본문 바로가기 주메뉴 바로가기


  • P-ISSN0023-3900
  • E-ISSN2733-9343

A Weeping Man and the Mourning Ritual: Literati Writing and the Rhetoric of Funeral Oration in Eighteenth-Century Joseon

Korea Journal / Korea Journal, (P)0023-3900; (E)2733-9343
2013, v.53 no.1, pp.143-171

  • Downloaded
  • Viewed


This article investigates the cultural irony of Confucian discipline set against the literary presentation of emotions, from the angle of cultural studies grounded on historical and philosophical approaches, literary text analysis, and gender criticism. First, it aims to explore how funeral oration legitimized the act of weeping for scholar-officials of Joseon and shows how gender was a key element in understanding the way emotional expressiveness was accommodated, represented, and articulated in the Confucian norm. Next, it examines how the level of emotional expressiveness of the funeral oration was closely linked to bloodline, physical and psychological distance, the nature of a relationship, and social context. Finally, it shows that mourning and sadness were deemed the purest and sincerest expression of authentic feeling, as seen through its close association with bodily reactions, and that the funeral oration served as an exhibition of the interaction of human feelings

emotion sadness gender funeral oration Confucian culture bodily pain physicality paradox cultural irony zhongyong



An, Jeong-bok 安鼎福. n.d. Sunam seonsaeng munjip 順菴先生文集(Collected Works of Sunam An Jeong-bok).


Bak, Pil-ju 朴弼周. n.d. Yeohojip 黎湖集(Collected Works of Yeoho Bak Pil-ju).


Bak, Yun-won 朴胤源. n.d. Geunjaejip 近齋集(Collected Works of Geunjae Bak Yun-won).


Chae, Je-gong 蔡濟恭. n.d. Beonamjip 樊巖集(Collected Works of Beonam Chae Je-gong).


Eo, Yu-bong 魚有鳳. n.d. Giwonjip 杞園集(Collected Works of Giwon Eo Yubong).


Jeong, Beom-jo 丁範祖. n.d. Haejwajip 海左集(Collected Works of Haejwa Jeong Beom-jo).


Jeong, Yak-yong 丁若鏞. n.d. Yeoyudang munjip 與猶堂文集(Collected Works of Yeoyudang Jeong Yak-yong).


Kim, Chang-hyeop 金昌協. n.d. Nongamjip 農巖集(Collected Works of Nongam Kim Chang-hyeop).


Kim, Chang-heup 金昌翕. n.d. Samyeonjip 三淵集(Collected Works of Samyeon Kim Chang-heup).


Kim, Jong-hu 金鍾厚. n.d. Bonamjip 本庵集(Collected Works of Bonam Kim Jong-hu).


Kim, Ju-sin 金柱臣. n.d. Sugokjip 壽谷集(Collected Works of Sugok Kim Ju-sin).


Korean Classics Research Institute, ed. 1986-2005. Hanguk munjip chonggan (Comprehensive Literary Collections of Korea). Seoul: Institute for the Translation of Korean Classics. http://db.itkc.or.kr.


Liji 禮記(Book of Rites).


Song, Mun-heum 宋文欽. n.d. Hanjeongdangjip 閒靜堂集(Collected Works of Hanjeongdang Song Mun-heum).


Song, Neung-sang 宋能相. n.d. Unpyeongjip 雲坪集(Collected Works of Unpyeong Song Neung-sang).


Yi, Deok-mu 李德懋. n.d. Cheongjanggwan jeonseo 靑莊館全書(Complete Works of Cheongjanggwan Yi Deok-mu).


Yi, Ha-gon 李夏坤. n.d. Dutacho 頭陀草(Collected Works of Yi Ha-gon).


Yi, Gwang-jeong 李光庭. n.d. Nureunjip 訥隱集(Collected Works of Nureun Yi Gwang-jeong).


Yi, Min-bo 李敏輔. n.d. Pungseojip 豊墅集(Collected Works of Pungseo Yi Minbo).


Yun, Bong-gu 尹鳳九. n.d. Byeonggyejip 屛溪集(Collected Works of Byeonggye Yun Bong-gu).


Zhongyong 中庸(Doctrine of the Mean).


Zuozhuan 左傳(Zuo’s Commentary).


An, Dae-hoe, ed. 2003. Joseon hugi sopummun-ui silche (The Style of Short Writings in the Late Joseon Period). Seoul: Taehaksa.


An, Young-sang. 2005. “Yeoheon Jang Hyeon-gwang-gwa Seongho Yi Ik-ui seongniseol bigyo yeongu” (A Comparative Study of Neo-Confucian Theories between Jang Hyeon-gwang and Yi Ik). Yugyo sasang yeongu (Journal of Confucian Philosophy) 24.


An, Young-sang. 2009. “Sadan chiljeongnon ihae-reul wihan Zhu Xi simtong seongjeongnon-ui geomto” (An Exploration of Zhu Xi’s Doctrine of Mind Unifying the Human Nature and Feeling for the Understanding of the Four-Seven Debate). Jeongsin munhwa yeongu (Korean Studies Quarterly) 117.


Bae, Jong-ho. 1978. “Yulgok-ui sadan chiljeongnon-gwa insim dosimseol” (Yulgok’s Four-Seven Thesis and Discourse on Moral and Human Mind). Dongbang hakji (Journal of Korean Studies) 19.


Birch, Charles. 1995. Feelings. Sydney: University of New South Wales Press.


Bolen, Jean Shinoda. 2003. Uri sok-e inneun yeosindeul. Translated by Jo Juhyeon and Jo Myeong-deok. Seoul: Ttohanaui Munhwa. Originally published as Goddesses in Everywoman: A New Psychology of Women (San Francisco: Harper and Row, 1984).


Bolen, Jean Shinoda. 2006. Uri sok-e inneun namsindeul. Translated by Yu Seong-hui. Seoul: Ttohanaui Munhwa. Originally published as Gods in Everyman: A New Psychology of Men’s Lives and Loves (San Francisco: Harper and Row, 1989).


Bourdieu, Pierre. 2003. Namseong jibae (Masculine Domination). Translated by Kim Yong-suk. Seoul: Tongmunseon. Originally published as La Domination masculine (Paris: Seuil, 1998).


Choe, Keysook. 2003. “Eoneo-ui yukcheseong, gonggam-gwa gyeongheom-ui susahak: namwon gosa-ui munche mihak” (The Body as a Language, the Rhetoric of Sympathy and Experience: The Narrative Aesthetics of Namwon gosa). Gososeol yeongu (Studies in Korean Classical Novels) 16.


Choe, Keysook. 2006. “Jendeo bipyeong: meta bipyeong-euroseoui gojeon dokhae” (Gender Critics: Reading the Korean Classical Literary Texts with a Metacritical Perspective). Hanguk gojeon yeoseong munhak yeongu (Korean Classical Woman Literature Studies) 12.


Choe, Keysook. 2012. “Gamjeongjeok ingan-ui balgyeon-gwa gamjeong-ui bokhapseong sunsuseong inyeomhwa” (The Discovery of Emotional Human Beings and the Complexity, Purity, and Idealization of Emotions). Gososeol yeongu (Studies in Korean Classical Novels) 34.


Chen, Bixiang 陳必祥. 1995. Hanmun muncheron (On Chinese Literary Writing Styles). Translated by Sim Kyung-Ho. Seoul: Ihoe Munhwasa. Originally published as Gudai sanwen wenti gailun 古代散文文體槪論(Taipei: Wenshizhe Chubanshe, 1986).


Hume, David. [1740] 1996. Jeongnyeom-e gwanhayeo (A Treatise of Human Nature). Translated by Yi Chun-ho. Seoul: Seogwangsa.


Hwang, Su-yeon. 2002. “17 segi jemangsilmun-gwa jemangnyeomun yeongu” (A Study on the Seventeenth-Century Ceremonial Writings for the Deceased Wife and Daughter). Hanguk hanmunhak yeongu (Journal of Korean Literature in Hanmun) 30.


Hwang, Su-yeon, et al., ed. 2010. 18 segi yeoseong saenghwalsa jaryojip (The Sourcebook of Women’s Life in the Eighteenth Century). Vols. 1-8. Seoul: Bogosa.


Irigaray, Luce. 1998. Na, neo, uri (I, You, and We). Translated by Park Jeongo. Seoul: Tongmunseon. Originally published as Je, tu, nous: pour une culture de la différence (Paris: B. Grasset, 1990).


Irigaray, Luce. 2000. Hana-iji aneun seong (This Sex Which Is Not One). Translated by Yi Eun-min. Seoul: Tongmunseon. Originally published as Ce sexe qui n’en est pas un (Paris: Minuit, 1977).


Jung, Min. 2007. Sippal segi joseon jisigin-ui balgyeon (A Discovery of the Joseon Literati of the Eighteenth Century). Seoul: Humanist.


Kim, Hyeon-mi. 2006. “Seulpeum-gwa tansik sok-ui jiabi/abeoji doegi” (Being a Husband/Father in Lamentation). Hanguk gojeon yeoseong munhak yeongu (Korean Classical Woman Literature Studies) 13.


Kim, Myeong-seok. 2009. “Gongja-ui yullijeok gamjeonggwan siron” (An Essay on Confucius’s View of Moral Sentiments). Dongyang cheolhak yeongu (Journal of Eastern Philosophy) 59.


Ko, Mi-ra. 1996. “Yeoseonghak yongeo sajeon: yangmyeonseong-gwa yeoseongseong” (A Dictionary of Women’s Studies: Androgyny and Femininity). Yeoseong-gwa sahoe (Women and Society) 7.


Legge, James, trans. 1949. The Chinese Classics: Confucian Analects, the Great Learning, and the Doctrine of the Mean. Hong Kong: Hong Kong University Press.


Li, Yuan 李媛. 2008. “Mingchao gongjiwen wenben de zhengzhi wenhua neihan 明朝公祭文文本的政治文化內涵” (The Political Cultural Implication of the Sacrificial Texts for the State Worship in the Ming Dynasty). Gudai wenming 古代文明(Journal of Ancient Civilizations) 4.


Liu, Xie. 1994. Munsim joryong (The Literary Mind and the Carving of Dragons). Translated and edited by Choe Dong-ho. Seoul: Mineumsa. Originally published as Wenxin diaolong 文心雕龍(n.p., 499-501).


Park, Mu-young. 2003. “18 segi jemang silmun-ui gongjeok gineung-gwa geulsseugi” (The Public Function and Styles of the Noble Husband’s Writings for His Dead Wife in the 18th Century). Hanguk hanmunhak yeongu (Journal of Korean Literature in Hanmun) 32.


Santangelo, Paolo. 2003. Sentimental Education in Chinese History: An Interdisciplinary Textual Research on Ming and Qing Sources. Boston: Brill.


Smith, Adam. 2009. Dodeok gamjeongnon (The Theory of Moral Sentiments). Translated by Park Se-il and Min Kyoung-guk. Seoul: Pibong. Originally published as The Theory of Moral Sentiments (London: A. Millar, 1759).


Spivak, G. Chakravorty. 2003. Dareun sesang-eseo (In Other Worlds). Translated by Tae Hye-suk. Seoul: Yeoiyeon. Originally published as In Other Worlds (New York: Methuen, 1987).


Wang, Zhiwen 王杰文. 2010. “Wange yu jiwen: zai leixing de duihua zhong biaoyan quanli 挽歌與祭文: 在類型的對話中表演權力” (Elegy and Funeral Oration: Displaying the Effective Power through Dialogue Patterns). Minzu yishu 民族藝術(Ethnic Arts Quarterly) 2.


Wierzbicka, Anna. 1999. Emotions across Languages and Cultures: Diversity and Universals. New York: Cambridge University Press.


Yi, En-young. 2001. “Joseon jeongi jemun yeongu” (A Study of Funeral Oration in Early Joseon). PhD diss., Ewha Womans University.


Yu, Junli 于俊利. 2008. “Tangdai jiwen de wenti yanbian 唐代祭文的文體演變” (The Evolution of the Funeral Oration Style during the Tang Dynasty). Shehui kexue pinglun 社會科學評論(Review of Social Sciences) 2.


Yu, Junli 于俊利, and Fu Shaoliang . 2009. “Cong tang daijiwen kan pianwen de yanjin ” (Considering the Evolution of Parallel Prose in the Funeral Oration during the Tang Dynasty). Dongfang congkan 東方叢刊(A Multidimensional Study of Orientalism) 2.


Yun, Sa-sun. 1971. “Toegye-ui simseonggwan: sadan chiljeongnon-eul jungsimeuro” (A Study on Toegye’s View of Human Nature with a Focus on the Four-Seven Theory). Asea yeongu (Journal of Asiatic Studies) 14.

Korea Journal