바로가기메뉴

본문 바로가기 주메뉴 바로가기

The Review of Korean Studies

“Antagonistic Unity”: Kim Oseong, Dialectical Anthropology, and the Discovery of Literature, 1929-1938

The Review of Korean Studies / The Review of Korean Studies, (P)1229-0076; (E)2773-9351
2013, v.16 no.2, pp.81-124
https://doi.org/10.25024/review.2013.16.2.004
I Jonathan Kief (Columbia University)
  • Downloaded
  • Viewed

Abstract

This paper offers an alternative perspective on the well-known “humanism” debates of the mid-1930s by focusing on the early writings of Kim Oseong 金午星 and their changing vision of disciplinary relations. First, I show how the basic content of Kim’s “humanism” (hyumeonijeum)—that is, his vision of both human life and human nature as internally dialectical—emerged in a series of early 1930s articles published in the Cheondogyo New Faction journal, Sin Ingan (New Human). Second, I trace how Kim’s ideas shifted in tandem with broader developments in the New Faction, emphasizing his changing vision of the relationship between philosophy, science, and religion. Third, I demonstrate how Kim pivoted in the year 1936 by “converting” to literature, entering the literary field, dispatching with Cheondogyo terminology, and taking up the term “humanism.” Fourth, using fictional and critical texts by An Hamgwang, Im Hwa, Han Seolya, Yi Giyeong, Song Yeong, and Han Intaek, I suggest that Kim’s relationship to literature should be understood within the context of both contemporary debates about Socialist Realism and the emergence of self-reflexive tropes in novels about novelists written by former members of the Korean Artists Proletarian Federation (KAPF) and their associates.

keywords
Kim Oseong, Cheondogyo New Faction, Sin Ingan, humanism, KAPF

Reference

1.

An, Hamgwang. 1936. “Changjak bangbeop nonui ui baljeon gwajeong gwa geu jeonmang” 창작방법 논의의 발전과정과 그 전망 [The process of development and (future) prospects of the creative method debate]. Chosun Ilbo, May 30-31, June 2-9.

2.

Baek, Cheol. 1975. Munhak jaseojeon: Jilli wa hyeonsil 문학 자서전: 진리와 현실 [Literary biography: Truth and reality]. Vol. 1. Seoul: Bagyeongsa.

3.

Baek, Cheol. 1983. “Nae ga mannan gongsanjuuijadeul: Jeonsin ui insaeng gwa Kim Oseong” 내가 만난 공산주의자들: 전신의 인생과 김오성 [The communists that I have met: Kim Oseong and a life of transformation]. Bukhan 139: 198-202.

4.

Bak, Chiu. 2010. Sasang gwa hyeonsil: Bak Chiu jeonjip 사상과 현실: 박치우 전집 [Thought and reality: The collected works of Bak Chiu]. Edited by Yun Daeseok and Yun Miran. Seoul: Inha Daehakgyo Chulpanbu.

5.

Cha, Seunggi. 1991. “1930 nyeondae changjak bangbeop nonjaeng gochal: Peurolletaria munhangnon ui jeongae yangsang eul jungsim euro” 1930년대 창작방법 논쟁 고찰: 프롤레타리아 문학론의 전개양상을 중심으로 [A consideration of the 1930s creative method debate: Focusing on the development of the theory of proletarian literature]. MA diss., Dankook University.

6.

Cheongnyeondang Donggyeongbu, ed. (1930) 1993. “Joseon minjung uige” 조선 민중의게 [To the Korean masses]. Hanguk Hakbo 19 (1): 1239-40.

7.

Choe, Wonsik. 2012. Munhak 문학 [Literature]. Seoul: Sohwa

8.

Donga Ilbo. 1930. “Jae-Donggyeong Cheondogyo cheongnyeondangwon geomgeo” 재동경 천도교 청년당원 검거 [Tokyo-based members of Cheondogyo Young Men’s Party detained]. November 24.

9.

Go, Bongjun. 2008. “1930 nyeondae bipyeongjang gwa hyumeonijeum: Kim Oseong ui neo hyumeonijeumnon eul jungsim euro” 1930년대 비평장과 휴머니즘: 김오성의 네오휴머니즘론을 중심으로 [Humanism and the 1930s critical sphere: Focusing on Kim Oseong’s theory of Neo-Humanism]. Hanguk Munhak Iron gwa Bipyeong 40:485-510.

10.

Günther, Hans. 2011. “Soviet Literary Criticism and the Formulation of the Aesthetics of Socialist Realism, 1932-1940.” In A History of Russian Literary Theory and Criticism: The Soviet Age and Beyond, edited by Evgeny Dobrenko and Galin Tihanov, 90-108. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.

11.

Han Intaek. 1936. “Haejik saryeong” 해직사령 [The dismissal order]. Sin Donga, February, 216-27.

12.

Han Intaek. 1937. “Haejik saryeong” 해직사령 [The dismissal order]. Sahae Gongnon, February, 164-77.

13.

Han Seolya. 1936. “Tongsok soseol e daehaya” 통속소설에 대하야 [On popular fiction]. Donga Ilbo, July 3-5, 7-8.

14.

Han Seolya. 1937a. “Joseon munhak ui sae banghyang” 조선문학의 새 방향 [Korean literature’s new direction]. Chosun Ilbo, January 1 (New Year’s Supplement 7), January 5, 7-8.

15.

Han Seolya. 1937b. “Gigyojuui ui geomto” 기교주의의 검토 [On mannerism]. Chosun Ilbo, February 4-7, 9.

16.

Hangukhak Jaryowon, ed. 2005. Joseon munhakga dongmaeng chongseo 조선문학가동맹 총서 [Compiled documents of the Korean Writers’ Alliance]. Vol. 3. Seoul: Hyeondae Munhwasa.

17.

Harootunian, Harry. 2000. Overcome by Modernity: History, Culture, and Community in Interwar Japan. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

18.

Heo, Su. 2011. Yi Donhwa yeongu 이돈화 연구 [Research on Yi Donhwa]. Seoul: Yeoksa Bipyeongsa.

19.

Hughes, Theodore. 2012. Literature and Film in Cold War South Korea: Freedom’s Frontier. New York: Columbia University Press.

20.

Hwang, Jong-yeon (Hwang Jong-yon), ed. 2013. Munhak gwa gwahak 문학과 과학 [Literature and science]. Vol. 1. Seoul: Somyeong.

21.

Im, Gyuchan, and Han Gihyeong, eds. 1990. Kapeu haesan hu ui munye donghyang 카프 해산 후의 문예 동향 [The cultural trajectory following the dissolution of KAPF]. Seoul: Taehaksa.

22.

Im Hwa. 1936a. “Widaehan nangmanjeok jeongsin: I rosseo jagi reul gwancheolhara!” 위대한 낭만적 정신: 이로써 자기를 관철하라! [The mighty romantic spirit: Achieve your (proper) self through this!]. Donga Ilbo, January 1 (New Year’s Supplement 7), January 3 (New Year’s Supplement 1), January 4 (New Year’s Supplement 2).

23.

Im Hwa. 1936b. “Munhak ui bigyujeongseong ui munje: Muironjuui ui il bipan” 문학의 비규정성의 문제: 무이론주의의 일 비판 [The indeterminacy of literature: A critique of theorylessness]. Donga Ilbo, January 28-February 2, February 4.

24.

Jeong, Changhyeon. 1997. “Sinmiri Aeguk Yeolsareung” 신미리 애국열사릉 [The Sinmiri National Patriots’ Tomb]. Tongil Gyeongje 33:97-101.

25.

Jeong, Huimo. 1999. “1930 nyeondae changjak bangbeop nonjaeng gwa kapeu munhak ui mihak” 1930년대 창작방법 논쟁과 카프문학의 미학 [The 1930s creative method debates and KAPF literature’s aesthetics]. Bipyeong Munhak 13:401-21.

26.

Jeong, Jinseok. 2010. “Gwangbok jikhu eollon eul jangakhan jwapa sinmun gwa jwaik gijadeul” 광복 직후 언론을 장악한 좌파 신문과 좌익 기자들 [The leftist newspapers and reporters who dominated the immediate post-Liberation press]. Sinmun gwa Bangsong, May, 98-105.

27.

Jeong, Yongseo. 1999. “Iljeha Cheondogyo cheongnyeondang ui undong noseon gwa jeongchi sasang” 일제하 천도교 청년당의 운동노선과 정치사상 [The political thought and movement trajectory of the Cheondogyo Young Men’s Party during the Japanese colonial period]. Hanguksa Yeongu 105:229-72.

28.

Jeong, Yongseo. 2010. “Iljeha haebanghu Cheondogyo seryeok ui jeongchi undong, 1905-1948” 일제하 해방후 천도교세력의 정치운동, 1905-1948 [The political movements of Cheondogyo, 1905-1948]. PhD diss., Yonsei University.

29.

Jo, Gyutae. 2000. “Cheondogyo Cheongnyeondang Donggyeongbu gigwanji Donghak ji Gwang” 천도교청년당 동경부 기관지 ‘동학지광’ [The official organ of the Cheondogyo Young Men’s Party in Tokyo, Light of Donghak]. Hanguk Minjok Undongsa Yeongu 25:379-88.

30.

Jo, Gyutae. 2006. “Cheondogyo sinpa ui jachi undong gwa Joseon nongminsa ui Keureseutintereun gaip hwaldong” 천도교 신파의 자치운동과 조선농민사의 크레스틴테른 가입 활동 [The Cheondogyo New Faction’s self-rule movement and the Peasant Society’s attempt to join the Krestintern]. Hanguk Minjok Undongsa Yeongu 48:123-59.

31.

Jo, Namhyeon. 2012. Hanguk hyeondae soseolsa 한국 현대 소설사 [A history of modern Korean literature]. Vol. 2. Seoul: Munhak gwa Jiseongsa.

32.

Jogwang. 1937. “Ilgi seolmun” 일기 설문 [Diary questionnaire]. May, 221-23.

33.

Kim Dongsik. 2008. “1930 nyeondae bipyeonggwa juche ui susahak: Im Hwa, Choe Jaeseo, Kim Girim ui bipyeong eul jungsim euro” 1930년대 비평과 주체의 수사학: 임화ㆍ최재서ㆍ김기림의 비평을 중심으로 [1930s criticism and the rhetoric of the subject: The criticism of Im Hwa, Choe Jaeseo, and Kim Girim]. Hanguk Hyeondae Munhak Yeongu 24: 167-211.

34.

Kim, Cheol. 1995. “Geundaejeok juche ui hyeongseong gwa gwallyeon hayeo: Yi Gwangsu wa Baek Cheol ui gyeongu” 근대적 주체의 형성과 관련하여: 이광수와 백철의 경우 [On the formation of the modern subject: The cases of Yi Gwangsu and Baek Cheol]. Minjok Munhaksa Yeongu 8 (1): 6-24.

35.

Kim, Gwang-un. 2003. Bukhan jeongchisa yeongu: Geondang, geonguk, geongun ui yeoksa 북한 정치사 연구: 건당, 건국, 건군의 역사 [Research on North Korean political history: The history of the foundation of the party, state, and military]. Seoul: Seonin.

36.

Kim, Hang. 2009. “Uri-nae-jonjae (In-dem-Uri-sein) raneun cheolhakjeok jeonhoe: Bak Jonghong gwa Haidegeo” 우리-내-존재 In-dem-Uri-sein라는 철학적 전회: 박종홍과 하이데거 [The philosophical turn to “In-dem-Uri-sein”: Pak Jonghong and Heidegger]. Minjok Munhwa Yeongu 50:183-227.

37.

Kim, Indeok and Seong Juhyeon, eds. 2012. Munheon euro boneun Ilje gangjeomgi jaeil Korian yeoksa wa munhwa 문헌으로 보는 일제 강점기 재일 코리안 역사와 문화 [The history and culture of Koreans in Japan during the colonial period as seen through documents]. Vol. 2. Seoul: Seonin.

38.

Kim, Jaehyeon. 2002. “Geundaejeok hangmun chegye ui seongnip gwa seoyang cheolhak suyong ui teukjing” 근대적 학문체계의 성립과 서양철학 수용의 특징 [The formation of the modern philosophical system and the characteristics of the reception of Western philosophy]. Hanguk Munhwa Yeongu 3:113-38.

39.

Kim, Jeonghyeon. 2008. “1930 nyeondae Niche sasang ui Hangukjeok suyong: Kim Hyeongjun ui Niche haeseok eul jungsim euro” 1930년대 니체사상의 한국적 수용: 김형준의 니체해석을 중심으로 [The 1930s Korean reception of Nietzsche’s thought: Focusing on Kim Hyeongjun’s interpretation of Nietzsche]. Niche Yeongu 14:245-79.

40.

Kim, Jeong-in. 2009. Cheondogyo geundae minjok undong yeongu 천도교 근대 민족운동 연구 [Research on Cheondogyo’s modern national movement]. Paju: Hanul.

41.

Kim, Oseong (Kim Hyeongjun). 1931. “Sajosang euro bon Suunjuui ui jiwi” 사조상으로 본 수운주의의 지위 [The place of Suunism as seen through trends of thought]. Cheondogyohoe Wolbo, February, 10-13, 37; March, 4-7.

42.

Kim, Oseong (Hyeongjun). 1932a. “Sin Ingan eun dasi naonda” 신인간은 다시 나온다 [Sin Ingan returns]. Sin Ingan, May, 1.

43.

Kim, Oseong (Kim Hyeongjun). 1932b. “Sin ingan ui sajeok jiwi” 신인간의 사적 지위 [The historical place of the new human]. Sin Ingan, June, 6-9; July, 8-10; August, 12-17.

44.

Kim, Oseong (Kim Hyeongjun). 1932c. “Ingan ui bonjil gujo” 인간의 본질 구조 [The essential structure of the human]. Sin Ingan, June, 6-9; July, 8-10; August, 12-17.

45.

Kim, Oseong (Kim Hyeongjun). 1932d. “Changsaenggeup ui jojik hullyeon e maejinhaja” 창생급의 조직 훈련에 매진하자 [Let’s push onward with the organizational training of the people]. Sin Ingan, November, 1-4.

46.

Kim, Oseong (Oseong; Kim Hyeongjun). 1933a. “Munhwa ui sidaejeok teukjing” 문화의 시대적 특징 [Culture’s period-specific characteristics]. Sin Ingan, July, 17-20; August, 22-25; September, 25-29.

47.

Kim, Oseong (Oseong; Kim Hyeongjun). 1933b. “Hyeondae wa cheolhak ui jungyoseong” 현대와 철학의 중요성 [The contemporary age and the importance of philosophy]. Sin Ingan, July, 17-20; August, 22-25; September, 25-29.

48.

Kim, Oseong (Kim Hyeongjun). 1934a. “Ingan haeseoksajeok euro bon ingan bonwi undong” 인간 해석사적으로 본 인간 본위 운동 [The movement (to establish) the proper place of the human as seen through the history of interpretations of the human]. Sin Ingan, January, 35-38; February, 24-25; March, 17-19; April, 18-20, 33.

49.

Kim, Oseong (Kim Hyeongjun). 1934b. “Suunjuuija ui inganjeok taedo” 수운주의자의 인간적 태도 [The Suunist’s human stance]. Sin Ingan, May, 7-12; June, 4-8; July, 8-11; August, 9-12; September, 7-10.

50.

Kim, Oseong (Oseong). 1935a. “Sinang gwa cheheom” 신앙과 체험 [Faith and experience]. Sin Ingan, February, 18-23.

51.

Kim, Oseong (Kim Hyeongjun). 1935b. “Ingan ui neungdongseong munje” 인간의 능동성 문제 [The problem of human activeness]. Sin Ingan, April, 10-15.

52.

Kim, Oseong (Oseong). 1935c. “Sinang gwa jikgwan” 신앙과 직관 [Faith and intuition]. Sin Ingan, April, 16-19; May, 22-25.

53.

Kim, Oseong (Kim Hyeongjun). 1935-36a. “Neungdongjeok ingangwan” 능동적 인간관 [An active vision of the human]. Sin Ingan, November, 18-21; December, 16-19; January, 45-48; February, 30-32; March, 28-30; April, 28-30.

54.

Kim, Oseong (Kim Hyeongjun). 1935-36b. “In-nae-cheon e uihan ingan haeseok” 인내천에 의한 인간 해석 [An interpretation of the human based upon ‘the human is heaven’]. Sin Ingan, November, 18-21; December, 16-19; January, 45-48; February, 30-32; March, 28-30; April, 28-30.

55.

Kim, Oseong (Kim Hyeongjun). 1935-36c. “Uju e daehan ingan ui jiwi” 우주에 대한 인간의 지위 [The place of the human in relation to the cosmos]. Sin Ingan, November, 18-21; December, 16-19; January, 45-48; February, 30-32; March, 28-30; April, 28-30.

56.

Kim, Oseong (Kim Hyeongjun). 1936a. “Cheongnyeon dou ege deurim” 청년 도우에게 드림 [To my young fellow believers]. Sin Ingan, February, 16-19.

57.

Kim, Oseong (Kim Dongjun). 1936b. “Jeonsegyejeok euro daedudoeneun inganjuuijeok sajo” 전세계적으로 대두되는 인간주의적 사조 [The humanist trend (now) emerging globally]. Sin Ingan, February, 43-46.

58.

Kim, Oseong. 1936c. “Neungdongjeok ingan ui tamgu” 능동적 인간의 탐구 [In pursuit of an active human: The intersection between literature and philosophy]. Chosun Ilbo, February 23, 25-29.

59.

Kim, Oseong (Hyeongjun). 1936d. “Inganjuui ui pilyeonseong” 인간주의의 필연성 [The need for humanism]. Sin Ingan, June, 21-24.

60.

Kim, Oseong (Oseong saeng). 1936e. “I sidae ui geongang sul” 이 시대의 건강술 [A means for health in this age]. Sin Ingan, August, 50-53.

61.

Kim, Oseong. 1936f. “Hyeondae munhak ui sin gungmyeon: Geu cheolhak gwa ui yeongwanseong e daehaya” 현대 문학의 신국면: 그 철학과의 연관성에 대하야 [Contemporary literature’s new position: On its connection with philosophy]. Chosun Ilbo, July 31-August 1; August 4-8.

62.

Kim, Oseong. 1937a. “Munhak e isseoseo yulli wa nolli” 문학에 잇서서 윤리와 논리 [Ethics and logic in literature]. Chosun Ilbo, September 19, 21-23.

63.

Kim, Oseong. 1937b. “Munhak e isseoseo ui yesulseong gwa sasangseong: Changjak gwa bipyeong ui hyeomnyeok eul wihaya” 문학에 잇서서의 예술성과 사상성: 창작과 비평의 협력을 위하야 [The artistic and the ideological in literature: For the collaboration of creation and criticism]. Donga Ilbo, October 24, 26-27, 29-30.

64.

Kim, Oseong. 1938. “Gamseong gwa jiseong: Jakga ui changjak ijeon ui taedo” 감성과 지성: 작가의 창작 이전의 태도 [Sensibility and intellect: The writer’s pre-creative stance]. Jogwang, January, 110-19.

65.

Kim, Oseong. (1946) 1974. Jidoja gunsang 지도자 군상 [Our group of leaders]. Reprinted in Namnodang yeongu jaryojip 남로당연구자료집 [South Korean Worker’s Party documentary research collection], vol.2, edited by Kim Namsik. Seoul: Goryeo Daehakgyo Chulpanbu.

66.

Kim, Yongdal. 1990. “Iljeha Yongcheon jibang ui nongmin undong e gwanhan yeongu” 일제하 용천 지방의 농민운동에 관한 연구 [Research on peasants movement in the Yongcheon region during the Japanese colonial period]. Bugaksaron 2:245-91.

67.

Kim, Yunsik. 2008. Baek Cheol yeongu: Han eopsi jiruhan geul sseugi, chameul su eopsi jogeuphan geul sseugi 백철 연구: 한없이 지루한 글쓰기, 참을 수 없이 조급한 글쓰기 [Research on Baek Cheol: Infinitely boring writing, uncontrollably hasty writing]. Seoul: Somyeong Chulpan.

68.

Kim, Yunsik. 2011. Im Hwa wa Sin Namcheol: Gyeongseong jedae wa sin munhaksa ui gwallyeon yangsang 임화와 신남철: 경성제대와 신문학사의 관련 양상 [Im Hwa and Sin Namcheol: Connections between Gyeongseong Imperial University and new literary history]. Seoul: Yeongnak.

69.

Malraux, André. 1936. “Our Cultural Heritage.” Left Review, July, 491-96.

70.

Park, Sunyoung. 2009. “Everyday Life as Critique in Late Colonial Korea: Kim Namcheon’s Literary Experiments, 1934-1943.” Journal of Asian Studies 68 (3): 861-93.

71.

Rucker, R.D. 1979. “Abram Moiseevič Deborin: Weltanschauung and Role in the Development of Soviet Philosophy.” Studies in Soviet Thought 19 (3): 185-207.

72.

Scheler, Max. 1958. Philosophical Perspectives. Translated by Oscar Haac. Boston: Beacon Press.

73.

Seo, Dongman. 2005. Bukjoseon sahoejuui cheje seongnipsa, 1945-1961 북조선 사회주의 체제 성립사, 1945-1961 [A history of the establishment of the North Korean socialist system, 1945-1961]. Seoul: Seonin.

74.

Seong, Juhyeon. 2009. “Cheondogyo Cheongnyeondang (1923-1939) yeongu” 천도교 청년당 (1923-1939) 연구 [Research on the Cheondogyo Young Men’s Party (1923-1939)]. PhD diss., Hanyang University.

75.

Sim, Jiyeon. 1991. Inmindang yeongu 인민당 연구 [Research on the People’s Party]. Seoul: Gyeongnam Daehakkyo Geukdong Munje Yeonguso.

76.

Sin, Ilcheol, ed. [1935] 1972. Jasu daehak gangui 자수대학 강의 [Self-study university lectures]. Compiled edition. Seoul: Gyeongin Munhwasa.

77.

Sin, Jaegi. 1998. “Kim Oseong bipyeong ui geundaeseong bipan yeongu: Geu ui neo hyumeonijeumnon eul jungsim euro” 金午星 비평의 근대성 비판 연구: 그의 네오 휴머니즘론을 중심으로 [Research on the critique of modernity in Kim Oseong’s criticism: Focusing on his theory of Neo-Humanism]. Eomunhak 62:267-83.

78.

Son, Jeongsu. 2002. Gaenyeomsa roseoui Hanguk geundae bipyeongsa 개념사로서의 한국 근대 비평사 [A conceptual history of modern Korean criticism]. Seoul: Yeongnak.

79.

Song Yeong. 1936. “Abeoji” 아버지 [Father]. Joong Ang, March, 271-83.

80.

Townsend, Susan. 2009. Miki Kiyoshi, 1897-1945: Japan’s Itinerant Philosopher. Boston: Brill.

81.

Wang, Sin-yeong. 2004. “1935 nyeon jeonhu ui ‘haengdongjuui’ nonjaeng: jechangja Komasseu Kiyosi ui ipjang eseo” 1935년 전후의 ‘행동주의’ 논쟁: 제창자 고마쓰 기요시(小松 淸)의 입장에서 [The ‘activism’ debate in the years around 1935: From the perspective of its originator, Komatsu Kiyoshi]. Bigyo Munhak 32: 101-26.

82.

Weston, Thomas. 2008. “The Concept of Non-Antagonistic Contradiction in Soviet Philosophy.” Science and Society 72 (4): 427-54.

83.

Workman, Travis. 2013. “Sŏ In-sik’s Communism and the East Asian Community (1937-40).” Positions: East Asia Cultures Critique 21 (1): 133-60.

84.

Yi, Byeongsu. 2006. “1930 nyeondae seoyang cheolhak suyong e natanan cheolhak 1-sedae ui cheolhakham ui teukjing gwa ironjeok yeonghyang” 1930년대 서양철학 수용에 나타난 철학 1세대의 철학함의 특징과 이론적 영향 [The philosophical characteristics and theoretical influence of the philosophical first generation’s 1930s reception of Western philosophy]. Sidae wa Cheolhak 17 (2): 81-112.

85.

Yi, Donhwa. (1931) 1968. Sinin cheolhak 신인철학 [Philosophy of the New Human]. Seoul: Cheondogyo Jungang Chongbu.

86.

Yi Giyeong. 1936a. “Myeongam ijungju” 명암 이중주 [The duet of light and dark]. Joong Ang, June, 98-105.

87.

Yi Giyeong. 1936b. “Munyejoek sigam” 문예적 시감 [Recent artistic reflections]. Pts. 2 and 3. Jogwang, August, 253-54.

88.

Yi Giyeong. 1937. “Don” 돈 [Money]. Jogwang, October, 166-81.

The Review of Korean Studies