바로가기메뉴

본문 바로가기 주메뉴 바로가기

logo

  • P-ISSN0023-3900
  • E-ISSN2733-9343
  • A&HCI, SCOPUS, KCI

ISSN : 0023-3900

Article Contents

Prev Next
e-Submission

Vol.56 No.2

Citation Share

Reassessment of the Late Joseon Neo-Confucian Scholar Yi Ik’s Attitude toward Western Learning: With a Focus on His Perception of the Lord of Heaven

Korea Journal / Korea Journal, (P)0023-3900; (E)2733-9343
2016, v.56 no.2, pp.111-133
https://doi.org/10.25024/kj.2016.56.2.111

(2016). Reassessment of the Late Joseon Neo-Confucian Scholar Yi Ik’s Attitude toward Western Learning: With a Focus on His Perception of the Lord of Heaven. Korea Journal, 56(2), 111-133, https://doi.org/10.25024/kj.2016.56.2.111

Abstract

This article aims to investigate how Yi Ik, a late Joseon Neo-Confucian scholar, formed his view toward Christianity and the concept of the Lord of Heaven (Cheonju). Yi viewed Seohak (Western Learning) postively, but his attitude toward Christianity remained very selective. For instance, while he agreed with the Jesuits’ claim that the biblical Lord of Heaven was equivalent to the Confucian Sangje, he rejected the ideas of heaven, hell, and spiritual immortality based on his Neo-Confucian convictions. Although Yi agreed with the Jesuit assertion that “the Lord of Heaven is the same as Sangje,” he modified this concept of god according to his Neo-Confucian philosophy and perceived it as something analogous to the Principle of Heaven (cheolli). This essay will show that Yi’s attention to Christianity originated from his academic objective of enriching the study of Neo-Confucianism. Therefore, the majority of scholars of Korean studies may need to reassess the established theory that Seohak motivated Yi Ik to go beyond Neo-Confucianism and advance toward modern Silhak (Practical Learning).

keywords
Yi Ik, Cheonju (Lord of Heaven), Sangje, Seohak (Western Learning), Silhak (Practical Learning), Seongnihak (Neo-Confucianism), modernity

Reference

1.

An, Jeong-bok. [1808] 1996-1997. Sunamjip 順菴集 (Collected Writings of Sunam). Rep. Seoul: Minjok Munhwa Chujinhoe.

2.

An, Jeong-bok, ed. [n.d.] 1915. Seongho saseol yuseon 星湖僿說類選 (Selections from Miscellaneous Discussions of Seongho Yi Ik). 2 vols. Gyeongseong: Joseon Goseo Ganhaenghoe.

3.

Sin, Hu-dam. 2007. Habin seonsaeng jeonjip 河濱先生全集 (Complete Works of Habin Sin Hu-dam). 2nd ed. Seoul: Asea Munhwasa.

4.

Yi, Ik. 1984. Seongho saseol 星湖僿說 (Miscellaneous Discussions of Seongho Yi Ik). In Seongho jeonseo 星湖全書 (Complete Works of Seongho Yi Ik). 7 vols. Repr. Seoul: Yeogang Chulpansa.

5.

Yi, Ik . 1998. Seongho jeonjip 星湖全集 (Collected Works of Seongho Yi Ik). 70 vols. Repr. Seoul: Minjok Munhwa Chujinhoe.

6.

Baker, Donald. 1997. Joseon hugi yugyo-wa cheonjugyo-ui daerip (Confucianism Confronts Catholicism in the Late Joseon Dynasty). Translated by Kim Se-yun. Seoul: Ilchogak.

7.

Cha, Gijin. 2013. “Seongho Yi Ik-ui seoyang yulli-wa seogyo insik” (A Study of Western Ethics and Christian Doctrine as Understood by Yi Ik). Paper presented at the International Conference for the 250th Anniversary of Seongho’s Death, Academy of Korean Studies, Seongnam, November 7–8.

8.

Hong, I-seop. 1946. Joseon gwahaksa (History of Joseon Science). Seoul: Jeongeumsa.

9.

Kang, Byung Soo. 2003. “Seongho Yi Ik-gwa Habin Sin Hu-dam-ui seohak damnon: Noeyang-e daehan insik-eul jungsim-euro” (A Study of the Debate on Western Learning between Yi Ik and Shin Hu-dam: Concerning the Theory of Archae Theory). Hanguk silhak yeongu (Journal of Korea Silhak Society) 6: 29–62.

10.

Kawahara, Hideki 川原秀城. 2013. “Ri Iki no kagakuron to shushigaku no sōtaika 李 瀷の科学論と朱子学の相対化” (Yi Ik’s Theory on Science and Relativization of Zhuji’s Philosophy). Paper presented at the International Conference for the 250th Anniversary of Seongho’s Death, Academy of Korean Studies, Seongnam, November 7–8.

11.

Keum, Jang-tae. 2000. “Seongho Yi Ik-ui seohak insik” (Seongho Yi Ik’s Perception of Western Learning). Donga munhwa (Journal of Institute of Asian Studies) 38: 1–38.

12.

Keum, Jang-tae . 2001. “Dunwa Sin Hu-dam-ui seohak bipan iron-gwa jaengjeom” (Shin Hu-tam’s Theoretical Criticism of Western Learning and its Issues). Jonggyohak yeongu (Journal of Religious Studies) 20: 1–25.

13.

Kim, Hyoung Chan. 2010. “Joseon yuhak-ui i gaenyeom-e natanan jonggyojeok seonggyeok-e gwanhan yeongu” (A Study on the Religious Character of the Concept of I in Korean Confucianism). Cheolhak yeongu (Journal of the Society of Philosophical Studies) 39: 67–101.

14.

Kim, Yung Sik. 2000. The Natural Philosophy of Chu Hsi (1130–1200). Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society.

15.

Lim, Boo Yeon. 2014. “Seongho hakpa-ui cheonjugyo insik-gwa yugyojeok daeeung” (Seongho School’s Perception of Christianity and the Confucian Response). Hanguk sasangsahak (The Study of Korean History of Thought) 46: 247–282.

16.

Noh, Dae-hwan. 1997. “Joseon hugi-ui seohak yuip-gwa seogi suyongnon” (Influx of Western Learning and the Reception of the Theory of Seogi in the Late Joseon). Jindan hakbo (Journal of the Jindan Historical Society) 83: 121–154.

17.

Seo, Jong-tae. 2001. “Yi Ik-gwa Sin Hu-dam-ui seohak nonjaeng: Dunwa seohakbyeon- ui ‘Gimun pyeon’-eul jungsim-euro” (Seohak Debates between Yi Ik and Sin Hu-dam: With a Focus on the Gimun Chapter of Dunwa’s Seohakbyeon). Gyohoesa yeongu (Research Journal of Korean Church History) 16: 179–211.

18.

Yi, Dae-geun. 2008. “Geungi nam-in-ui cheongwan yeongu” (Perspective toward God among the Seoul Region Confucian Scholars). Katolik sinhak (Catholic Theology) 13: 183–215.

19.

Yi, Neung-hwa. 1928. Joseon gidokgyo geup oegyosa (Joseon Christianity and Diplomatic History). Seoul: Joseon Gidokgyo Changmunsa.

20.

Yi, Yong-ju. 2003. Zhu Xi-ui munhwa ideollogi (Zhu Xi’s Cultural Ideology). Seoul: Ihaksa.

21.

Yun, Sa Sun.1976. “Silhak sasang-ui cheolhakjeok seonggyeok” (Philosophical Character of Silhak Thought). Asea yeongu (The Journal of Asiatic Studies) 19.2: 1–22.

Korea Journal

e-Submission OA Policy