바로가기메뉴

본문 바로가기 주메뉴 바로가기

logo

  • P-ISSN1013-0799
  • E-ISSN2586-2073
  • KCI

Article Contents

Prev Next
e-Submission

Vol.36 No.2

Citation Share

Improving the Perfectionism Index to Identify Influential Journals versus Mass Producers

Journal of the Korean Society for Information Management / Journal of the Korean Society for Information Management, (P)1013-0799; (E)2586-2073
2019, v.36 no.2, pp.201-222
https://doi.org/10.3743/KOSIM.2019.36.2.201

(2019). Improving the Perfectionism Index to Identify Influential Journals versus Mass Producers. Journal of the Korean Society for Information Management, 36(2), 201-222, https://doi.org/10.3743/KOSIM.2019.36.2.201

Abstract

The Perfectionism Index (PI) is an indicator that is recently proposed to distinguish influential researchers from mass producers. In this study, Near Perfectionism Index (NPI), an improved indicator of Perfectionism Index, can be a solution to the problem of PI that indiscriminately gives a penalty to all low-cited papers regardless of publishing time or other issues. NPI improved the method to give a penalty to tail complement area considering the citation distribution curve. It prevents the improvement of the h-index from adversely affecting the researcher’s influence indicator. This study uses NPI to evaluate information and library science journals in Web of Science database. It successfully distinguishes between influential journals and mass producers unlike journal h-index or average citation frequency which could not differentiate influentials from mass producers.

keywords
인용 지수, 완벽주의 지수, 준완벽주의 지수, 학술지 평가, 연구자 평가, h-지수, 유력 학술지, 거대 학술지, citation indicator, perfectionism index, near perfectionism index, journal evaluation, researcher evaluation, h-index, influential journal, mega journal

Journal of the Korean Society for Information Management

e-Submission OA Policy