The Review of Korean Studies
- P-ISSN1229-0076
- E-ISSN2773-9351
- SCOPUS, ESCI
ISSN : 1229-0076
The Potsdam Conference and the Role of the U.S. in the Division of Korea along the 38th Parallel North: August-11 Draft Theory vs. July-25 Conception Theory
Abstract
Conventional accounts of the division of the Korean Peninsula at the 38th parallel north see the line as having been suddenly drafted for the convenience of the military on August 11, 1945. This narrative was based on oral testimony records of Brigadier General Lincoln, who headed the strategic planning unit under the U.S. joint special operations agency. Lincoln and his subordinates, Colonels Bonesteel and Rusk, testified that their decision was based on a <i>National Geographic</i> map, which was later discovered at the U.S. National Archives. Cartographic discrepancies, however, suggest that the August 11 accidental draft may be a deliberate cover-up for actual deliberations that had taken place earlier. Interviews with Lieutenant General Hull reveal that the idea of the 38th parallel line was created at an earlier date, around July 25, during the Potsdam Conference. The 38th parallel plan is therefore better interpreted as an outcome of U.S. decision-makers’ advance preparation, which began at a date no later than July 25. It was apparently based on political interest to prevent the Soviet Union’s southward advancement. While Hull’s memoir partly differs from the conventional U.S.-Soviet secret pact theory, it should be regarded as relevant, especially because he was the superior in position to the three individuals on whose testimony the conventional theories are based. The present study concludes that while the actual draft of the 38th parallel dividing line was confirmed and formulated to the superior authorities by Lincoln and others on August 11, the plan was devised earlier, around July 25.
- keywords
- 38th Parallel, Potsdam Conference, John Edwin Hull, George A. Lincoln, Dean Rusk
Reference
Allison, John M. 1973. Ambassador from the Prairie or Allison Wonderland. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Appleman, Roy E. 1961. United States Army in the Korean War: South to the Naktong, North to the Yalu. Washington, DC: Department of the Army.
Barranco, Vicente F. 1984. Seoul Diary: Soviet Debacle in the Far East. Manila: Fernando Ma. Guerrero Memorial Foundation & University of Santo Tomas Press.
Beitzell, Robert, ed. and analytical introduction. 1970. Tehran, Yalta, Potsdam: The Soviet Protocols. Hattiesburg, MS: Academic International.
Cho, Soon Sung. 1967. Korea in World Politics, 1945-1950: An Evaluation of American Responsibility. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Cline, Ray S. 1951. United States Army in World War II: The War Department: Washington Command Post - The Operation Division. Washington, DC: Department of the Army.
Collins, Joseph Lawton. 1969. War in Peacetime: The History and Lessons of Korea. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Dobbs, Charles M. 1981. The Unwanted Symbol: American Foreign Policy, the Cold War, and Korea, 1945-1950. Kent, OH: The Kent State Press.
Feis, Herbert. 1953. China Tangle: The American Effort in China from Pearl Harbor to the Marshall Mission. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Gromyko, Andrey Andreyevich, ed. 1979. Krymskaya konferentsiya rukovoditeley tryekh soyuznykh derzhav – SSSR, SShA i Velikobritanii, 4-11 fevralya, 1945 g.: Sbornik dokumentov [Crimean Conference of the leaders of the three Allied powers – USSR, USA and UK, 4-11 February 1945: A collection of documents]. Moscow: Publishing House of Political Literature.
Gromyko, Andrey Andreyevich, ed. 1980. Berlinskaya (Potsdamskaya) konferentsiya rukovoditeley tryekh soyuznykh derzhav – SSSR, SShA i Velikobritanii: 17 iyulya – 2 avgusta, 1945 g.: Sbornik dokumentov [Berlin (Potsdam) Conference of the leaders of the three allied powers – USSR, USA and UK: July 17 - August 2, 1945: A collection of documents]. Moscow: Publishing House of Political Literature.
Gu, Daeyeol. 1995. Haebang gwa bundan. Vol. 2 of Hanguk gukje gwangyesa yeongu. Seoul: Yeoksa Bipyeongsa.
Gu, Yeongnok and Bae, Yeongsu. 1982. Han-Mi gwangye, 1882-1982 [Korea-U.S. relations, 1882-1982]. Seoul: Seoul National University Institute of American Studies.
Institute of Oriental Studies, Soviet Academy of Sciences, ed. (1974) 1990. Hanguk tongsa [A History of Korea]. Vol. 2. Translated by Yi, Yonggwon et al. Seoul: Daeya. Originally published in Russian as Istoriya Koryei. Moscow: Nauka.
Karig, Walter, Malcom W. Cagle, and Frank A. Manson. 1952. Battle Report, the War in Korea. New York: Rinehart.
Kim, Hakjun. 2008. Gangdaeguk jeongchi arae seoui Habando bunhal gwa Soryeon ui Bukhan gunjeong gaesi: 1863 nyeon-1941 nyeon 1 wol. Vol. 1 of Bukhan ui yeoksa. Seoul: Seoul National University Press.
Kim, Gijo. 1993. “Hanbando (38 seon) bunhal gwajeong ui jaejomyeong.” Part 2. Oegyo 27 (September): 99-112.
Kim, Gijo. 1994. 38 seon bunhal ui yeoksa: Mi-So-Il gan ui jeollyak daegyeol gwa jeonsi oegyo bisa 1941-1945. Seoul: Dongsan Publishing Co.
Kim, Gijo. 2006. Hanbando 38 seon bunhal ui yeoksa: Ilje 15 nyeon jeonjaeng jeongjeollyak gwa Mi-So oegyo jeollyak bisa (1931-1945). Paju: Hanguk Haksul Jeongbo.
Kodzaxmet-uli, K. (Kozhakhmet-uly, K.), et al. 2004. Vsemirnaya istoriya (1945-2002) [World history (1945-2002)]. Almaty: Mektep.
Lee, Wan Bom. 2001. 38 seon heokjeong ui jinsil [America’s 38th Parallel Decision in Korea, 1944-1945]. Seoul: Jisik Saneopsa.
Lee, Wan Bom. 2002. “Hanbando bunhal ui gukje jeongchihak: 19 segi mal-20 segi cho yeolgang ganui nonui reul jungsim euro.” Gukje Jeongchi Nonchong 42 (4): 191-215.
Lee, Wan Bom. 2005. “Teurumeon gwa Dongbuga naengjeon: Miguk ui wonpok silheom seonggong e ttareun Soryeon ui daeiljeon chamjeon baeje gusang, 1945 nyeon 4 wol-1945 nyeon 8 wol” [Truman and the Cold War in the Northeast Asia: The U.S. War Ending Plan with the A-Bomb in the Summer of 1945]. Miguksa Yeongu 21 (May): 69-103.
Library of Congress Legislative Service, ed. 1950. Korea: Origins of the Dividing Line at the 38th Parallel. June 29. Washington, DC: Library of Congress Legislative Service.
Matray, James Irving. 1981. “Captive of the Cold War: The Decision to Divide Korea at the 38th Parallel.” Pacific Historical Review 50 (2): 145-68.
Matray, James Irving. 1985. The Reluctant Crusade: American Foreign Policy in Korea, 1941-1950. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press.
Mee, Charles L. Jr. 1975. Meeting at Potsdam. New York: M. Evans.
Morales, Marianne Krause, Manuel Lara Garcia and Antonio Rodriguez Baixeras. 2008. Ciencias sociales, geografía e historia. Madrid, Spain: Edelvives.
Mun, Myeongja. 1999. Naega bon Bak Jeonghui wa Gim Daejung: Washington eseo beoreojin ildeul. Seoul: Mal.
Oh, Chunggeun. 1988. “Hanbando reul dulleo ssan Mi-So gwangye.” In Vol. 1 of Hanguk hyeondaesa yeongu, edited and translated by Kim, Dongchun, 300-04. Seoul: Iseong gwa Hyeonsil.
Pak, Gilyon (Bak Gillyong) and Kim, Gukhu. 1994. Kim Ilseong oegyo bisa: Sahu e balkyeojin Kim Ilseong ui oegyo jeollyak [The Secret of Kim Il Sung’s Diplomacy: Kim Il Sung’s Diplomatic Strategy Discovered after His Death]. Seoul: Joong-Ang Ilbo.
Ree, Erik Van. 1989. Socialism in One Zone: Stalin’s Policy in Korea, 1945-1947. Oxford: Berg.
Sandusky, Michael C. 1983. America’s Parallel. Alexandria, VA: Old Dominion.
Schnabel, James F. 1972. United States Army in the Korean War: Policy and Direction, The First Year. Washington, DC: United States Army.
Schnabel, James and Robert J. Watson. 1978. The History of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and National Policy. Vol. 3, pt. 1. Translated by Gukbang Jeonsa Pyeonchan Wiwonhoe (Department of Defense Military History Compilation Committee) as Hanguk Jeonjaeng. Vol. 1 (Seoul: Gukbang Jeonsa Pyeonchan Wiwonhoe, 1990).
Seong, Hwangyong. 1992. Geundae dongyang oegyosa. Seoul: Myeongjisa.
Shin, Yong-ha (Sin, Yongha). 1988. “Hanguk nambuk bundan ui wonin gwa Pocheudam miryakseol.” In Haebang jikhu ui minjokmunje wa sahoe undong, 11-12. Hanguk sahoesa yeonguhoe nonmunjip 13. Seoul: Munhak gwa Jiseongsa.
Shin, Yong-ha (Sin, Yongha). 2004. “Yeolgang ui Hanguk nambuk bundan mit sintak tongchi jeongchaek gwa Baekbeom Gim Gu ui noseon.” Paper presented at Symposium in Commemoration of the 2nd Anniversary of Kim Koo Museum and Library, Gwangbok jikhu ui Geonguk undong gwa Baekbeom Gim Gu. Seoul, Korea, October 1.
Slusser, Robert M. 1977. “Soviet Far Eastern Policy, 1941-1950: Stalin’s Goals in Korea.” In The Origins of the Cold War in Asia, edited by Yonosuke Nagai and Akira Iriye, 123-46. New York: Columbia University Press.
Soviet Union Ministry of Foreign Affairs, ed. 1984. Sovetskiy Soyuz na Mezhdunarodnykh Konferentsiyakh Perioda Velikoy Otechestvennoy Voyny, 1941-1945 [International conferences participated by the Soviet Union 1941-1945]. Moscow: Politicheskaya Literatura.
Stueck, William. 2002. Rethinking the Korean War: A New Diplomatic and Strategic History. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Tegeran Yalte Potsdam: Sbornik dokumentov [Tehran Yalta Potsdam: A collection of documents]. 1967. Moscow: Publishing House of “International Relations.”
Tegeran Yalte Potsdam: Sbornik dokumentov [Tehran Yalta Potsdam: A collection of documents]. 1970. 2nd amplified ed. Moscow: Publishing House of “International Relations.”
Tehran, Yalta and Potsdam Conferences: Documents. 1969. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
Teukbyeol chwijaeban, Joong-Ang Ilbo [Joong-Ang Ilbo’s Special Investigative Bureau]. 1994. Birok: Joseon minjujuui inmin gonghwaguk. Seoul: Joong-Ang Ilbo.
Tongilbu (Ministry of Unification). 1999. Tongilbu 30 nyeon sa: Pyeonghwa, hwahae hyeomnyeok ui baljachwi, 1969-1999 [The 30 Years History of Ministry of Unification]. Seoul: Ministry of Unification.
Torkunov, Anatoly V., Valeriy I. Denisov, and Vladimir F. Li. 2008. Koreyskiy poluostrov: Metamorfozy poslevoennoy istorii [Korean Peninsula: Metamorphosis of the postwar history]. Moscow: Olma Media Grupp.
Trigubenko, Marina E. (1985) 1988. “Joseon ui bundan sanghwang eseoui inmin minjujuui hyeongmyeong ui seonggyeok” [Characteristic of people’s democratic revolution in divided Korea]. In Bukhan ui jeongchi gyeongjae, translated by Gukto Tongirwon (The Board of National Unification). Seoul: Gukto Tongirwon. Originally published in Russian by Institute of World Communism and Economy, Soviet Academy of Sciences as Democratic People’s Republic of Korea. Moscow: Nauka.
Truman, Harry S. 1955. Memoirs by Harry S. Truman. Vol. 1, Year of Decisions, 1945. New York: Doubleday.
Truman, Harry S. 1956. Memoirs by Harry S. Truman. Vol. 2, Years of Trial and Hope, 1946-1952. New York: Doubleday.
U.S. Army Center of Military History, ed. 1949-52. RG 319, Entry 145: OCMH, 2-3.7A BA2, USACMH Manus. File South to the Naktong, North to the Yalu.
U.S. Department of Defense, ed. 1945a. Foreign Relations of the United States: Diplomatic Papers, 1945. Vol. II, The Conference of Berlin. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
U.S. Department of Defense, ed. 1945b. Foreign Relations of the United States: Diplomatic Papers, 1945. Vol. VI, The British Commonwealth, the Far East. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
U.S. Department of Defense, ed. 1945c. Foreign Relations of the United States: Diplomatic Papers, 1945. Vol. VII, The Far East, China. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
U.S. Department of Defense, ed. 1948. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1948. Vol. VI, The Far East and Australasia. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
U.S. Department of Defense, ed. 1955. The Entry of the Soviet Union into the War Against Japan: Military Plans, 1941-1945, Manuscript. Washington, DC: Department of Defense.
Vanin, Yuri et al. 1999. Reosia ui Hanguk yeongu: Hanguk insik ui yeoksajeok baljeon gwa hyeonjaejeok gujo [Russia’s research on Korea: Historical development in recognition of Korea and current Stage]. Translated by Gi Gwangseo. Seoul: Pulbit.
Weathersby, Kathryn. 1990. “Soviet Policy Toward Korea, 1944-1946.” PhD diss., Indiana University.
Weathersby, Kathryn. 1993. “Soviet Aims in Korea and the Origins of the Korean War, 1945-1950: New Evidence from Russian Archives.” Cold War International History Project Working Paper No. 8. Washington, DC: Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars. http://www.wilsoncenter.org/sites/default/files/Working_Paper_8.pdf
Whelan, Richard. 1990. Drawing the Line: The Korean War, 1950-1953. Boston: Little Brown.
Yi, Gyutae 李圭泰. 1997. Beiso no chōsen senryō seisaku to nanboku bundan taisei no keisei katei: Kaihō to futatsu no seiken no sōkoku. 米ソの 朝鮮占領政策と 南北分斷體制の 形成過程: ‘解放’と ‘二つの 政權’の 相克. Tokyo: Shinzansha Shuppan.
Yi, Yonghui. 1965. “Sampalseon hoekjeong singo: Soryeon daeil chamjeonsa e yeonhayeo.” Asea Hakbo 1 (December): 409-63.
Yi, Yonghui. 1983. “38 seon hoekjeong singo.” In Bundan jeonhu ui hyeondaesa, edited by Irwol Seogak, 228-29. Irwol Chongseo 14. Seoul: Irwol Seogak.
Yi, Yonghui. 1987. Hanguk gwa gukje jeongchi. Yi Yonghui jeojakjip I. Seoul: Mineumsa.
Zhukov, Georgiy K. and Nikolay F. Zabrodin. 1945. “Korea, Short Report.” Archive of the Foreign Policy of the Russian Federation, Fond 0430, Opis 2, Delo 18, Papka 5, 1, (June 29): 18-30.
- Downloaded
- Viewed
- 0KCI Citations
- 0WOS Citations