China's Northeast Project and South Korean-Chinese Relations

The issue of China’s Northeast Project (NEP) is minor when juxtaposed against other important problems in Northeast Asia. However, this issue is more than a simple matter of historical interpretation. The NEP dispute between Korea and China involves many factors, including that of national sovereignty and the balance of power in Northeast Asia. Many Korean scholars insist that the NEP was just an effort to promote “historical hegemony” in a systematic and organized manner by the Chinese government. They believe that China is distorting the history of Goguryeo (Koguryo) in order to secure preemptive rights in the region in preparation for the collapse of North Korea. But, in order for this analysis to be justified, a comprehensive study should be undertaken to determine the role and intent of the Chinese central government regarding the NEP, and China’s policy towards Northeast Asia and the Korean peninsula. Through this analysis, we found sensitive differences between the historical distortions and the political and territorial intent of the NEP. Though the political implications of the NEP have been amplified beyond objective facts, it is hard to deny that China has begun adjusting to the existing realities in the Korean peninsula through the NEP. Therefore, if the two countries do not enter into a conflict, they will be able to seek a rational solution to the issues that have arisen and an amicable relationship can be developed between them. First of all, it is necessary to establish a scholarly basis for a foreign policy that separates historical sovereignty from territorial sovereignty. Another solution is to spread and deepen the Korean-Chinese historical discourse. If handled well, the relationship will develop in a positive way. If the relationship is handled poorly, there will be unpleasant political and strategic ramifications.

keywords: Northeast project, South Korean-Chinese relations, Goguryeo history, Gando problem, historical sovereignty

Reference

(2003January) China’s Influence Is Limited, International Herald Tribune

(2004August) Seeking Peace in a Once and Future Kingdom, The New York Times

(2002) Return of the Dragon: China's Wounded Nationalism, Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press

(2001) Taiwan-PRC Competition on Korean Peninsula,

(2004) Yatai anchuan xinlun (A New Analysis of Asia-Pacific Security), Beijing: Guoji Guangbo Chubanshe

(2004) Chaoxian Hewenti yu Dongbeiya Anchuan (The Korean Nuclear Crisis and Security Situation in Northeast Asia), Guoji Zhanlue yu Anchuanxingshi Pinggu (Strategic and Security Review 2003-2004), Beijing: Shishi Chubanshe

(2003) Gengzou, shijie, meiguo he zhongguo (The World, USA, and China), Beijing: Qinghua University Press

(2001) Hegemony on the Offensive: Chinese Perspectives on U.S. Global Strategy,

(2003) China’s New Diplomacy,

10.

(2003) An Emerging China’s Emerging Grand Strategy: A New-Bismarckian Turn In International Relations Theory and the Asia-Pacific, New York: Columbia University

11.

(2002) The Struggle Against Terrorism: Grand Strategy and the Tactics,

12.

(2004) Northeast Asia’s Pandora's Box: North Korean Escapees,

13.

(2004) Zhongguo hepingjueqi (Peaceful Rise of China), Beijing: Zhongguo Shehuikexue Chubanshe

14.

(2003) Chinese-North Korean Relations: Managing Asymmetrical Interdependence In North Korea and Northeast Asia, New York: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers

15.

(2004March) ‘Peaceful Rising’ Seeks to Ally ‘China Threat.’, Asia Times,

16.

(2004a) Jonggukeui sae-loun sahoejuyi tamsaek (The Search for China's New Socialism), Seoul: Changbi

17.

(2004b) The Meaning and Limits of China’s Constructive Role in the Korean Question,

18.

(2004c) Dongbuk gongjeong chujin hyeonhwang-gwa chujin gigu siltae (The Proceeding and Research Unit of the Northeast Project) In Jungguk-ui “dongbuk gongjeong,”geu silche-wa heoguseung (“China’s Northeast Project”: Its Substance and Fabrication), Seoul: Koguryo Research Foundation

19.

(2003) Dongbuga simin sahoe gyoryu-wa gongdongchejeok jiyeok tonghap (The Exchange of Civil Society and the Northeast Asian Community) In Dongbuga gongdongche-reul hyanghayeo (For the Northeast Asia Community), Seoul: Dong-A Ilbo Press

20.

(2002) Bukhan jungguk gwan-gye: 1945-2000 (North Korea-China Relations: 1945-2000), Seoul: Jungsim

21.

(2004) 21 shiji duiwai zhanluede xuanzhe (China's Foreign Strategy: A Choice in the Early Period of the 21st Century), Beijing: Shishi Chubanshe

22.

(2002) Zhongguo bianjiangshidi yanjiu zhongshu 1989-1998 (The Outline of China's Borderland History and Geography Study), Harbin: Heilongjiang Chubanshe

23.

(2003) Zhongguo dongbei bianjiang yanjiu (Study on the Northeast Borderland), Beijing: Zhongguo Shihuikexue Chubanshe

24.

(2000) Hegemony: China’s Plan to Dominate Asia And The World, San Francisco: Encounter Books

25.

(2004) Dongbei zuozheng (Regulation of the Northeast), Beijing: Dangdai Shijie Chubansh

26.

(2004) Zhongguo yu Yazhou: Guancha, Yanjiu, Pinglun (China and Asia: Progress, Problems, and Prospects), Shanghai: Shanghai Shihuikexue Chubanshe

27.

(2004) China’s Northeast Project: Launch of a History War?,

28.

(2003) Kaizhuan dongbei bianjiang wenti yanjiude Jigewenti” (Some Questions on the Unfolding of a Northeast Borderland) In Zhongguo dongbei bianjiang yanjiu (Study on Northeast Borderland), Beijing: Zhongguo Shihuikexue Chubanshe

29.

(2004) Bipolarity and Balancing in East Asia In Security Cooperation in East Asia, Beijing: Beijing University

30.

(2001) China and North Korea: The Close but Uncomfortable Relationship,

31.

(2004) Zhongguo jiujing zai nalii (Where the Hell Is China Going?), Shanghai: Xuelin Chubanshe

32.

(2001November) Diplomatic Rows Feared After Court Orders Revision of Ethnic Koreans Law, The Korea Times,

33.

(2003) Jungguk-ui dongbukgongjeong-ui heosil (The Truths and Falsities of The Northeast Project in China),

34.

(2003) Jungguk-ui hanguk godaesa ppaeatgi gongjak (Chinese Spade-work to Deprive Korea of Ancient History),

35.

(2004Aupust) China’s Nationalism Wraps Koguryo History, Korea Times,

36.

(2004) The Rise and Descent of ‘Peaceful Rise.’,

37.

(1992) The Origin of a Northeastern Ethnic Group Translated by Im Dong-seok,

38.

(2003) Interpreting China's Grand Strategy: Past, Present, and Future, Santa Monica, CA: Rand Corporation

39.

(2003) Suzao Zhongguode Lixiang Anquan Huanjing (Constructing China’s Ideal Security Environment), Beijing: Zhongguo Shehuikexue Chubanshe

40.

(1999) A Neutral Reunified Korea: A Chinese View,

41.

(2004) Zhongguowaijiao (Chinese diplomacy),

42.

(2003) Fault Line in China's Economic Terrain, Santa Monica, CA: Rand Corporation

43.

(2004) Why Has ‘Trust’ Become a Focal Issue in Sino-Japanese Relations,

44.

(2003) Zhongguo Dazhanlue (China's Grand Strategy), Beijing: Zhongguo Shehuikexue Chubanshe

45.

(2004September) Jigum gando munjae ggeo-nae-nun geoseun bujeokjeol (Bringing up the Issue of Gando Now Is Premature), JoongAng Ilbo

46.

(2005) China’s Northeast project and Korean History,

47.

(2001) The Territorial Integrity Norm: International Boundaries and The Use of Force,

48.

(2001) Power and Responsibility in Chinese Foreign Policy, Canberra: Asia Pacific Press

49.

(2001) China’s Stalled Fifth Wave: Zhu Rongji’s Reform Package of 1998-2000,

바로가기메뉴

Article Contents

Vol.45 No.2

China's Northeast Project and South Korean-Chinese Relations

Abstract

Reference

Korea Journal