바로가기메뉴

본문 바로가기 주메뉴 바로가기

Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society

  • P-ISSN2466-2542
  • KCI

Article Contents

Prev Next
e-Submission

Vol.43 No.3

Citation Share

A Comparative Analysis of Subject Headings Related to Korea in the CCT and NDLSH

Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society / Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society, (P)2466-2542;
2012, v.43 no.3, pp.121-141
https://doi.org/10.16981/kliss.43.3.201209.121

(2012). A Comparative Analysis of Subject Headings Related to Korea in the CCT and NDLSH. Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society, 43(3), 121-141, https://doi.org/10.16981/kliss.43.3.201209.121

Abstract

This study compares and analyzes the numbers and characteristics of Korea-related subjects included in the 2008 Japanese edition of the National Diet Library Subject Headings (NDLSH) and the 2nd edition of the Chinese Classified Thesaurus(CCT). The analysis results show that 258 subjects, approximately twice as many as 137 subjects in CCT, were found in NDLSH. There are more pure subjects that exclude the references in CCT than in NDLSH. On the other hand, much more subjects are found in NDLSH in the event that personal names, corporate headings, and subjects combined with detailed headings are included. Meanwhile, more subjects are relatively engaged in the fields of politics, diplomacy, and military in CCT because CCT is characterized by socialism and by being a pro-North Korea. Moreover, the considerable numbers of subjects reflecting North Korea’s viewpoint are included in CCT. NDLSH changed only recently the names of both South and North Korea into the “Republic of Korea” and the “Democratic People's Republic of Korea”, respectively. On the other hand, CCT more frequently uses “Joseon” than “Korea”, and the distinction between the names is unclear. CCT thoroughly supports the stance of the developed country, directly involved in the disputable subjects between two countries such as “Dokdo”, “the East Sea”, “Dumangang”, and “Baekdusan”. Both heading lists consider “Balhae” as part of Chinese history in CCT, which has ignored the position of Korea.

keywords
주제명표목표, 일본국립국회도서관주제명표목표, 중국분류주제사표, Subjects headings, NDLSH, CCT

Reference

1.

국립중앙도서관 도서관연구소. 주요 6개국 국립도서관 한국관련 주제어 자료집. 서울 : 국립중앙도서관 도서관연구소, 2010.

2.

김영귀. “LC Subject Headings에 나타난 한국관련 주제명의 선정 및 표기에 관한 연구.” 부산여자대학교 논문집(인문사회과학대학편), 제44집(1997), pp.237-272.

3.

김정현. “미국의회도서관 주제명표목표의 한․중․일 관련 주제명표목의 변천과정 비교 분석.” 한국도서관․정보학회지, 제41권, 제2호(2010), pp.147-169.

4.

김정현. “주요 국가의 국가도서관 목록에 나타난 한국관련 주제명 비교 분석.” 정보관리학회지, 제28권, 제3호(2011), pp.141-162.

5.

문지현, 김정현. “｢国立国会図書館件名標目表｣의 한․중 관련 주제명표목에 대한 비교분석.” 한국도서관․정보학회지, 제42권, 제1호(2011), pp.247-267.

6.

문지현, 김정현. “｢中国分类主题词表｣의 한․일 관련 주제명에 대한 비교 분석.” 한국도서관․정보학회지, 제42권, 제3호(2011), pp.331-350.

7.

윤정옥. “미국의회도서관 주제명표목표(LCSH)의 한국과 일본 관련 주제표목의 비교 연구.” 도서관, 제56권, 제1호(2001), pp.30-55.

8.

최석두. “｢中國分類主題詞表｣의 형식과 구조.” 國會圖書館報, Vol.39, No.6(2002), pp.29-48.

9.

Kim, Joy. Library of Congress Subject Headings : Related to Korea and East Asia in General.[Unknown] : Association for Asian Studies, 1980.

10.

永森 光晴, 杉本 重雄. “国会図書館件名標目表(NDLSH)のSKOS化とそのグラフィカルブラウザの作成.” ディジタル図書館, Vol.31(2006), pp.13-21.

11.

村上幸二, “BSH(基本件名標目表)とNDLSH(国立国会図書館件名標目表)の計量的比較分析.” 紀要40(2009), pp.135-147.

12.

国立国会図書館. 国立国会図書館件名標目表2008年度版.<http://www.ndl.go.jp/jp/library/data/ndl_ndlsh.html>. [인용 2012. 8. 15].

13.

中国分类主题词表Web版. <http://cct.nlc.gov.cn/login.aspx> [인용 2012. 8. 15].

14.

中国图书馆《中国图书馆分类法》编辑委员会 编. 中国分类主题词表. 第二版. 北京 : 北京图书馆出版社, 2005.

15.

Web NDL Authorities 国立国会図書館典拠データ検索・提供サービス.<http://id.ndl.go.jp/auth/ndlsh> [인용 2012. 8. 10].

Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society

e-Submission OA Policy