Korea Journal
- P-ISSN0023-3900
- E-ISSN2733-9343
- A&HCI, SCOPUS, KCI
Mars and Manna: Defense Industry and the Economic Transformation of Korea under Park Chung Hee
Abstract
This paper examines the origins of South Korea’s industrial economy in the Park Chung Hee regime’s program for building a “self-reliant national defense” (jaju gukbang). Through independent arms development in the 1970s, Park’s technocrats engineered and launched the modernizing forces that propelled South Korea’s rapid economic growth, referred to as the “Miracle on the Hangang River.” From 1973 to 1979, the regime’s Heavy and Chemical Industrialization Plan (HCIP) systematically merged civilian industries with a state-controlled system of indigenous weapons production built from the ground up. Drawing strength from a defense-related infrastructure, HCIP rapidly advanced civilian technology and developed a highly skilled labor force, while simultaneously promoting private sector growth and exportation. As select civilian industries produced weapons, military technologies were diffused through “spin-off ” effects that built and expanded private-sector, export-based heavy and chemical industries. Deeply intertwined with economic development and export trade, South Korea’s burgeoning defense industry aggressively supported Park’s dual pursuits of “self-reliance” (jaju) in both national security and the economy. The legacy of South Korea’s independent military modernization is seen in the state’s enduring deep ties with what today represent the most technologically advanced and lucrative commercial industries in the Korean economy.
- keywords
- jaju gukbang, Park Chung Hee, heavy and chemical industrialization, Korean economy, defense industry, chaebol, South Korea
참고문헌
ADD (Agency for Defense Development). 1987. Gukbang gwahak yeongusosa: 1970–1980 (A History of the Agency for Defense Development: 1970–1980). Vol. 1. Daejeon: ADD.
ADD . 2007. Gukbang gwahak yeongusosa: 1991–2005 (A History of the Agency for Defense Development: 1991–2005). Vol. 3. Daejon: ADD.
Froebe, Jr., John A. (NSC). “Draft State Cable on Approach to South Korea on French Reprocessing Plant,” Memorandum for Secretary Kissinger, July 11, 1975, National Security Adviser Presidential Country Files for East Asia and the Pacific.
Frost & Sullivan Research Service. 2005. “County Industry Forecast—The South Korean Aerospace & Defense Industry.” http://www.frost.com/prod/ servlet/report-brochure.pag?id=4618-01-00-00-00.
Gerald R. Ford Library, Ann Arbor, Michigan. National Security Adviser, Presidential Country Files for East Asia and the Pacific, 1974-1977, Box 9.
Gyeongje 2 (Second Economic Secretariat in the Blue House). 1973. “Junghwahak gongeop-e ttareun gongeop gujo gaepyeollon” (A Theory on Industrial Restructuring based on the Heavy and Chemical Industrialization Promulgation). January 30. Seoul.
Han, Pilsun. 2000. Suryutan-eseo wonjaro-kkaji (From Grenades to Nuclear Reactor). Daejeon: ADD.
HCIPCPC (Heavy and Chemical Industry Promotion Council Planning Office). 1976. Heavy and Chemical Industry. Seoul: Government of the Republic of Korea.
Jimmy Carter Library and Museum, Atlanta, Georgia. White House Central File, Subject File, Countries, Box CO-41.
KDIA (Korea Defense Industry Association). 1988. Bangjinhoesa (The Official History of Korean Defense Businesses). Seoul: KDIA.
KDIA . 2012. Bangwi saneop gaeron (Introduction to Korean Defense Industry). Vol. 1. Seoul: KDIA.
MND (Ministry of National Defense of ROK). 1994. Yulgok saeop-ui eoje-wa oneul geurigo naeil (The Past, Present, and Future of the Yulgok Operation). Seoul:MND.
MND (Ministry of National Defense of ROK). 2002. Gukbangsa 4: 1972–1981. 12 (The History of National Defense 4). Seoul: MND.
MND (Ministry of National Defense of ROK). 2010. 2010 Defense White Paper. Seoul: MND.
MND (Ministry of National Defense of ROK). 2014. 2014 Defense White Paper. Seoul: MND.
MND (Ministry of National Defense of ROK). 2016. 2016 Defense White Paper. Seoul: MND.
PANAK (Presidential Archives of the National Archives of Korea). 1968. “Mi gukbangseong gukje anjeon damdang buchagwanbo-waui hoedam gyeolgwa bogo” (Report on the Talk with Assistant Deputy Secretary of International Security at the US Department of Defense). EA0002502. November 4, 1968
PANAK (Presidential Archives of the National Archives of Korea). 1972. “Byeonggi saengsan cheje” (Weapon Production System). EA0004549. February 15, 1972.
PANAK (Presidential Archives of the National Archives of Korea). 1974. “Jeoncha gaebal gyehoek” (Plan for Development of Tanks). EA0004802. July 13, 1974.
PANAK (Presidential Archives of the National Archives of Korea). 1975a. “Guksan 81-mm bakgyeokpo suchul geonui” (Proposal for the Export of Domestic 81-Mm Mortars). EA0004856. August 18, 1975.
PANAK (Presidential Archives of the National Archives of Korea). 1975b. “Gunsu simuihoe uigyeol sahang bogo” (Report on the Decisions of Munitions Council). EA0004861. November 12, 1975.
PANAK (Presidential Archives of the National Archives of Korea). 1976a. “Balkanpo ryangsan gyehoek” (Plan for Mass Production of Vulcans). EA0004874. May 3, 1976.
PANAK (Presidential Archives of the National Archives of Korea). 1976b. “Janggapcha saengsan chuljang gyeolgwa bogo” (Report on Overseas Trip for Armored Vehicles Production). EA0004886. July 20, 1976.
PANAK (Presidential Archives of the National Archives of Korea). 1976c. “Bangwi saneop-e daehan jiwon jisi” (An Order to Support the Defense Industry). EA0000236. November 18, 1976.
Presidential Secretariat of the Republic of Korea. 1970–1977. Park Chung Hee daetongnyeong yeonseol munjip (President Park Chung Hee’s Speeches). Vols. 7, 8, 10, 12 and 14. Donga chulpansa.
Shaw, William. 1984. South Korean Foreign Military Sales (FMS) Program. Washington, DC: US Library of Congress, Federal Research Division.
US Congress. 1978. House of Representatives. Committee on International Relations. Investigation of Korean-American Relations. 95th Congress, 2nd session. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
US Department of State. 2011. Foreign Relations of the United States (FRUS), 1969–1976. Vol. E-12. Documents on East and Southeast Asia, 1973–1976. Washington D.C.: US Government Printing Office, 2011.
Amsden, Alice H. 1989. Asia’s Next Giant: South Korea and Late Industrialization. New York: Oxford University Press.
An, Yongsu. 2014. “Changjo gyeongje sidae, min-gun gisul yunghap chokjin-eul tonghan saneop gyeongjaengnyeok ganghwa bangan” (An Era of Creative Economy, Strategy for Promoting Industrial Competitiveness through Military-Civilian Technological Convergence). Hanggong uju bangwi saneop hanguk-ui saengjon jeollyak (An Aerospace Defense Industry: Korea’s Survival Strategy)14.3: 173–192.
Bak, Yeonggu. 2012. Hanguk-ui junghwahak gongeopwa: Gwajeong-gwa naeyong (South Korea’s Heavy and Chemical Industrialization: Course and Contents). 2vols. Seoul: Haenam.
Bitzinger, Richard A. 1995. “South Korea’s Defense Industry at the Crossroads.”Korean Journal of Defense Analysis 7.1: 233–249.
Bitzinger, Richard A. 2003. Towards a Brave New Arms Industry? Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Bitzinger, Richard A., and Mikyoung Kim. 2005. “Why Do Small States Produce Arms? The Case of South Korea.” Korean Journal of Defense Analysis 17.2: 183–205.
Business Monitor International. 2011. South Korea Defense & Security Report Q32011. London.
Eckert, Carter. 1996. “Total War, Industrialization and Social Change in Late Colonial Korea.” In The Japanese Wartime Empire, 1931–1945, edited by Myers Peter Duus Ramon H., and Mark Peattie, 3–39. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Eckert, Carter. 2016. Park Chung Hee and Modern Korea: The Roots of Militarism, 1866–1945. Cambride, MA: Belknap Press.
Glassman, Jim, and Young-Jin Choi. 2014. “The Chaebol and the US military–Industrial Complex: Cold War Geopolitical Economy and South Korean Industrialization.” Environment and Planning A 46: 1160–1180.
Hahm, Sung Deuk, and L. Christopher Plein. 1995. “Institutions and Technological Development in Korea: The Role of the Presidency.” Comparatives Politics 28.1(October): 55–76.
Heo, Uk, and Karl DeRouen Jr. 1998. “Military Expenditures, Technological Change, and Economic Growth in the East Asian NICs.” The Journal of Politics 60.3(August): 830–846.
Hwang, Dong Joon. 1996. “The Role of Defense Industry in Innovation and the Development of Dual-Use Technology.” Korean Journal of Defense Analysis 8.1:153–176.
Jones, Leroy P., and Il Sakong. 1980. Government, Business, and Entrepreneurship in Economic Development: The Korean Case. London: Harvard University Press.
Kia Heavy Industries. 1999. Kia junggongeop 20nyeon sa (Kia Heavy Industries—20 Year History). Changwon: Kia.
Kim, Chung-yum. 2011. From Despair to Hope: Economic Policymaking in Korea, 1945–1979. Seoul: Korea Development Institute.
Kim, Eun Mee. 1997. Big Business, Strong State. New York: State University of New York Press.
Kim, Hyung-A. 2004. Korea’s Development under Park Chung Hee: Rapid Industrialization, 1961–1979. New York: RoutledgeCurzon.
Kim, Hyung-A. 2011. “Heavy and Chemical Industrialization, 1973–1979: South Korea’s Homeland Security Measures.” In Reassessing the Park Chung Hee Era, edited by Hyung-A Kim and Clark Sorensen, 19–42. Seattle: University of Washington Press.
Kim, Hyung-A. 2013. “Industrial Warriors: South Korea’s First Generation of Industrial Workers in Post-Developmental South Korea.” Asian Studies Review 37.4(October): 577–595.
Kim, Jingi. 2010. “Park Chung Hee-wa hanguk-ui mugi, bangwi saneop” (Park Chung Hee and the South Korean Weapons, Defense Industry). In Park Chung Hee sidae-reul hoego-hada, edited by Yi Chisu, 163–211. Seoul: Seonin.
Kim, Kwangmo. 2015. Junghwahak gongeop-e Park Chung Hee-ui honi saraitda (Park Chung Hee’s Spirit Lives in Korea’s Heavy and Chemical Industries). Seoul:Giparang.
Kim, Kwangmo. 2017. The Odyssey of Korean Heavy and Chemical Industrialization. Seoul:RH Korea.
Ku, Sanghoe. 1998. Hanguk-ui bangwi saneop (South Korea’s Defense Industry). Sejong Yeonguso.
Kwon, Peter Banseok. 2016. “The Anatomy of Chaju kukpang: Military-Civilian Convergence in the Development of the South Korean Defense Industry under Park Chung Hee, 1968–1979.” PhD diss., Harvard University.
Kwon, Peter Banseok. 2017. “Beyond Patron and Client: Historicizing the Dialectics of US-ROK Relations amid Park Chung Hee’s Defense Industry Development in South Korea, 1968–1979.” Seoul Journal of Korean Studies 30.2: 185–216.
Moon, Chung-in. 1988. “U.S. Third Country Arms Sales Regulation and the South Korean Defense Industry: Supplier Control and Recipient Dilemma.” In Alliance under Tension: The Evolution of South Korean-US Relations, edited by Manwoo Lee, Ronald D. McLaurin, and Chung-in Moon, 79–102. Boulder, Colorado:Westview Press.
Moon, Chung-in. 2015. “Military Self-Reliance, the Big Push, and the Growth of the Defense Industry: Lessons and Implications.” Korea and the World—Contemporary History and Its Implications, Research Series of Korean Contemporary History 6: 205–238.
Moon, Chung-in, and Jin-young Lee. 2008 “The Revolution in Military Affairs and the Defence Industry in South Korea.” Security Challenges 4.4: 117–134.
Moon, Seung-sook. 2005. Militarized Modernity and Gendered Citizenship in South Korea. Durham and London: Duke University Press.
Nolan, Janne E. 1986. Military Industry in Taiwan and South Korea. London:Macmillan.
O, Won-chol. 1996. Hangukyeong gyeongje geonseol: Enjinieoring eopeurochi (The Korean-Model of Economic Development: Engineering Approach). Vol. 5. Seoul: Kia Gyeongje Yeonguso.
O, Won-chol. 2009. The Korea Story: President Park Jung-hee’s Leadership and the Korean Industrial Revolution. Seoul: Wisdom Tree.
Park, Jae-Ok. 2010. “Defense Science and Technology of the ROK and Desirable Directions for Relevant R&D Policies.” Korean Journal of Defense Analysis 22.2:197–215.
Shin, Wookhee. 1993. Dynamics of Patron-Client State Relations: The United States and Korean Political Economy in the Cold War. Seoul: American Studies Institute, Seoul National University.
Weiss, Linda. 2014. America Inc.? Innovation and Enterprise in the National Security State. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Yu, Hansik. 2005. “Oneul seonjin gongeopwa-reul irungeot- eun bak daetongnyeongui bangwi saneop” (It Was President Park’s Defense Industry Development that Helped South Korea to Achieve Today’s Advanced Industrialization). Park Chung Hee 4: 16–19.
Mr. Bak (name protected for privacy; former director of the Agency for Defense Development), interview by author, Daejon, South Korea, October 29, 2012.
Kim, Chung-yum (former Chief of Staff under President Park, 1969–1978), interview by author, Seoul, South Korea, April 5, 2013.
Kim, Kwangmo (Vice Director of HCI Planning Corp., 1972–1979), interview by author, Mapo, South Korea, April 16, 2013.
Kim, Kwangmo (Vice Director of HCI Planning Corp., 1972–1979), interview by author, Mapo, South Korea, April 18, 2014.
Kim, Kwangmo (Vice Director of HCI Planning Corp., 1972–1979), interview by author, Mapo, South Korea, June 13, 2017.
Yu, Hansik (former skilled worker in Kia Heavy Industries in the 1970s), interview by author, Changwon, South Korea, August 19, 2017.
- 다운로드 수
- 조회수
- 0KCI 피인용수
- 0WOS 피인용수