. 2013. “Gapsin jeongbyeon” [The Coup of 1884]. In Hanguksa [The History of Korea], edited by Guksa pyeonchan wiwonhoe, 333-435. Gwacheon: Guksa pyeonchan wiwonhoe.
Song, Sangdo. 1974. Giryeo supil [Miscellaneous Observations from a Journey by Burro]. Seoul: Guksa pyeonchan wiwonhoe.
ter Haar, Barend J. 2017. Guan Yu: The Religious Afterlife of a Failed Hero. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Van Lieu, Joshua. 2014. “A Farce that Wounds Both High and Low: The Guan Yu Cult in Chosŏn-Ming Relations.” Journal of Korean Religions 5 (2): 39-70.
Yi, Neunghwa. 1927. “Joseon musok go” [A Study of Joseon Shamanistic Customs]. Gyemyeong 19.
Yi, Seonghyeong. 2014. “Dae-Myeong uiri ron ui chui wa Joseon Gwanwang-myo” [Joseon Guan Yu Temples and the Development of Ming Loyalism]. Hanguk hanmunhak yeongu 53: 353-90.
- Downloaded
- Viewed
- 0KCI Citations
- 0WOS Citations