“How to Cross the Border ” of Historical Perceptions in the History Textbooks of Korea,China and Japan: “Liquidation ” of the Asia-Pacific War and Historical Reconciliation

신주백

doi:10.25024/kj.2008.48.3.133

P-ISSN0023-3900
E-ISSN2733-9343
A&HCI, SCOPUS, KCI

Home

OA Policy

ISSN : 0023-3900

Article Contents

Prev Next

e-Submission

Vol.48 No.3

Citation Share

“How to Cross the Border ” of Historical Perceptions in the History Textbooks of Korea,China and Japan: “Liquidation ” of the Asia-Pacific War and Historical Reconciliation

Korea Journal / Korea Journal, (P)0023-3900; (E)2733-9343

2008, v.48 no.3, pp.133-165

https://doi.org/10.25024/kj.2008.48.3.133

(2008). “How to Cross the Border ” of Historical Perceptions in the History Textbooks of Korea,China and Japan: “Liquidation ” of the Asia-Pacific War and Historical Reconciliation. Korea Journal, 48(3), 133-165, https://doi.org/10.25024/kj.2008.48.3.133

copy

Abstract

In their dealing with the Tokyo Trial, history textbooks of the five East Asian countries have exhibited their indifference to Asian identity, as can be seen from their description of historical facts specific to the region from nationalist viewpoints, which are a far cry from being a comprehensive and balanced his-toriography. While some Japanese history textbooks avoid dealing with the war responsibility of Japan, other four East Asian countries have failed to exactly frame and fairly present the facts. In a word, the history textbooks of East Asian countries, though they advocate globalization, have not delivered to students the conciliatory and cooperative frameworks that will help them realize the universal value of human beings. The ideas of reconciliation and cooperation presuppose the fact-finding of a historical past, whether or not they be acceptable or unfavorable to oneself. There should be efforts to fairly deliver historical facts to the generations to come, which will be a starting point for a dialogue between the historical text-books of East Asian countries.

keywords: history education, history textbook, “liquidation” of the past, Tokyo Trial, San Francisco Peace Treaty, war responsibility

Reference

Basic Education Curriculum Material Development Center, People’s Republic of China, comp, (2006) 義務敎育課程標準實驗敎科書世界歷史9年級下冊, People’s Education Press

Basic Education Curriculum Material Development Center, People’s Republic of China, comp, (2006) 全日制普通高級中學校敎科書世界近現代史下冊, People’s Education Press

Basic Education Curriculum Material Development Center, People’s Republic of China, comp, (2008) 普通高中課程標準實驗敎科書歷史必修上冊, People’s Education Press

Gomi, Humihoko, (2006) 新編新しい社會歷史, Tokyo Shoseki

Historical Department for Elementary and Middle Schools, Publication Team, comp, (2006) 義務敎育課程標準實驗敎科書世界歷史9年級下冊, Yuelu Publishing House

Huzioka Nobukazu, (2006) 改訂版新しい歷史敎科書, Fusosha

Hwang, Jae-gi, (2002) Sahoe II, Kyohaksa Publishing

Ishii, Susumu, (2007) 改訂版詳說日本史B, Yamakawa Shuppansha

Iwasaki, Hiroshi, (2007) 日本史, Daiichi Gakushusha

10.

Jo, Hwa-ryong, (2002) Sahoe II(Social Studies II).Seoul:Kumsung Publishing, Kumsung Publishing

11.

Kim, Eun-sook, (2004) Segyesa, Kyohaksa Publishing

12.

Kim, Gwang-nam, (2006) Hanguk geunhyeondaesa, Doosan Publishing

13.

Kim, Gwang-won, (1995) Segye ryeoksa, Education Book Publishing

14.

Kimura, Seiji, (2007) Yoseol segyesa A, Yamakawa Shuppansha

15.

Kong, Qizhu, comp, (2006) 義務敎育課程標準實驗敎科書世界歷史9年級下冊, Sichuan Jiaoyu Publishing

16.

Lee, Jin-suk, (2002) Sahoe II in : わたしたちの中學社會?歷史的分野, Jihaksa Publishing, Nihon Shoseki Shinsha

17.

Ministry of Education and Human Resources Development, Republic of Korea, (2000) Hanguk geunhyeondaesa,

18.

Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science, and Technology (MEXT), Japan, (2008) 中學校學習指導要領解說社會編, MEXT

19.

Ministry of Education, People’s Republic of China, (2001) 全日制義務敎育歷史課程標準(實驗稿), Beijing Normal University Press

20.

Ministry of Education, People’s Republic of China, (2003) 普通高中歷史課程標準(實驗), Beijing Normal University Press

21.

Miyahara, Takeo, (2007) 新訂版高校日本史A, Jikkyo Shuppan

22.

Mukaiyama, Hiroshi, (2007) 改訂版世界史A, Daiichi Gakushusha

23.

Murao Zirou, (2003) 最新日本史B, Meisesha

24.

Nakamuru, Tadasi, (2007) 新訂版世界史A, Jikkyo Shuppan

25.

Oh, Chang-hun, (2004) Segyesa, Jihaksa Publishing

26.

Oh, Geum-sung, (2004) Segyesa, Kumsung Publishing

27.

Ooyama, Kyouheii, (2008) 日本史B, Jikkyo Shuppan

28.

Sagara, Masatosi, (2007) 新選世界史B, Tokyo Shoseki

29.

Sasaki, Hiroshi, (2007) 新訂版日本史, Shimizu Shoin

30.

Sibata, Michio, (2008) 改訂版現代の世界史B, Yamakawa Shuppansha

31.

Sin, Ju-back, (2002) Nambukhan iljung daeman-ui yeoksa gyogwaseo sok-e pyohyeondoen jeonhu chaegim-gwa yeoksa gyoyuk,

32.

Sin, Ju-back, (2002) Dongasia geunhyeondaesa-eseo jeonjaeng-gwa pyeonghwa-e daehan gieok-ui chai, geurigo yeoksa gyoyuk,

33.

Sin, Ju-back, (2005) Ilbon junghakgyo yeoksa gyogwaseo 2005 nyeondo geomjeongbon bunseok?ilje gangjeomgi mit hyeondae hanil gwangyereul jungsim-euro,

34.

Sin, Ju-back, (2005) Hanguk-gwa ilbon-ui daeil gwageo cheongsan undong-ui yeoksa?hanguk-gwa gwallyeonhayeo, Yeoksa munje yeongu

35.

Sin, Ju-back, (2007) Ilbon jeongbu-ui jeonhu cheori bangchim-e daehan hanguk jeongbu-ui dae-eung, Baeksan hakbo

36.

Takamura, Naosuke, (2008) 改訂版日本史A, Yamakawa Shuppansha

37.

Tanaka, Akira, (2007) 日本史A, TokyoShoseki

38.

Tanaka, Hiroshi, (2000) 記憶と妄却, History and Criticism Publishing

39.

Umitu, Masatomo, (2006) 中學社會?地理的分野, Nihon Shoseki Shinsha

40.

UNESCO, (1949) A Handbook for the Improvement of Textbooks and Teaching Materials, UNESCO

41.

Wang, Yamin, comp, (2008) 普通高中課程標準實驗敎科書歷史必修下冊, Daxiang Publishing House

42.

Yang, Won-taek, (2007) Sahoegwa gyoyuk gwajeong gaejeongan, Ministry of Education and Human Resources Development, Republic of Korea

바로가기메뉴

Article Contents

Vol.48 No.3

“How to Cross the Border ” of Historical Perceptions in the History Textbooks of Korea,China and Japan: “Liquidation ” of the Asia-Pacific War and Historical Reconciliation

Abstract

Reference

Korea Journal