- P-ISSN0023-3900
- E-ISSN2733-9343
- A&HCI, SCOPUS, KCI
ISSN : 0023-3900
Rodrigues the Gift-Giver: A Korean Envoy’s Portrayal of His Encounter with a Jesuit in 1631
Abstract
This paper addresses an extremely favorable portrayal by an envoy of Joseon Korea, Jeong Du-won, of the Portuguese Jesuit João Rodrigues, whom Jeong met in the course of his tributary mission to Ming China in 1630–1631. In his subsequent report to the Joseon king, Jeong portrayed Rodrigues as a benign gift-giver, while portraying himself as a passive recipient of Western gifts. Jeong’s characterization of the Jesuit and his gifts has provided modern historians with an important case to illustrate their Eurocentric account of Western Learning in Korea, an account in which the Koreans played simply the passive role of recipient of European culture. While questioning this Eurocentric account, I shall situate Jeong’s portrayal of the Jesuit in its political contexts—Jeong’s China mission and the bureaucratic politics of the Joseon dynasty. The image of Rodrigues as the benign gift-giver was created by Jeong, the Joseon envoy who served as the transmitter of higher culture from China to Korea. In his self-serving rhetorical efforts to legitimize the “barbarian” informant from the West, he managed to legitimize his own achievements within the China mission.
- keywords
- Jeong Du-won, João Rodrigues, Western Learning, tributary mission, Jesuits in China, cultural encounter
Reference
An, Jeong-bok. n.d. Japdong sani 雜同散異 (Miscellaneous Notes), manuscript copy, Kyujanggak Institute for Korean Studies..
Guksa Pyeonchan Wiwonhoe (National Institute of Korean History). 1955–1958. Joseon wangjo sillok (Annals of the Joseon Dynasty). 48 vols. Seoul: Guksa Pyeonchan Wiwonhoe. http://sillok.history.go.kr/main/main.do.
Guksa Pyeonchan Wiwonhoe (National Institute of Korean History). 1959–1960. Bibyeonsa deungnok (Records of the Border Defense Command). 28 vols. Seoul: Guksa Pyeonchan Wiwonhoe. http://db.history.go.kr/ item/level.do?itemId=bb.
Guksa Pyeonchan Wiwonhoe (National Institute of Korean History). 1961–1977. Seungjeongwon ilgi (Diaries of the Royal Secretariat). 144 vols. Seoul: Guksa Pyeonchan Wiwonhoe. http://sjw.history.go.kr/main.do.
Jeong, Du-won. 2008. “Jocheon gi jido” (Cartographic Record of a Mission to the Celestial Court). In vol. 1 of Yeonhaengnok seonjip boyu 燕行錄選集補遺 (A Sequel to the Collection of Beijing Travelogues), edited by Daedong Munhwa Yeonguwon, 117–202. Seoul: Daedong Munhwa Yeonguwon.
Jo, Gyeong-nam. 1964. Sokjamnok 續雜錄 (Sequel to the Miscellaneous Writings during the War). In vol. 4 of Nanjung jamnok 亂中雜錄 (Miscellaneous Writings during the War). 4 vols.
Sayeogwon (Office of Interpretation). [1882] 2006. Tongmungwan ji 通文館志 (Records of the Office of Interpretation). 2 vols. Repr. Seoul: Kyujanggak Institute for Korean Studies, Seoul National University.
Yi, Ik. 1977–1984. Gugyeok seongho saseol 國譯星湖僿說 (Miscellaneous Discussions of Seongho Yi Ik, Translated into Modern Korean). 12 vols. Seoul: Minjok Munhwa Chujinhoe.
Ahn, Sang-Hyeon. 2009. “Hanguksa choecho-ui mangwongyeong I. Jeong Du-wonui “Seoyangguk Gibyeol Janggye” (The First Telescope in Korean History I. Translation of Jeong’s Report). Journal of Astronomy and Space Sciences 26.2: 237–266.
Ahn, Sang-Hyeon. 2011. “Myeong-ui jeicha hongipo gumae-wa gwallyeondoen du munseo: ‘Bohyo simalseo’-wa ‘Gongchong hyochung so’” (Two Documents concerning the Ming’s Second Purchase of the Red Barbarian Cannon: The “Report on the Process of Paying Loyalty to the Emperor” and the “Memorial for Presenting Cannon in order to Show Fidelity to the Emperor”). Kyujanggak 39: 377–405.
Cooper, Michael, S.J. 1974. Rodrigues the Interpreter: An Early Jesuit in Japan and China. New York: Weatherhill.
Fairbank, John K. 1968. “A Preliminary Framework.” In The Chinese World Order: Traditional China’s Foreign Relations, 1–19. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Han, Myung Gi. 2007. “‘Jaejoji eun’-gwa joseon hugi jeongchisa: Imjin waeran– jeongjodae sigi-reul jungsim-euro” (Political Roles and Significances of ‘Chaejochieun’ in Late Chosun Korea). Daedong munhwa yeongu (Journal of East Asia Studies) 59: 191–230.
Han, Myung Gi. 2009. Jeongmyo·byeongja horan-gwa dongasia (The Jurchen and Manchu Invasions of Joseon from an East Asian Perspective). Seoul: Pureun Yeoksa.
Han, Qi 韓琦, and Wu Min 吳旻. 2006. Xichao chongzheng ji·Xichao ding’an (wai sanzhong) 熙朝崇正集·熙朝定案 (外三種) (Collection of Documents concerning the Defense of Christian Teaching in the Present Dynasty, Collection of Official Documents concerning the Restoration of Christian Mission in the Present Dynasty) (Three Other Materials). Beijing: Zhonghua Shuju.
Huang, Yi-Long. 2001. “Sun Yuanhua: A Christian Convert Who Put Xu Guangqi’s Military Reform Policy into Practice.” In Statecraft and Intellectual Renewal in Late Ming China, edited by Catherine Jami, Peter Engelfriet, and Gregory Blue, 225–259. Leiden: Brill.
Huh, Tae Koo. 2002. “Sipchil segi joseon-ui yeomcho muyeok-gwa hwayak jejobeop baldal” (Saltpeter Trade and the Development of Gunpowder-Making Techniques in Seventeenth-Century Joseon). Hanguksa ron (Review of Korean History) 47: 203–254.
Jeong, Eun-ju. 2012. Joseon sidae sahaeng girokhwa: yet geurim-euro ingneun hanjung gwangyesa (Paintings on China Missions in Joseon: A History of Sino- Korean Relations Seen through Old Paintings). Seoul: Sahoe Pyeongnon.
Kang, Jae-eon. 1990. Joseon-ui seohaksa (History of Western Learning during the Joseon). Seoul: Minumsa.
Kim, Seul-gi. 2016. “Sukjongdae gwansanggam-ui siheollyeok hakseup: euryunyeon yeokseo sageon-gwa geu-e daehan gwansaggam-ui daeeung-eul jungsim-euro” (Gwansanggam’s Learning of Shixianli during King Sukjong’s Reign: Focusing on the Euryu Year Calendar Affair and the Response of Joseon Astronomers toward It). Master’s thesis, Seoul National University.
Kye, Seung Bum. 2006. “Pabyeong nonui-reul tonghae bon joseon jeongi daemyeong- gwan-ui byeonhwa” (A Change in the Korean View of Ming China: Court Debates on the Ming Requests for Korean Troops in Early Joseon). Daedong munhwa yeongu (Journal of East Asia Studies) 53: 309–346.
Li, Gertraude Roth. 2002. “State Building before 1644.” In The Cambridge History of China, Vol. 9: The Ch’ing Dynasty to 1800. Part I, edited by Willard J. Peterson, 9–72. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Lim, Hyong Taek. 2005. “Joseon sahaeng-ui haero yeonhaengnok: 17 segi dongbuga- ui yeoksa jeonhwan-gwa silhak” (Beijing Travelogues of Joseon Embassies via Sea Routes: Historical Changes in North-East Asia and the Practical Learning in the Seventeenth Century). Hanguk silhak yeongu (Journal of Korea Silhak Society) 9: 1–35.
Lim, Jongtae. 2010. “‘Postponed reciprocity’: How Did a Korean Traveler Portray His Encounter with Westerners in Early Eighteenth-century Beijing?” Horizons: Seoul Journal of Humanities 1.2: 175–193.
Lim, Jongtae. 2016. “The Tributary Relations between the Chosŏn and Ch’ing Courts to 1800.” In The Cambridge History of China, Vol. 9: The Ch’ing Dynasty to 1800. Part II, edited by Willard J. Peterson, 146–196. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Pratt, Mary Louise. 2008. Imperial Eyes: Travel Writing and Transculturation. 2nd ed. London: Routledge.
Tan, Shulin 譚樹林. 2013. “Wan ming fujing shichen yu chaoxian xixue zhi fazhan— yi chenzhoushi Jeong Du-won yixing wei zhongxin 晩明赴京使臣與朝鮮西學之發 展—以進奏使鄭斗源一行爲中心” (Joseon Envoys to the Late Ming and the Rise of Western Learning in Joseon: A Case of Jeong Du-won’s Mission). In Chuanjiaoshi yu zhongxi wenhua jiaoliu 傳敎士與中西文化交流 (Western Missionaries and the Cultural Exchanges between China and the West), 175–191. Beijing: Sanlian Shudian.
Yamaguchi, Masayuki 山口正之. 1967. Chosen seikyo shi: Chosen kirisutokyo no bunkashideki kenkyu 朝鮮西敎史: 朝鮮キリスト敎の文化史的硏究 (Western Religion in Korea: A Cultural Historical Approach to the Christianity of the Joseon Dynasty). Tokyo: Yuzankaku.
Yi, Won-sun. 1986. Joseon seohaksa yeongu (Studies in Western Learning during the Joseon Dynasty). Seoul: Iljisa.
Zhao, Hong 趙紅. 2006. “Mingdai Denglai xunfu kaolun 明代登萊巡撫考論” (A Research on the Grand Coordinator of Deng-Lai in the Ming Dynasty). Jinan daxue xuebao (Journal of Jinan University) 16.6: 69–73.
- Downloaded
- Viewed
- 0KCI Citations
- 0WOS Citations