바로가기메뉴

본문 바로가기 주메뉴 바로가기

logo

  • P-ISSN0023-3900
  • E-ISSN2733-9343
  • A&HCI, SCOPUS, KCI

Medical Policies toward Indigenous Medicine in Colonial Korea and India

Korea Journal / Korea Journal, (P)0023-3900; (E)2733-9343
2006, v.46 no.1, pp.198-224

Abstract

Both the British and Japan emphasized the superiority of Western medicine to indigenous in their colonies, India and Korea respectively, partly relying on the practice of indigenous medicine due to the lack of qualified doctors. The British and Japan, however, differed in acting medical law on indigenous practitioners and affected the sociopolitical space where the revivalist movements for indigenous medicine resulted from indigenous medical practitioners in India and the Japanese colonial government in Korea. It is worth noting that the two imperial powers politicized Western and indigenous medicine in similar fashion to legitimize their rules over the colonies.

keywords
indigenous medicine, imperialism, colonialism, medical policy, Western medicine, indigenous practitioner, doctor, revivalist movement, indigenous medicine, imperialism, colonialism, medical policy, Western medicine, indigenous practitioner, doctor, revivalist movement

Reference

1.

Arnold, (1986) Cholera and Colonialism in British India,

2.

(1988) Disease, Medicine and Empire, Medicine and Indigenous Societies Manchester and New York: Manchester University Press

3.

Colonizing the Body, (19931993) University of California Press,

4.

Amsterdam, (1994) Crisis and Contradiction in India's Public Health The History of Public Health and the Modern State,

5.

Bak, Ji-hyang, (2000) Jegukjuui (Imperialism), Seoul: Seoul National University Press

6.

Bak, Seop, (2001) Singminji-ui gyeongje byeondong (The Economic Change in Colony), Seoul: Moonji Publishing

7.

Bala, (1991) Imperialism and Medicine in Bengal, Sage Publications

8.

Bose, Sugata, (2004) Modern South Asia, New York and London: Routledge

9.

Brass, (1972) The Politics of Ayurvedic Education A Case Study of Revivalism and Modernization in India In Education and Politics in India Studies in Organization edited by Susanne Hoeber Rudolph, Harvard University Press

10.

(1913) Government-General in Korea,

11.

(1915) Government-General in Korea The Annual Report of Japanese Government-General,

12.

Cumings, Bruce, (1997) Koreas Place in the Sun: A Modern History, New York: W. W. Norton & Company

13.

Cumings, Bruce, (2002) The Origins of the Korean War, 4th rep, Yuk Sa Bi Byung Sa

14.

(1924) Dojinkai 同任會 The Twenty Years' History of Dojinkai,

15.

Duus, Peter, (1995) The Abacus and the Sword: The Japanese Penetration of Korea, 1895-1910, University of California Press

16.

Gann, L. H, (1996) Reflections on the Japanese and German Empires of World War Ⅱ, The Japanese Wartime Empire, 1931-1945, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press

17.

Gann, (19841895-1945) edited by Ramon H, Princeton Princeton University Press

18.

Harrison, (1994) Public Health in British India, Cambridge University Press

19.

Biswamoy Pati, (2001) Medicine and Orientalism. Health, Medicine and Empire, London: Sangam Books

20.

Hume, (19771849-1889) Western Medicine and Yuna-i Tibb in the Punjab Bulletin of the History of Medicine 51,

21.

Ministry of Welfare Hundred Years’ History of Medical System Ministry of Welfare,

22.

Jaggi, (1980) Impact on Indigenous Systems of Medicine In History of Science Technology and Medicine in India 15 Western Medicine in India,

23.

Jaggi, O. P, (2000) Medicine in India: Modern Period, Place: Oxford University Press

24.

Roger, (19821836) Policies towards Indigenous Healers in Independent India,

25.

Jeffery, (1988) The Politics of Health in India University of California,

26.

Jeffery, (19791918-1939) The Establishment of Medical Dependancy,

27.

Jo, Heonyeong, (1997) Hanbanguihakui Wigireul Apdugo (Facing the Crisis of Korean Traditional Medicine), Hanuihak-ui bipan-gwa haeseol (The Critic and Explanation on Korean Traditional Medicine), Seoul: Sonamoo

28.

Kang, (1980) A History of Japanese Intrusion into Korea,

29.

Place-> Tokyo, (1965) The History of Medicine in Modern Japan,

30.

Kee, Changduk, (1995) Gundae uihak gyoyuksa (A History of Medical Education in Korea), Academia

31.

Modern Japan, (1992) Colonial Rule of British and Japanese,

32.

Kim, (1984) A Medical Mirror of Chenggang,

33.

Kumar, Deepak, (1997) Unequal Contenders, Uneven Ground: Medical Encounters in British India, 1820-1920, Western Medicine as Contested Knowledge, Manchester and New York: Manchester University

34.

Kurmar, Anil, (1998) Medicine and the Raj: British Medical Policy in India, 1835-1911, New Delhi: Sage Publication

35.

Lambert, Helen, (1997) Plural Traditions? Folk Therapeutics and English Medicine in Rajasthan, Western Medicine as Contested Knowledge, and New York: Manchester University

36.

Leslie, (1973) The Professionalizing Ideology of Medical Revivalism Enterpreneurship and Modernization of Occupational Cultures in South Asia, Duke University Press

37.

Poggie, (1974) The Modernization of Asian Medical Systems edited by John J, Greenwood Press

38.

Washington DC, (1975) Pluralism and Integration in the Indian and Chinese Medical Systems Medicine in Chinese Cultures Comparative Studies of Health Care in Chinese and Other Societies edited by Arthur Kleinman,

39.

Metcalf, (1985) Nationalist Muslims in British India The Case of Hakim Ajmal Khan,

40.

Nair, Sunitha B, (2001) Social History of Western Medical Practice in Travancore, Disease and Medicine in India, Deepak Kumar. New Delhi: Tulika Books

41.

Indigenous Medicine, (1921) The Administrative Sanitary Law in Korea Intellectuals and Social Consciousness in Colonial India,

42.

Park, Yunjae (Bak, Yun-jae), (2000) 1910nyeondae cho ilje-ui pest bangyeok hwaldong-gwa joseon jibae (The Preventive Activity of Pest and the Imperial Japans Ruling Power over Korea in the Early 1910s), Hankuksa-ui gujo-wa jeongae (The Structure and development of Korean History), Compilation Committee Commemorating the Sixth Birthday of Professor Ha Hyeon-gang. Seoul: Hyean

43.

(2005) Hanguk geundae uihak-ui giwon (The Origin of Korean Modern Medical System), Seoul: Hyean

44.

Quaiser, Neshat, (2001) Politics, Culture and Colonialism: Unanis Debate with Doctory, Medicine and Empire, London: Sangam Books

45.

Shin, Dongwon (Sin, Dong-won), (2003) chongdokbu-ui hanuihak jeongchaek (Traditional Medicine under Japanese Rule after 1930s),

46.

(1918) An Explanation on the Sanitation in Korea,

47.

Son, (1992) A Study on the History of Local and Autonomous System in Korea,

48.

Barbara Joan, (1984) The Ayurvedic Revivalist Movement in Early Twentieth-Century British India, Harvard University

49.

(1976) Akira 管谷章 The History of Medical System in Japan,

50.

Yi, (1977) A History of Korean Traditional Medicine 3 of Hanguk hyeondae munhwasa daegye An Outline of Cultural History in Modern Korea Institute of Korean Culture, Korea University

51.

Yun, Hae-dong, (2001) Munhwa jeongchi-ui silsang (A True Picture of Cultural Policy),

52.

Cumings, (199519971988199220002001198419962001199319881994) &fnote;* This work was supported by a Korean Research Foundation Grant For comparative studies on British and Japanese colonialism Gann wrote on Western and Japanese colonialism his works do not include a direct comparison between Britain and Japan,

53.

Arnold, (198619971910192320051973192120001993) Even when Britain and Japan displayed a positive attitude toward indigenous medicine it was not towards the process but rather the substance They recognized only the importance of indigenous drugs and emphasized their use ; A doctor in India published a description of Ayurvedic medicine in which he attributed the decline of Ayurvedic medicine to indigenous practitioners His identification of Ayurvedic medicine as a lost culture that was more open,

54.

Kee Changduk, (199819951914200519772001199819151918) The Annual Report of Japanese Government-General,

55.

Jo, (199519971997200119951980197719881913198019442000) Two sets of statistics accurately demonstrate the similar situation faced in the rural areas of both colonies Just before liberation from the British a committee appointed to inquire into the situation of Indian indigenous medicine concluded Indian medicine at present serves more than 80% of the population in rural area a year before Korea was liberated about 60% of death certificates in a province were issued by indigenous practitioners,

56.

Gann, (1984200219111913191319132005199520011997) Japan planned to enact a medical law just after annexation the practitioners complicated sphere of activities in Korea delayed the promulgation of the medical law Considering that the main purpose of the medical law was to draw a line clearly demarcating indigenous practitioners from qualified doctors it is reasonable to conclude that the complicated working forms of indigenous practitioners delayed Japans legislative capacity in this regard,

57.

; Leslie, (1984) the registration law in India did not embrace all regions of the subcontinent As this law was only enforced in one city the need still remained to set standards for indigenous practitioners Bulletin on Police,

58.

25th, (1982) Records of National Assembly of Korea,

59.

Paul R, (1995) After liberation from British rule political forces continued to play decisive roles in the formulation of medical policies on Indian systems of medicine Brass concludes that the revivalist movement has tended from the beginning to be strongly oriented toward politics Britain was going to hold onto key powers in the areas of finance and defense the India Act of 1935 brought all the provincial governments under the control of elected Indian ministers the Congress paid little attention to indigenous medicine in the beginning The practitioners of Western medicine demanded Indianization of the Indian Medical Service and creation of more openings for them an issue that was figured in every session of the Congress from 1893 to 1907 ; Budget allocations for the indigenous system of medicine never exceeded 13% of the total health budget and usually remained far below this figure,

60.

Kang, (1980) The indigenous practitioners in Gyeonggi-do province promised to send graduates to villages without doctors in order to persuade a Japanese official who was sympathetic to Eastern medicine to support their cause In 1939 Korean indigenous doctors established an association in an effort to revive indigenous medicine supporting the medical policy of the Japanese colonial government The association used Oriental as its name,

61.

Panikkar, K. N, (1995) Indigenous Medicine and Culture Hegemony. Culture, Ideology, Hegemony: Intellectuals and Social Consciousness in Colonial India, Tulika

Korea Journal