A Comparison of American and Korean Experimental Studies on Positive Behavior Support within a Multi-Tiered System of Supports
(University of South Florida)
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to summarize the empirical literature on implementation of positive behavior support (PBS) within a multi-tiered system of supports in American and Korean schools and to compare its key features and outcomes in an attempt to suggest future directions for development of a Korean school-wide PBS model and implementation manuals as well as directions for future research. Twenty-four American articles and 11 Korean articles (total 35 articles) that reported the outcomes of implementation of PBS at a tier 1 and/or tier 2, or tier 3 level and that met established inclusion criteria were analyzed using systematic procedures. Comparisons were made in the areas of key features and outcomes of PBS in addition to general methodology (e.g., participants, design, implementation duration, dependent measures) at each tier of PBS. The results indicated that positive outcomes for student behavior and other areas were reported across tiers in all American and Korean studies. At the tier 1 level, teaching expectations and rules were the primary focus of PBS in American and Korean schools. However, Korean schools focused on modifying the school and classroom environments and teaching social skills whereas American schools focused on teacher training on standardized interventions or curricular by experts and teacher support during implementation of PBS. At the tier 2 level, more American studies reported implementation of tier 2 interventions within school-wide PBS, and Check/In Check/Out (CICO) was found to be the most commonly used tier 2 intervention. The results also indicated that in comparison to Korean schools, American schools were more likely to use systematic screening tools or procedures to identify students who need tier 2 interventions and more likely to promote parental involvement with implementing interventions. At the tier 3 level, more Korean studies reported the outcomes of individualized interventions, but more American studies reported that designing individualized intervention plans based on comprehensive functional behavior assessment results and establishment of systematic screening systems were focused when implementing individualized interventions. Furthermore, few Korean studies reported the assessment of procedural integrity, social validity, and contextual fit in implementing PBS across tiers, indicating the need for development of valid instruments that could be used in assessing these areas. Based on these results, limitations of the study and suggestions for future research are discussed.
- keywords
- 긍정적 행동지원, 학교차원, 다층지원체계, 일반학교, 실험연구, 한국과 미국의 연구 비교, positive behavior support, school wide PBS, MTSS, multi-tiered intervention, comparison of American and Korean studies
Reference
강삼성, 이효신 (2012). 학급수준의 긍정적 행동지원이 통합학급 초등학생의 문제행동과 학교생활 만족도에 미치는 영향. 정서․행동장애연구, 28(3), 1-35.
김경양, 남보람, 김영란, 박지연 (2010). 학교차원의 긍정적 행동지원에 관한 문헌연구: 보편적 지원의 실행과 성과를 중심으로. 특수교육, 9(3), 117-140.
김미선, 박지연 (2005). 학급차원의 긍정적인 행동지원이 문제행동을 보이는 초등학교 장애학생과 그 또래의 문제행동에 미치는 영향. 특수교육학연구, 40(2), 355-376.
김미선, 송준만 (2006). 학교차원의 긍정적 행동지원이 초등학교 학생들의 문제행동과 학교 분위기에 미치는 영향. 특수교육학연구, 41(3), 207-227.
김보경, 박지연 (2017). 학년 단위의 긍정적 행동지원을 통해 실시된 보편적 지원이 통합학급초등학생의 사회적 능력, 수업참여행동 및 학교분위기에 대한 인식에 미치는 영향. 정서․행동장애연구, 33(1), 85- 105.
김영란 (2009). 보편적 차원의 긍정적 행동지원에 관한 문헌연구. 특수교육저널: 이론과 실천, 10(4), 81-106.
김영표 (2018). 학교차원 긍정적 행동 지원에 관한 국내 연구 경향 분석. 예술인문사회융합멀티미디어논문지, 8(1), 229-236.
김예리, 박지연 (2017). 학년차원의 긍정적 행동지원을 통해 실시된 표적집단 중재 실행연구. 정서행동장애연구, 33(3), 297-324.
김유리, 양영모, 노진아 (2015). 긍정적 행동지원 관련 단일 대상 연구의 동향 및 질적 지표에 의한 연구방법의 분석. 특수아동교육연구, 17(1), 51-81.
김지영, 고혜정 (2014). 지적장애 학생을 대상으로 한 긍정적 행동지원(PBS) 연구 메타분석: 국내 실험 연구를 중심으로. 특수교육재활과학연구, 53(1), 159-178.
나현정, 장은진, 한미령, 조광순 (2018). 학급차원의 보편정 긍정적 행동지원이 초등학생들의 문제행동 감소와 학업수행 증진에 미치는 영향. 한국심리학회지: 학교, 15(1), 91-109.
문병훈, 이영철 (2014). 지적장애학생을 위한 긍정적 행동지원(PBS) 메타분석: 최근 15년간(1999년-2013년) 국내 학위논문 및 학술지 논문을 중심으로. 지적장애연구, 16(1), 71-92.
문병훈, 이영철 (2016). 학교차원의 긍정적 행동지원이 초등 지적장애학생과 비장애학생의 문제행동 및 학교생활 만족도에 미치는 영향. 특수교육학연구, 51(2), 71-92.
박재천 (2017. 11. 12). 학생이 교사 위협ㆍ욕설ㆍ성희롱... 충북 올해 교권침해 59건. 연합뉴스
윤은미, 김자경, 강혜진 (2007). 긍정적인 행동지원이 정신지체학생과 급우의 수업시간 문제행동에 미치는 영향. 교사교육연구, 46(2), 1-22.
이동철, 이재원 (2011). 학급차원의 긍정적 행동지원이 통합체육수업 시 장애학생의 수업행동, 교사와의 상호작용, 신체활동에 미치는 효과. 한국특수체육학회지, 19(3), 33-48.
이동형 (2014). 학생훈육에 대한 대안적 접근의 필요성. 한국심리학회 학술대회 자료집, 2014(1), 178-178.
이선아, 이효신 (2015). 초등학교 학생의 수업 중 문제행동 개선을 위한 학급차원의 긍정적 행동지원의 적용. 정서․행동장애연구, 31(2), 61-84.
이성용, 김진호 (2017). 키워드 네트워크 분석을 통한 국내 긍정적 행동지원 연구동향 분석. 지적장애연구, 19(2), 147-172.
이주연, 정제영, 박주형, 주현준, 정성수 (2013). 학교폭력 예방 교육 및 치료 기관으로서 Wee센터 운영 실태 분석. 교육행정학연구, 31(2), 67-89.
이효정, 김은혜 (2018). 학교차원의 긍정적 행동지원 실행 연구 최신 동향-2012-2017년 국내외 학술지를 중심으로. 정서․행동장애연구, 34(1), 217-237.
장은진 (2017). 초등학교 학급차원 보편적 긍정적 행동지원 모형개발. 사회과학연구. 28(1), 175-191.
정은주 (2013). 초등학교 일반학급에서 긍정적 행동지원을 적용한 연구에 관한 문헌 분석. 특수교육저널: 이론과 실천, 14(3), 85-110.
차재경, 김진호 (2014). 학급단위의 보편적 차원 긍정적 행동지원이 통합학급 학생들의 수업 참여행동과 방해행동에 미치는 영향. 지적장애연구, 16(4), 85-109.
최진오 (2010). 학년 단위 긍정적 행동지원 모형 개발. 특수교육저널: 이론과 실천, 11(2), 311-332.
최하영 (2017). 일반 초․중․고등학교에서 보편적 차원의 긍정적 행동지원을 적용한 국내 실험 연구 분석. 행동분석․지원연구, 4(2), 23-43.
Bambara, L., & Kern L. (2005). Individualized supports for students with problem behaviors. New York: Guilford Press.
Bradshaw, C. P., Waasdorp, T. E., & Leaf, P. J. (2012). Effects of school-wide positive behavioral interventions and supports on child behavior problems. Pediatrics. 130(5), e1136- e1145
Bruhn, A. L., Lane, K. L., & Hirsch, S. E. (2014). A review of tier 2 interventions conducted within multitiered models of behavioral prevention. Journal of Emotional and Behavioral Disorders, 22(3), 171-189.
Bruhn, A. L., Woods-Groves, S., Fernando, J., Choi, T., & Troughton, L. (2017). Evaluating technology-based self-monitoring as a tier 2 intervention across middle school settings. Behavioral Disorders, 42(3), 119-131.
Bruni, T. P., Drevon, D., Hixson, M., Wyse, R., Corcoran, S., & Fursa, S. (2017). The effect of functional behavior assessment on school based interventions: A meta analysis of single case research. Psychology in the Schools, 54(4), 351-369.
Bunch-Crump, K. R., & Lo, Y. Y. (2017). An Investigation of Multitiered Behavioral Interventions on Disruptive Behavior and Academic Engagement of Elementary Students. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 19(4), 216-227.
Caldarella, P., Shatzer, R. H., Gray, K. M., Young, K. R., & Young, E. L. (2011). The effects of school-wide positive behavior support on middle school climate and student outcomes. RMLE Online, 35(4), 1-14.
Campbell, A., & Anderson, C. M. (2011). Check in/check‐out: A systematic evaluation and component analysis. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 44(2), 315-326.
Carr E. G. et al. (2002). Positive Behavior Support: Evolution of an Applied Science. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 4(1), 4-16, 20.
Carter, D. R., Carter, G. M., Johnson, E. S., & Pool, J. L. (2013). Systematic implementation of a Tier 2 behavior intervention. Intervention in School and Clinic, 48(4), 223-231.
Colvin, G., Sugai, G., Good, R. H., & Lee, Y. Y. (1997). Using active supervision and precorrection to improve transition behaviors in an elementary school. School Psychology Quarterly, 12(4), 344-363.
Dwyer, K., Rozewski, D., & Simonsen, B. (2012). A comparison of function-based replacement behaviors for escape-motivated students. Journal of Emotional and Behavioral Disorders, 20(2), 115-125.
Floress, M. T., & Jacoby, A. L. (2017). The Caterpillar Game: A SW-PBIS aligned classroom management system. Journal of Applied School Psychology, 33(1), 16-42.
Franzen, K., & Kamps, D. (2008). The utilization and effects of positive behavior support strategies on an urban school playground. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 10(3), 150-161.
Gage, N. A., Whitford, D. K., & Katsiyannis, A., (2018). A review of schoolwide positive behavior interventions and supports as a framework for reducing disciplinary exclusions. The Journal of Special Education, 1-10.
Horner, R. H., Sugai, G., Smolkowski, K., Eber, L., Nakasato, J., Todd, A., & Esperanza, J. (2009). A randomized, waitlist-controlled effectiveness trial assessing school-wide positive behavior support in elementary schools. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 11, 133-144.
Horner, R. H., et al. (2014). scaling up school-wide positive behavioral interventions and supports: experiences of seven states with documented success. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 16(4), 197-208.
Ingram, K., Lewis-Palmer, T., & Sugai, G. (2005). Function-based intervention planning: Comparing the effectiveness of FBA function-based and non-function-based intervention plans. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 7(4), 224-236.
Koegel, R. l. (2018). The evolution of positive behavioral intervention and support. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 20(1), 4-5.
Lane, K. L., Harris, K. R., Graham, S., Weisenbach, J. L., Brindle, M., & Morphy, P. (2008). The effects of self-regulated strategy development on the writing performance of second-grade students with behavioral and writing difficulties. The Journal of Special Education, 41(4), 234-253.
Lane, K. L., Graham, S., Harris, K. R., Little, M. A., Sandmel, K., & Brindle, M. (2010). Story writing: The effects of self-regulated strategy development for second-grade students with writing and behavioral difficulties. The Journal of Special Education, 44(2), 107-128.
Lassen, S. R., Steele, M. M., & Sailor, W. (2006). The relationship of school‐wide positive behavior support to academic achievement in an urban middle school. Psychology in the Schools, 43(6), 701-712.
Lewis T. J., Colvin G., & Sugai G. (2000). The Effects of Pre-Correction and Active Supervision on the Recess Behavior of Elementary Students. Education and treatment of Children, 23, 109-121.
Lewis, T. J., Powers, L. J., Kelk, M. J., & Newcomer, L. L. (2002). Reducing problem behaviors on the playground: An investigation of the application of schoolwide positive behavior supports. Psychology in the Schools, 39, 181-190.
Little, M. A., Lane, K. L., Harris, K. R., Graham, S., Story, M., & Sandmel, K. (2010). Self-regulated strategies development for persuasive writing in tandem with schoolwide positive behavioral support: Effects for second-grade students with behavioral and writing difficulties. Behavioral Disorders, 35(2), 157-179.
Luiselli, J. K., Putnam, R. F., Handler, M. W., & Feinberg, A. B. (2005). Whole‐school positive behaviour support: effects on student discipline problems and academic performance. Educational Psychology, 25(2-3), 183-198.
McIntosh, K., Campbell, A. L., Carter, D. R., & Rossetto Dickey, C. (2009). Differential effects of a tier two behavior intervention based on function of problem behavior. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 11(2), 82-93.
Miller, L. M., Dufrene, B. A., Sterling, H. E., Olmi, D. J., & Bachmayer, E. (2015). The effects of check-in/check-out on problem behavior and academic engagement in elementary school students. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 17(1), 28-38.
Miller, M. A., Fenty, N., Scott, T. M., & Park, K. L. (2011). An examination of social skills instruction in the context of small-group reading. Remedial and Special Education, 32(5), 371-381.
Oswald, K., Safran, S., & Johanson, G. (2005). Preventing trouble: Making schools safer places using positive behavior supports. Education and Treatment of Children, 265-278.
Ross, S. W., Romer, N., & Horner, R. H. (2012). Teacher well-being and the implementation of school-wide positive behavior interventions and supports. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 14(2), 118-128.
Ross, S. W., & Sabey, C. V. (2015). Check-in check-out+ social skills: Enhancing the effects of check-in check-out for students with social skill deficits. Remedial and Special Education, 36(4), 246-257.
Scheuermann, B., & Hall, J. A. (2008). Positive Behavioral Supports For The Classroom(1st ed.). 김진호, 김미선, 김은경, 박지연 (2009). <긍정적 행동지원>. 서울: 시그마프레스.
Sherrod, M., Getch, Y., & Ziomek-Daigle, J. (2009). The impact of positive behavior support to decrease discipline referrals with elementary students. Professional School Counseling, 12(6), 421-427.
Simonsen, B., Myers, D., & Briere III, D. E. (2011). Comparing a behavioral check-in/ check-out (CICO) intervention to standard practice in an urban middle school setting using an experimental group design. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 13(1), 31-48.
Solomon, B. G., Klein, S. A., Hintze, J. M., Cressey, J. M., & Peller, S. L. (2012). A meta‐analysis of school‐wide positive behavior support: An exploratory study using single‐case synthesis. Psychology in the Schools, 49(2), 105-121.
Stormont, M. Lewis, T. J., Beckner R., & Johnson, N. W. (2008). positive behavior support systems in early childhood and elementary settings. 노진아, 김연하 (2012) <프로그램 학교 차원의 긍정적 행동 지원 시스템을 실행하기>. 서울: 시그마프레스.
Sugai, G., Horner, R. H., Dunlap, G. Hieneman, M., Lewis, T. J., Nelson, C. M., Scott, T.,.....Wilcox, B. (2000). Applying Positive Behavior Support and Functional Behavioral Assessment in Schools. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 2(3), 131-143.
Sugai, G., & Horner, R. H. (2002). The evolution of discipline practices: School-wide positive supports. Child and Family Behavior Therapy, 24(1-2), 23-50.
Sugai, G., & Horner, R. R. (2006). A promising approach for expanding and sustaining school-wide positive behavior support. School Psychology Review, 35(2), 245-259.
Sugai, G., & Horner, R. H. (2008). What we know and need to know about preventing problem behavior in schools. Exceptionality, 16(2), 67-77.
Sugai, G., & Simonsen, B. (2012). Positive behavioral interventions and supports: History, defining features, and misconceptions. Center for PBIS & Center for Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports, University of Connecticut.
Todd, A. W., Campbell, A. L., Meyer, G. G., & Horner, R. H. (2008). The effects of a targeted intervention to reduce problem behaviors: Elementary school implementation of check in-check out. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 10(1), 46-55.
Turnbull, A., Bohanon, H., Griggs, P., Wickham, D., & Sailor, W. (2002). A Blueprint for Schoolwide Positive Behavior Support: Implementation of Three Components. Exceptional Children, 68(3), 377-402.
Turtura, J. E., Anderson, C. M., & Boyd, R. J. (2014). Addressing task avoidance in middle school students: Academic behavior check-in/check-out. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 16(3), 159-167.
Wolfe, K., Pyle, D., Charlton, C. T., Sabey, C. V., Lund, E. M., & Ross, S. W. (2016). A systematic review of the empirical support for Check-In Check-Out. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 18(2), 74-88.
Morrison, J. Q., & Jones, K. M. (2007). The effects of positive peer reporting as a class-wide positive behavior support. Journal of Behavioral Education, 16(2), 111-124.
Maggin, D. M., Zurheide, J., Pickett, K. C., & Baillie, S. J. (2015). A systematic evidence review of the check-in/check-out program for reducing student challenging behaviors. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 17(4), 197-208.
McDaniel, S. C., Lochman, J. E., Tomek, S., Powell, N., Irwin, A., & Kerr, S. (2018). Reducing risk for emotional and behavioral disorders in late elementary school: a comparison of two targeted interventions. Behavioral disorders, 43(3), 370-382.
Mendez, L. R., Ogg, J., Loker, T., & Fefer, S. (2013). Including parents in the continuum of school-based mental health services: a review of intervention program research from 1995 to 2010. Journal of Applied School Psychology, 29(1), 1-36.
- Downloaded
- Viewed
- 0KCI Citations
- 0WOS Citations