바로가기메뉴

본문 바로가기 주메뉴 바로가기

Korean Journal of Psychology: General

  • KOREAN
  • P-ISSN1229-067X
  • E-ISSN2734-1127
  • KCI

A Critical Overview on the Researches imployed Marcia's Concept of 'Identity Statuses'

Korean Journal of Psychology: General / Korean Journal of Psychology: General, (P)1229-067X; (E)2734-1127
1994, v.13 no.1, pp.167-185
A-Chung Park (Keimyung University)

Abstract

In the past 15 years approximately 50 empirical studies have sought in various ways to operationalize the concept of identity and investigate its personality and behavioral correlates. In recent years empirical research on ego identity has been dominated by Marcia's concept of "identity statuses" (I964). In Korea,considerable research on ego identity has appeared over the past 10 years. Empirical researches on ego identity were discussed and evaluated according to the following there standpoints in this review: 1) The measurement of ego identity, 2) The relation between Identity Status and other areas, and 3) The longterm stability of the identity statuses. In this research, some suggestions for future research were suggested. At first, the original step of categorizing the broad construct of identity into subtypes, each of which is subsequently evaluated by interview rather then questionnair, seem to have had a broad appeal to investigators. But the Identity Status Interview does not capture all Erikson had in mind, rather it strikes an optimal compromise between Erikson's clinical idiographic form of inquiry and that prescribed by nomothetic, empirical science. Still more crucial, however, is the question of the overall validity of Marcia's paradigm as a theoritical and empirical approach to the study of ego identity. Therefore, the identity status interview approach remains open to a number of methodological improvements. Secondly, in this research it has been suggested that ego identity be investigated not only as a static configuration but also in terms of developmental processes which contribute to the individual's acquistion of a "sense of who he is". It is important to add that "identity" cannot properly by understand as a developmental end-point. Rather, it must be assumed that processes mediating both identity consolidation continue beyond adolescence and throughout adulthood as the individual respons to crisis in his life situation. Thirdly, most of the researches on ego identity have taken the college students as subjects. From now on any other population such as the high school student, working youth should be taken as subjects in order to generalize broadly the existing research findings. Finally. though research on ego identity has increased considerably since 1970, the area is still relatively new in comparison with many other areas of adolescent developmental research. To sum up this study, two possible directions for future research are suggested. On one hand, considerable work remains to be done within the identity status paradigm. On the other, the study of both identity as process and of the variables mediating identity formation indicates a new point of departure for research requiring the developmental typological approach.

keywords

Korean Journal of Psychology: General