초록

원문정보공개 서비스가 제공되면서 원문정보의 공개를 결정하는 데에 소모되는 시간이 매우 짧아지고 원문정보공개 건수는 크게 증가하였다. 공공기관에서는 개인정보 노출의 위험성 또한 높아졌다. 본 연구에서는 원문정보공개 서비스에서의 개인정보 보호 실태를 알아보고 개인정보 노출 원인을 분석하여 개선방안을 제안하였다. 실태 조사 결과는 다음과 같다. 첫째, 수집한 원문정보 중 13%의 원문정보가 비공개 대상정보인 개인정보를 포함하고 있었다. 둘째, 비공개 대상정보인 개인정보가 포함된 원문정보 중 공무원의 개인정보가 포함된 원문정보가 가장 많은 비중을 차지했다. 특히 휴가․병가에 관한 기록물이 많았다. 셋째, 계약업무를 주로 다루는 기관에서는 대표자 개인에 관한 정보가 노출되는 사례가 많았다. 넷째, 개인정보 필터링에 감지되지 않는 개인정보가 많았다. 개인정보 노출 원인을 분석하여 제안한 개선방안은 다음과 같다. 첫째, 개인정보 보호지침을 재설계해야 한다. 둘째, 원문정보의 공개․비공개를 결정하는 업무담당자의 교육을 강화해야 한다. 셋째, 정부의 양적 실적 위주의 과도한 정보공개정책을 완화해야 한다. 넷째, 원문정보공개 시스템의 개인정보 필터링 기능을 개선해야 한다.

Abstract

With the provision of the original text information disclosure service, the time spent on determining the disclosure of the original text information decreased, and the number of original text information disclosure significantly increased. In public institutions, the risk of the exposure of personal information also increased. In this study, the status of personal information protection in the original text information disclosure service was investigated. Moreover, the causes of the exposure of personal information were analyzed, and improvements were proposed. The survey presented the following results. First, 13% of the original text information collected contains personal information, which is the nondisclosure information. Second, among the original text information that includes personal information, the original text information, including the personal information of the public official, was the most important. In particular, many records about vacation and medical leaves were found. Third, there were many cases in which information about the individual of the representative was exposed in the agency that deals mainly with the contract work. Fourth, a large volume of personal information was not detected by filtering personal information. Upon analyzing the cause of the exposure of personal information, the following improvements are suggested. First, privacy guidelines should be redesigned. Second, the person in charge of the task of deciding whether or not to disclose original text information should be trained further. Third, the excessive disclosure of information based on the government’s quantitative performance should be eased. Fourth, the filtering function of the personal information of the original text information disclosure system should be improved.

초록

본고의 목적은 1894년부터 1910년까지 한국과 일본 공문서관리시스템의 중층적․종속적 구조를 밝히는 것으로, 기록사료학적 관점에서 분석하고자 한다. 연구대상 시기는 일제가 한국의 기록관리제도를 장악하여 조선을 침탈해가던 시기로서 그 내용은 일본내각과 군부가 대륙침략전쟁을 위하여 한국에 구축한 인프라 관련 기록과 통감부 설치와 관련하여 결재된 원본문서이다．특히 일본제국이 청일전쟁․동학농민전쟁을 진압하기 위해 전주를 중심으로 한 전북지역에 전략적으로 구축한 인프라기록을 중심으로 검토하였다. 이를 위해 갑오개혁기와 통감부시기에 걸쳐 일본정부가 한국을 지배하기 위해 작성한 정책․예산․인사 결정 관련 상위레벨의 결재 원본 출처와 편성 실태를 밝히고, 한국 내각과 통감부가 작성한 하위레벨 공문서 실태를 분석하였다. 그 결과 본 논문에서는 이 시기 한국의 공문서관리제도는 일국사적 관점에서만 고찰해서는 안되며, 한․일간 수직적 연관구조 속에서 중층적이고 종속적인 시스템 속에서 파악해야 한다는 점을 제기하였다.

Abstract

This paper aims to interrogate the layered and dependent structure of the modern and official document management in Korea and Japan from 1894 to 1910. The focus of its study is on documents related with the strategic infrastructure construction in Jeonbuk Province through an analysis from the perspective of historic archival studies. For this study, the chosen period was when Japanese imperialists were on their way to seize the Korean official archival system. As such, our objects are the documents connected with the institution of the Japanese resident-general system in Korea and its infrastructural constructions as part of Japan’s war plans of invading the continent. Among others, we examined the documents of the strategic infrastructure construction around Jeonju in Jeonbuk Province by Imperial Japan, in order to wage the Sino-Japanese War and subdue the Donghak Peasant Revolution. More specifically, we illuminate the sources and organization of the approval of the original documents in a higher level that is relevant to the determination of political, financial, and personnel matters, which were designed for the Japanese governmental rule over Korea from the era of the Gabo Reform to the period of the Japanese resident-generals, as well as analyze the actual states of the official documents ina lower level, which were drawn up by Korean government and the resident-general. Consequently, this paper suggests that official Korean archival system at this time must be understood under the context of a layered and dependent structure within the vertical connections between Korea and Japan, and not from the point of view of a national history.

초록

Abstract

This study investigates the current preservation and management of four records and documentary heritage in Korea that is in the UNESCO's Memory of the World Register. The study analyzes their problems and corresponding solutions in digitizing those world records heritages. This study also reviews additional four documentary books in Korea that are in the wish list to add to UNESCO's Memory of the World Register. This study is organized as the following: Chapter 2 examines the value and meanings of world records and documentary heritage in Korea. The registry requirements and procedures of UNESCO's Memory of the World Register are examined. The currently registered records of Korea include Hunmin-Chongum, the Annals of the Choson Dynasty, the Diaries of the Royal Secretariat (Seungjeongwon Ilgi), and Buljo- Jikji-Simche-Yojeol (vol. Ⅱ). These records heritage's worth and significance are carefully analyzed. For example, Hunmin-Chongum(「訓民正音」) is consisted of unique and systematic letters. Letters were delicately explained with examples in its original manual at the time of letter's creation, which is an unparalleled case in the world documentary history. The Annals of the Choson Dynasty(「朝鮮王朝實錄」) are the most comprehensive historic documents that contain the longest period of time in history. Their truthfulness and reliability in describing history give credits to the annals. The Royal Secretariat Diary (called Seungjeongwon-Ilgi(「承政院日記」)) is the most voluminous primary resources in history, superior to the Annals of Choson Dynasty and Twenty Five Histories in China. Jikji(「直指」) is the oldest existing book published by movable metal print sets in the world. It evidences the beginning of metal printing in the world printing history and is worthy of being as world heritage. The review of the four registered records confirms that they are valuable world documentary heritage that transfers culture of mankind to next generations and should be preserved carefully and safely without deterioration or loss. Chapter 3 investigates the current status of preservation and management of three repositories that store the four registered records in Korea. The repositories include Kyujanggak Archives in Seoul National University, Pusan Records and Information Center of National Records and Archives Service, and Gansong Art Museum. The quality of their preservation and management are excellent in all of three institutions by the following aspects: 1) detailed security measures are close to perfection 2) archiving practices are very careful by using a special stack room in steady temperature and humidity and depositing it in stack or archival box made of paulownia tree and 3) fire prevention, lighting, and fumigation are thoroughly prepared. Chapter 4 summarizes the status quo of digitization projects of records heritage in Korea. The most important issue related to digitization and database construction on Korean records heritage is likely to set up the standardization of digitization processes and facilities. It is urgently necessary to develop comprehensive standard systems for digitization. Two institutions are closely interested in these tasks: 1) the National Records and Archives Service experienced in developing government records management systems; and 2) the Cultural Heritage Administration interested in digitization of Korean old documents. In collaboration of these two institutions, a new standard system will be designed for digitizing records heritage on Korean Studies. Chapter 5 deals with additional Korean records heritage in the wish list for UNESCO's Memory of the World Register, including: 1) Wooden Printing Blocks(經板) of Koryo-Taejangkyong(高麗大藏經) in Haein Temple(海印寺); 2) Dongui-Bogam(「東醫寶鑑」) 3) Samguk-Yusa(「三國遺事」) and 4) Mugujeonggwangdaedaranigyeong(「無垢淨光大다羅尼經」). Their world value and importance are examined as followings. Wooden Printing Blocks of Koryo-Taejangkyong in Haein Temple is the worldly oldest wooden printing block of cannon of Buddhism that still exist and was created over 750 years ago. It needs a special conservation treatment to disinfect germs residing in surface and inside of wooden plates. Otherwise, it may be damaged seriously. For its effective conservation and preservation, we hope that UNESCO and Government will schedule special care and budget and join the list of Memory of the Word Register. Dongui-Bogam is the most comprehensive and well-written medical book in the Korean history, summarizing all medical books in Korea and China from the Ancient Times through the early 17th century and concentrating on Korean herb medicine and prescriptions. It is proved as the best clinical guidebook in the 17th century for doctors and practitioners to easily use. The book was also published in China and Japan in the 18th century and greatly influenced the development of practical clinic and medical research in Asia at that time. This is why Dongui Bogam is in the wish list to register to the Memory of the World. Samguk-Yusa is evaluated as one of the most comprehensive history books and treasure sources in Korea, which illustrates foundations of Korean people and covers histories and cultures of ancient Korean peninsula and nearby countries. The book contains the oldest fixed form verse, called Hyang-Ka(鄕歌), and became the origin of Korean literature. In particular, the section of Gi-ee(紀異篇) describes the historical processes of dynasty transition from the first dynasty Gochosun(古朝鮮) to Goguryeo(高句麗) and illustrates the identity of Korean people from its historical origin. This book is worthy of adding to the Memory of the World Register. Mugujeonggwangdaedaranigyeong is the oldest book printed by wooden type plates, and it is estimated to print in between 706 and 751. It contains several reasons and evidence to be worthy of adding to the list of the Memory of the World. It is the greatest documentary heritage that represents the first wooden printing book that still exists in the world as well as illustrates the history of wooden printing in Korea.

초록

공공기관의 기록물관리 업무에 QR코드의 도입사례를 알아보고 이를 통해 이용자의 업무만족감을 높이는 방안을 제시하고자 하였다. QR코드의 정의와 기록관에서 제공할 수 있는 이용자서비스에 대해 살펴보았고 QR코드를 이용한 도입사례를 살펴보았다. 기록관에 QR코드를 적용하려는 이유는 현재 공공기관에서는 기록물관리전문요원의 1인체제이다. 직원 수와 기록물의 양은 방대해지고 있다. 모든 업무의 내용을 숙지하여 정확하게 설명해야하고 기록관리 생애주기 이해가 부족한 직원들에게 전문적인 내용을 무한반복 설명을 해야하는 어려움이 있다. 도입사례로는 비전자 기록물등록 방법 안내, 중요기록물 및 행정박물 위치 및 이력 안내, 표준기록관리 교육 제공으로 나눴다. 이를 연구자가 제작한 ‘기록관리 안내서’(QR코드 유무)를 부산광역시 S구청 공무원들을 대상으로 실험집단과 통제집단으로 나누어 적용하여 연구하였다. 기록관리안내 만족도는 QR코드 활용 유무에 따라 의미 있는 차이가 있었다. 2017년 12월, 1차 조사와 2018년 3월 2차 조사를 비교분석하였을 때 실험집단의 경우 1차 조사에서 평균 2.94였으나 2차 조사에서 3.75로 결과치가 높게 나타났으며 통계적으로 의미가 있었다. 이는 기존의 활자로 제공하는 안내보다 QR코드를 도입하여 안내 하는 것이 높은 만족도를 보인다고 할 수 있다. 본 연구는 QR코드를 활용한 공공기관의 기록관리 도입사례와 이용자 만족도를 알아보는 것이지만 기록관리시스템(RMS)과 문서생산시스템에 접목시켜 완성도가 높아 질 수 있도록 하는 것이 향후 과제이다.

Abstract

The act was designed to identify the introductory cases of the use of quick response (QR) codes in records management by public institutions and propose measures to enhance users’ satisfaction with their work. This study looked at the definition of the QR codes and the user services that can be provided by the records depository and reviewed the introduction cases using the codes. The reason QR codes are used by records depositors is that public institutions currently have a single-person system that specializes in records management. With the number of employees and the number of records becoming more extensive, explaining the contents of all tasks accurately as well as other professional contents to employees who lack understanding of the records management life cycle is becoming more difficult. The introductory cases were divided into information on how to register nonelectronic records, information on location and history of important records and administrative museum, and education on standard records management. The research was conducted by dividing the research team’s “Records Management Guide” (QR code status) into experimental groups and control groups for officials of the Busan Metropolitan Government. There were significant differences in the level of satisfaction with records management guidance depending on whether or not QR codes were used. When the first and second surveys were compared in December 2017 and March 2018, the results of the first survey averaged 2.94, but the second survey showed high results at 3.75 and was statistically significant. This can be said to be more satisfactory by introducing QR codes than guidance provided by existing type. Although this research examines introductory cases of records management by public institutions using QR codes and user satisfaction, future tasks are to be applied to Records Management System and document production systems so that completion can be improved.