바로가기메뉴

본문 바로가기 주메뉴 바로가기

logo

논문 상세

이전 다음
논문 투고

Vol.43 No.4
Citation Share

도서관의 경제적 가치측정 연구의 탐색적 메타분석

An Exploratory Meta Analysis of Library Economic Valuation Studies

한국문헌정보학회지 / Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science, (P)1225-598X; (E)2982-6292
2009, v.43 no.4, pp.117-137
https://doi.org/10.4275/KSLIS.2009.43.4.117
정혜경 (KDI국제정책대학원대학교)
고영만 (성균관대학교)
심원식 (성균관대학교)
표순희 (이화여자대학교)
정혜경, 고영만, 심원식, & 표순희. (2009). 도서관의 경제적 가치측정 연구의 탐색적 메타분석. 한국문헌정보학회지, 43(4), 117-137, https://doi.org/10.4275/KSLIS.2009.43.4.117
  • 다운로드 수
  • 조회수
PDF 다운로드

초록

본 연구는 도서관의 경제적 가치를 실증적으로 측정한 국내․외 42개의 선행연구들을 수집․정리하고, 상이하게 나타난 투자수익률이나 비용편익비율을 어떻게 해석해야 하는지를 메타분석을 통해서 통계적인 방법으로 파악하고자 한다. 메타분석법은 도서관의 경제적 가치측정 연구들이 제시한 수치를 통계적인 방법으로 분석하여 그 결과를 객관적으로 종합하기 위하여 적용되었다. 선행연구를 토대로 6개의 변인(조사시점, 도서관 유형, 연구방법, 혜택범위, 서비스범위, 1인당 GDP)을 도출하였고, 이들을 대상으로 6개의 가설을 설정하였다. 메타 회귀분석 결과, 혜택의 범위(직접효과, 간접효과) 및 국민 1인당 GDP의 수준에 따라 투자수익률의 일관성 있는 예측이 가능하다는 결과가 나타났다. 본 연구는 도서관의 경제적 가치 분야에서 수행된 국내 최초의 메타분석으로서, 이 분야의 연구에서 도출된 결과를 정책결정에 적용하는 데 도움이 될 것으로 기대된다.

keywords
메타분석, 투자수익률, 경제적 가치, 도서관 가치측정 연구, Meta-analysis, Return On Investment (ROI), Library Valuation Study, Meta-analysis, Return On Investment (ROI), Library Valuation Study

Abstract

This study aims to grasp how to understand the difference in return on investment (ROI) or the cost-benefit ratio in forty-two domestic and overseas studies of library valuation, using a meta-analytical review method. Meta-analysis, a quantitative analysis on the findings of previous studies, was conducted to gather the general findings and lessons from prior empirical research. The results of meta-regression analysis indicate that the pattern of findings is consistent with our expectations regarding the effect of benefit scope and per capita GDP included in the ROI figure. This study appears to be the first meta-analytical review conducted on library valuations and the findings provide strong implications for the policy-making process.

keywords
메타분석, 투자수익률, 경제적 가치, 도서관 가치측정 연구, Meta-analysis, Return On Investment (ROI), Library Valuation Study, Meta-analysis, Return On Investment (ROI), Library Valuation Study

참고문헌

1.

김동석, 조동호, 고영만. 2003. 디지털 도서관의 경제성 평가: 국립디지털도서관 DLP 사례연구.ꡔ정보관리학회지ꡕ, 20(4): 159-193.

2.

김병준, 변우혁. 2003. CVM 질문형에 따른 지불의사액 비교분석. ꡔ한국임학회지ꡕ, 92(3): 270-275.

3.

노정순. 2008. 문헌정보학분야에서 메타분석 연구에 관한 고찰. ꡔ한국문헌정보학회지ꡕ, 42(1):45-62.

4.

노정순. 2009. 사서의 직무만족도에 관한 메타분석 연구. 정보관리학회지 , 25(3): 273-296.

5.

오성삼. 2002. ꡔ메타분석의 이론과 실제ꡕ. 건국대학교 출판부.

6.

정혜경, 정은주. 2008. 공공도서관 문화프로그램의 경제성 분석에 관한 연구. ꡔ정보관리학회지ꡕ,25(3): 377-392.

7.

표순희, 정동열. 2008. 공공도서관 경제적 이용가치 측정방안에 관한 연구. ꡔ한국문헌정보학회지ꡕ,42(2): 219-234.

8.

Aabø, Svanhild. 2004. “Valuing the Benefits of Public Libraries." Information Economics and Policy, 17(2): 175-198.

9.

Aabø, Svanhild. 2005. “Are Public Libraries Worth Their Price?" New Library World, 106(11/12): 487-95.

10.

Aabø, Svanhild. 2009. “Libraries and Return on Investment(ROI): A Meta-Analysis." New Library World, 110(7/8): 311-324.

11.

Aabø, Svanhild, & Audunson, R. 2002. “Rational Choice and Valuation of Public Libraries:Can Economic Models for Evaluating Non-Market Goods be Applied to Public Libraries?"Journal of Library and Information Science, 34(1): 5-16.

12.

Aabø, Svanhild, & Strand, Jon. 2004. “Public Library Valuations, Nonuse Values, and Altruistic Motivations." Library and Informations Science Research, 26(3): 351-372.

13.

Arrow, K., Solow, R., Portney, P., Leamer, E., Radner, R., & Schuman H. 1993. “Report of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Panel on Contingent Valuation." Federal Register, 58(10): 4016-4614.

14.

Bolton Metropolitan Borough Council and MLA North West. 2005. Bolton's Museum, Library and Archive Services: An Economic Evaluation. Metropolitan Borough Council, Bolton.

15.

Boyle, K.J., Poe, G.L., & Bergstrom, J.C. 1994. “What Do We Know about Groundwater Values?: Preliminary Indications from a Meta Analysis of Contingent-Valuation Studies." American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 76(5): 1055-1061.

16.

Buffalo and Erie County Public Library. 2006. Erie County Taxpayers: Your Return on Investment in the Library. [online]. [cited 2009. 10].<http://www.buffalolib.org/aboutthelibrary/ect.asp>.

17.

Carson, R.T. 1997. “Contingent Valuation Surveys and Tests of Insensitivity to Scope." in R.J. Kopp, W.W. Pommerehne, and N. Schwarz, eds., Determining the Value ofNon-Marketed Goods: Economic, Psychological, and Policy Relevant Aspects of ContingentValuation Methods. Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers.

18.

Chung, Hye-Kyung. 2007. “Measuring the Economic Value of Special Libraries." TheBottom Line: Managing Library Finances, 20(1): 30-44.

19.

Chung, Hye-Kyung. 2008. “The Contingent Valuation Method in Public Libraries." Journalof Librarianship and Information Science, 40(2): 71-80.

20.

Colorado State Library. 2006. “Public Libraries-a Wise Investment: Denver Public Library."Library Research Service. [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://www.lrs.org/publi/roi/>.

21.

Colorado State Library. Library Research Service. 2006. “Public Libraries-a WiseInvestment: Douglas Public Library." [online]. [cited 2009. 10].<http://www.lrs.org/public/roi/>.

22.

Colorado State Library. Library Research Service. 2006. “Public Libraries-a Wise Investment: Eagle Valley Library District." [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://www.lrs.org/public/roi/>.

23.

Colorado State Library. Library Research Service. 2006. “Public Libraries-a Wise Investment: Fort Morgan Public Library." [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://www.lrs.org/public/roi/>.

24.

Colorado State Library. Library Research Service. 2006. “Public Libraries-a Wise Investment: Mesa County Library District." [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://www.lrs.org/public/roi/>

25.

Colorado State Library. Library Research Service. 2006. “Public Libraries-a Wise Investment: Montrose Library District." [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://www.lrs.org/public/roi/> .

26.

Colorado State Library. Library Research Service. 2006. “Public Libraries-a Wise Investment: Rangeview Library District." [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://www.lrs.org/public/roi/>.

27.

Elliott, Donald S., Holt, Glen E., Hayden, Sterling W., & Holt, Leslie Edmonds. 2007. Measuring Your Library's Value: How To Do a Cost-Benefit Analysis for Your Public Library. Chicago: ALA.

28.

Griffiths, J.M., King, D., & Lynch, T. 2004. Taxpayer Return on Inivestment in Florida Public Libraries: Summary Report. [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://dlis.dos.state.fl.us/bld/roi/pdfs/ROISummaryreport.pdf>

29.

Griffiths, J.M., King, D., & Aemi, S. 2006. Taxpayer Return on Investment in Florida Public Libraries. [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://actforlibraries.org/old%20site/researstates.php>

30.

Hanemann, W.M. 1994. “Valuing the Environment Through Contingent Valuation." Journal of Economic Perspective, 8(4): 19-43.

31.

Hausman, J.A. ed. 1993. Contingent Valuation: A Critical Assessment. Amsterdam: North-Holland.

32.

Harless, David W., & Allen, Frank R. 1999. “Using the Contingent Valuation Method to Measure Patron Benefits of Reference Desk Service in an Academic Library." College & Research Libraries, 60(1): 56-69.

33.

Hider, P. 2008. “Using the Contingent Valuation Method for Dollar Valuations of Library Services." Library Quarterly, 78(4): 437-58.

34.

Holt, Glen, Hold, Leslie, Hayden, Sterling, & Elliott, Donald. 2003. Cost Benefit Analysis Manual for Medium-Sized And Smaller Public Libraries. [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://www.webjunction.org/do/'displayContent?id=12389>

35.

Holt, G. et al. 2001. Public Library Benefits Valuation Study. [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://www.slpl.lib.mo.us/using/valuationg.htm>

36.

Holt, Glen E., & Elliott, Donald. 2003. “Measuring Outcomes: Applying Cost-Benefit Analysis to Middle-Sized and Smaller Public Libraries." Library Trends, 51(3): 424-40.

37.

Holt, Glen E., Elliott, Donald, & Moore, Amonia. 1999. “Placing a Value on Public Library Services." Public Libraries, (March/April): 98-108.

38.

Imholz, S., & Arns, J.W. 2007. Worth their Weigh: An Assessment of the Evlolving Field of Library Valuation, Americans for Libraries Council. New York : NY.

39.

Indiana Business Research Center. 2007. The Economic Impact of Libraries in Indiana. [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://www.incontext.indiana.edu/2007/december/6.asp>.

40.

Johansson-Stenman, O. 1998. “The Importance of Ethics in Environmental Economics with a Focus on Existence Values." Environmental and Resource Economics, 11(3): 429-42.

41.

Kahneman, D., & Knetsch, J.L. 1992. “Valuing Public Goods: the Purchases of Moral Satisfaction." Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 22(1): 57-70.

42.

Kamer, P.M. 2005. “Placing an Economic Value on the Services of Public Libraries in Suffolk county." New York: A Research Report by the Long Island Association. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://scls.sufflok.lib.ny.us/pdf/librarystudy.pdf>.

43.

Kamer, P.M. 2006. The Economic Value of the Middle Country Public Library in Suffolk County, New York. [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://actforlibraries.org/old%20site/researchstates.php>.

44.

Kotchen, M.J., & Reiling, S.D. 2000. “Environmental Attitudes, Motivations, and Contingent Valuation of Nonuse Values: A Case Study Involving Endangered Species." Ecological Economics, 32(1): 93-107.

45.

Levin, Driscoll, & Fleeter. 2006. Value for Money: Southwestern Ohio's Return from Investment in Public Libraries. [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://www.9libraries.info/docs/EcononmicBenefitsStudy.pdf>.

46.

Library Council of New South Wales. Enriching Communities: the Value of Public Libraries in New South Wales. Sydney, Australia. : State Library of New South Wales.

47.

Luther, Judy. 2008. University Investment in the Library: What's the Return?: A Case Study at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://libraryconnect.elsevier.com/whitepapers/lcwp0101.pdf>.

48.

McClure, C.R., Fraser, B.T., Nelson, T.W., & Robbins, J.B. 2001. Economic Benefits and 2009. 10]. <http://www.natlib.govt.nz/catalogues/library-documents/economic-valuation-nbd-nuc>.

49.

McDermott Miller Ltd. National Bibliographic Database and National Union Catalogue: Economic Valuation. [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://www.natlib.govt.nz/catalogues/library-documents/economic-valuation-nbd-nuc>.

50.

Missingham, Roxanne. 2005. “Libraries and Economic Value: A Review of Recent Studies." Performance Measurement and Metrics, 6(3): 142-58.

51.

Morris, A., Hawkins, M. & Sumsion, J. 2001. The Economic Value of Public Libraries, Resource: The Council for Museums, Archives and Libraries. London.

52.

Noonan, Douglas S. 2003. “Contingent Valuation and Cultural Resources: A Meta-Analytic Review of the Literature." Journal of Cultural Economics, 27: 159-176.

53.

NorthStar Economic, Inc. 2008. The Economic Contribution of Wisconsin Public Libraries to the Economy of Wisconsin, Madison, WI. [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://dpi.wi.gov/pdf/wilibraryimpact.pdf>.

54.

Nunes, Paulo A.L.D., & Schokkaert, Erik. 2003. “Identifying the Warm Glow Effect in Contingent Valuation." Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 45(2): 231-245.

55.

Ojea, Elena, & Loureiro, Maria L. 2007. “Altruistic, Egoistic and Biospheric Values in Willingness to Pay (WTP) for Wildlife." Ecological Economics, 63(4): 807-814.

56.

Pung, C. Clarke, A., & Pattern, L. 2004. “Measuring the Economic Impact of the British Library.” New Review of Academic Librarianship, 10(1): 79-102.

57.

Steffen, Nicolle, Lietzau, Zeth, Lance, Keith Curry, Rybin, Amanda, & Molliconi, Carla. 2009. Public Libraries-a Wise Investment: A Return on Investment Study of Colorado Libraries. [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://www.dpld.org/files/aboutus/DCLroi.pdf>.

58.

Utah State Library Division. 2007. Return on Investment of Public Library Services to Utah's Economoy. [online]. [cited 2009. 10]. <http://library.utah.gov/documents/library/value/economic-impact_utah_libraries.pdf>.

한국문헌정보학회지

논문 투고 OA 정책