바로가기메뉴

본문 바로가기 주메뉴 바로가기

대중서사연구

A Study of Cooking-Showdown Cartoons

대중서사연구 / 대중서사연구, (P)1738-3188; (E)27139964
2013, v.0 no.30, pp.619-647
https://doi.org/10.18856/jpn.2013..30.018

  • Downloaded
  • Viewed

Abstract

The Cooking-Showdown Cartoon is the site where the life of food and the cultural life of cartoons meet in a dramatic confrontation. A Cooking-Showdown Cartoon's plot gains plausibility only if its method for representing taste is persuasive. We can therefore expect Cooking-Showdown Cartoons to have the most advanced techniques for representing taste. This paper analyzes how Cooking-Showdown Cartoons represent the ‘pursuit of taste’ and investigates how this technique corresponds with the overall theme of Cooking-Showdown Cartoons. In brief, the first technique for representing taste is emphasizing the quality of the ingredients. Showing the difficulty involved in obtaining these ingredients serves to emphasize the taste of the dishes made with them. The second technique is emphasis on skill. Using his culinary skills, the hero is able to defeat the villain who uses superior ingredients. The third technique is the function of the food critics, who with their refined palates and moral bearing act in these texts as mirrors of taste. Since these techniques are objective descriptions of taste, we can call it an ‘objective representation of taste.’ The final and most powerful technique employed in Cooking-Showdown Cartoons is food from the heart. It is the hero's good and true heart that enables him to defeat the villain who otherwise has the same skill level. These foods can persuade the readers by appealing to subjective values like the heart or memory. This technique can therefore be called a ‘subjective representation of taste.’Cooking-Showdown Cartoons have a serial system and thus have serial text. The objective description of taste plays a central role in these serial texts, lending them probability of plot and making them entertaining. The whole text of Cooking-Showdown Cartoons comprises a dramatic plot that has a stable-instable-stable structure. This process shows the final showdown between hero and villain. The most important and powerful technique for representing taste is the subjective representation at this showdown. Although the plot follows a melodramatic trajectory, the finale of Cooking-Showdown Cartoons is unfulfilled, since the villain is invited to the final festival. We can find no development in the whole text. The world of Cooking- Showdown Cartoons regresses to the first situation in the plot. The finale of Cooking-Showdown Cartoons can have two results and qualities, depending on one's point of view. First, it can be read as an ultimate forgiveness narrative. In this case, Cooking-Showdown Cartoons are very positive texts. Secondly, according to a different viewpoint, it can be read as a tool to distribute capitalism. This is because the world of the finale is exactly the same as the world in which the text begins, where capitalism dominates the world with violence.

keywords
만화, 요리만화, 요리대결만화, 맛의 재현, 맛의 객관적 묘사, 맛의 주관적 묘사, Cartoon, Cooking Cartoon, Cooking-Showdown Cartoon, representation of taste, objective representation of taste, subjective representation of taste

Reference

1.

다이스케 테라사와, <미스터 초밥왕>, 총 27권. 학산문화사, 1993-2012.

2.

박하·허영만·김재연, <짜장면> 총11권, 학산문화사, 1999-2001.

3.

허영만, <식객> 제 1권, 김영사, 2003.

4.

사이조 신지, <철냄비짱> 총 26권, 최윤선 역, 대원씨아이, 2000-2010.

5.

김응교, 「재일조선인 조선어 시 동인지 <종소리> 연구」, 현대문학연구 제34집, 2008. 237-276쪽.

6.

최수웅, 「요리만화의 스토리텔링 양상 연구」, 인문콘텐츠 제18호, 2010. 147-166쪽.

7.

김기홍, 「음식 스토리텔링과 만화」. 글로벌문화콘텐츠 제8호, 2012. 25-55쪽.

8.

박노현, 텔레비전 드라마 미학 연구 , 동국대학교 대학원 박사학위 논문, 2008.

9.

손상익, 만화로 여는 세상 , 고려원 미디어, 1996.

10.

이종대, 희곡의 세계 , 태학사, 1997.

11.

이상섭, 아리스토텔레스의 시학 연구 , 문학과 지성사, 2002.

12.

박인하, 장르만화의 세계 , 살림, 2004.

13.

오시로 요시타케, 만화의 문화기호론 , 김이랑 역, 눈빛, 1996.

14.

로즈마리 잭슨, 환상성 , 서강여성문학연구회 역, 문학동네, 2003.

15.

아리스토텔레스, 수사학 , 이종오 역, 리젬, 2007.

16.

이상섭, 문학비평용어사전 , 민음사, 2009.

대중서사연구