바로가기메뉴

본문 바로가기 주메뉴 바로가기

대중서사연구

순정만화라는 유령 - 순정만화라는 장르의 역사와 감성만화의 정의

A Ghost denominated 'Sunjeong Manhwa' - History of the genre 'Sunjeong Manhwa' and definition of the Sentimental Comics -

대중서사연구 / 대중서사연구, (P)1738-3188; (E)27139964
2016, v.22 no.2, pp.297-325
https://doi.org/10.18856/jpn.2016.22.2.010
한상정 (상지대학교)
  • 다운로드 수
  • 조회수

Abstract

Until today, the term 'Sunjeong Manhwa' is used broadly. However, the definition of the term is not so clear, and studies on the characteristics of it are not so common. The researcher premise one of the major reason is the standard from 1950s has not changed until now, for more than sixty years. In other words, researches before roughly bound different genres together as in the term ‘Sunjeong Manhwa’, so that it was difficult to figure characteristics out and define what the Sunjeong Manhwa is. Thus, divide all of the historical products we called as Sunjeong Manhwa by their features and redefine one of them as romance comics. The researcher believe by following this and review the history, the properness of genre separation can be understood. The researcher categorized Sunjeong manhwa in three different genres. They are Family-Sunjeong manhwa(1957-1962), Girlish manhwa(1963-1976) and Sentimental manhwa(1977-present), and the first category shows closest to the Sunjeong Manhwa in dictionary definition. That makes it can be called Sunjeong manhwa, but the range of it was families in general, so it can also be called as Family manhwa, or Family-Sunjeong manhwa. Second one is Girlish manhwa and it is influenced by Japanese Shojo Manga in 1960s. Third one is the very genre that we normally think the typical Sunejong Manhwa. The researcher categorized the last genre as Sentimental manhwa instead of Sunjeong manhwa. The researcher apprehends intrinsic features of this text are sensitive story, flowing fanciness and purposeful theatricality and discarded diverse factors that other studies are insisting (such as sex of both readers and main characters). These characteristics are, unless there are no obstacles from environmental factors, helps to build an ‘Sentimental Scene’, a three dimensions mental model. Sentimental scene is a process that readers drawing a three-dimensional image in their mind while reading or after reading the text. It is absolutely personal and abstract image. This model forms more vivid and lasts longer in image description, Sentimental description than textual and thesis. The Sentimentality, fanciness and theatricality are essential factors for constructing the Sentimental scene. The textual feature of Sentimental manhwa is important, but the readers who can properly make the image and the environment can have an influence on construction of Sentimental scene. This study arranges some confusion on existing studies about Sunjeong manhwa defines textual features of the genre and has a way to give explanation for contrasting appraisal for the genre. There is a limit in generalization and universalization since bring readers and reading into study.

keywords
감성만화, 순정만화, 장식성, 연극성, 감성적 장면, 정신적 재현, Sentimental Comics, Sunjeong Manhwa, Fanciness, Theatricality, Sentimental Scene, mental representation

참고문헌

1.

권영섭, <바람 따라 물결따라>, 1967.

2.

다케미야 게이코, <바람과 나무의 시>, 1976.

3.

민애니, <꿈의 건반>, 1971.

4.

이혜순, <돌아오지 않는 바람>, 1980년 전후.

5.

차성진, <은반위의 요정>, 1980.

6.

한성학, <영원한 종>, 1957.

7.

박인하, 『누가 캔디를 모함했나』, 살림, 2000.

8.

백정숙, 「순정만화의 짧은 역사」, 『마인』 3월호, 1996.

9.

손상익, 『한국만화통사 하』, 시공사, 1998.

10.

한상정, 「'장식성'의 반복적 출현에 대한 소고: 순정만화와 타 장르(포스터, 일러스트, 서정화, 소죠망가)를 중심으로」, 『만화애니메이션 연구』 12호, 한국만화애니메이션학회, 2007, 45-56쪽.

11.

한상정, 「감성만화의 이미지 서사의 주특성으로서의 연극성」, 『미학예술학연구』 26집, 한국미학예술학회, 2007, 151-176쪽.

12.

한영주, 『우리만화 다시보기(1950-1969)』, 부천만화정보센터, 글논그림밭, 2001.

13.

Antonio R. Damasio, “Le sentir du sentiment”, Le sentiment même de soi: corps, émotion, conscience, Paris: Odile Jacob, 1999, pp.277-292.

14.

Henry Morgan, “Autres thèmes, autres styles”, Thierry Groensteen, L’Univers des mangas: une introduction à la bande dessinée japonaise, Paris: Casterman, 1991, pp.27-52.

15.

Jean-Marie Galliana, “Image mentale et compréhension de textes décrivent des configurations spatiales: vers une approche développementale”, Jacqueline Bideaud et Yannick Courbois, Image mentale et développement, Paris: PUF, 1998, pp.115-138.

16.

Marguerite Cocude, “Generating and maintaining visual images: the incidence of individual and stimulus characteristics”, M. Denis et les autres (éd.), Cognitive and Neuropsychological Approaches to Mental Imagery, Vol.42, 1988, pp.213-222.

17.

Marie-France Ehrlich et Hubert Tardieu, “Modèles mentaux, modèles de situation et compréhension de textes”, in Les Modèles mentaux: Approche cognitive des représentations, Paris: Masson, 1993, pp.47-77.

18.

Michel Denis, Les images mentales, Paris: PUF, 1979.

19.

Michel Denis, “Imagerie mentale”, in Olivier Houdé, Danierl Kayser, Olivier Koenig, Joëlle Proust et François Rastier, Vocabulaire de sciences cognitives, Paris:PUF, 1998.

20.

Peeters Benoît, Case, Planche, Récit, Paris: Casterman, 1998.

21.

Thierry Groensteen, L’Univers des mangas: une introduction à la bande dessinée japonaise, Paris: Casterman, 1991.

22.

YONESAWA Yoshihiro, “ソジョ壊れ年報”, ソジョ壊れの歴史 1, 平凡社, 1991, pp.4-8.

대중서사연구