바로가기메뉴

본문 바로가기 주메뉴 바로가기

Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science

  • P-ISSN1225-598X
  • E-ISSN2982-6292

Article Contents

Prev Next
e-Submission

Vol.48 No.2

Citation Share

A Content Analysis of Picture Book Reviews in Korean Periodicals

Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science / Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science, (P)1225-598X; (E)2982-6292
2014, v.48 no.2, pp.331-352
https://doi.org/10.4275/KSLIS.2014.48.2.331

(2014). A Content Analysis of Picture Book Reviews in Korean Periodicals. Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science, 48(2), 331-352, https://doi.org/10.4275/KSLIS.2014.48.2.331

Abstract

In this study, the picture book reviews shown in Korean periodicals were analyzed to provide the developmental foundation for picture book reviews and expand the professional area of librarians as the producers of book review. Through the literature research and the Delphi Technique the desirable standard of book reviews was suggested, the contents in domestic book review mediums were analyzed for the rightness of describing based on the standard of the book review and henceforward the way of development was suggested. The result from analysis of book review showed that the outstanding book reviews should be more produced based on the desirable standard of book review and the evaluative statements should be developed more than the descriptive statements. Depending on the mediums the contents of the book review were different by the book reviewers’ occupations, so the book reviewers should develop their professional knowledges in literature and art. Because the longer book review made the outstanding book review with the rightness of the desirable standard of book review, the certain quantity of book review should be needed and the role of librarians as the book reviewers should be further extended.

keywords
Review Criteria, Children’s Book Review, Fiction Picture Book, Non-fiction Picture Book, Content of Book Review, 서평기준, 어린이 도서 서평, 픽션 그림책, 논픽션 그림책, 서평의 내용

Reference

1.

김상호. 1994. 문헌비평을 위한 서평의 분석적 고찰: 서평문화와 출판저널을 중심으로. 한국비블리아학회지 , 7: 247-262.

2.

김상호. 2004. 도서관서평의 구조와 표현 - 사서의 목소리 내기. 書誌學硏究 , 29: 346-360.

3.

심윤희. 2003. 아동 도서에 대한 신문의 북리뷰 實態와 그 影響에 관한 硏究 - 동아일보, 문화일보, 조선일보, 중앙일보 4개 일간지를 중심으로 . 석사학위논문, 서강대학교 언론 대학원 출판전공.

4.

심향분, 현은자. 2005. 서평전문지에 나타난 그림책 서평 분석 연구. 아동학회지 , 26(1): 203-216.

5.

이란주. 2011. 어린이자료 전문서평지 개발 방안에 관한 연구. 한국비블리아학회지 , 22(4): 341-359.

6.

이상금. 1999. 그림책을 보고 크는 아이들 . 서울: 사계절.

7.

장지숙. 2003. 어린이 도서 서평 매체에 관한 연구 . 박사학위논문, 이화여자대학교 대학원 문헌정보학과.

8.

한윤옥. 2008. 독서교육과 자료의 활용 . 서울: 한국도서관협회.

9.

동아일보 아카이브. [online] [cited 2013. 1. 10.]<http://www.donga.com.ca.skku.edu:8080/pdf/archive>

10.

오픈키드. [online] [cited 2013. 2. 10.] <http://www.openkid.co.kr/webzine>

11.

조선일보 아카이브. [online] [cited 2013. 1. 10.]<http://srchdb1.chosun.com.ca.skku.edu:8080/pdf/i_archive>

12.

학교도서관 저널. [online] [cited 2013. 2. 10.] <http://slj.co.kr>

13.

한국잡지협회. [online] [cited 2012. 9. 20.] <http://museum.kmpa.or.kr>

14.

Bishop, K. and P. Van Order. 1998. “Reviewing children's books: A Content analysis."Library Quarterly, 68(2): 145-182.

15.

Burchette, R. B. 1992. An Examination of Children's Book Reviews Media. M.L.S. thesis, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

16.

Bushin, O. M. and Steinfirst, S. 1989. “Criticism of Artwork in Children's Picture Books:A Content Analysis." Journal of Youth Services in Libraries, 2(1): 256-266.

17.

Crow, S. R. 1986. “The Reviewing of Controversial Juvenile Books: A Study." School Media Quarterly, 14(4): 83-85.

18.

Dodson, J. S. 1983. A Content Analysis of Children's Picture Story Book Reviews Published in Selected Journals During the Year, 1981. Ph. D. diss., Southern Illinois University.

19.

Galloway, Mabel Louise. 1965. An Analytical Study of the Extent and Nature of the Reviewing of Juvenile Books in Eight Journals and Newspapers with Special Regard to Their Usefulness as Selection Aids for School Libraries. Ed. D. diss., Columbia University.

20.

Kennemer, P. 1980. An Analysis of Review of Books of fiction for Children and Adolescents Published in Major Selection Aids in the United States in 1979. Ph. D. diss., University of Colorado.

21.

Matson, E. A. 2008. The Birth of Children's Book Reviews, 1918-1929. A Master's Paper for the M. S. in L. S degree. University of North Carolina.

22.

Stewig, J. W. 1980. “Picture books: What do reviews really review?" Top of the News, 37(3): 83-84.

23.

Walter, Virginia A. 2009. 김경혜 역. 어린이와 도서관 올바른 이해와 실천 . 서울: 국립어린이청소년도서관.

24.

Weber, Rosemary. 1979. “The Reviewing of children's and Young adult books in 1977."Top of the News 35, 1979(4): 131-137.

25.

Wilson, Margo and K. Bishop. 1999. “Criteria for reviewing children's books." Library Resources & Technical Services, 43(1): 3-13.

26.

Witucke, V. 1980. “A Comparative analysis of juvenile book review media." School Media Quarterly, 8(1): 153-160.

27.

Witucke, V. 1982. “The Performance of juvenile book review media." Serials Review, 8(Spring): 49-55.

Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science

e-Submission OA Policy