The cutoff criterion and the accuracy of the polygraph test for crime investigation

한유화; 박광배

Korean Psychological Journal of Culture and Social Issues

P-ISSN1229-0661
E-ISSN1229-0661
KCI

Home

OA Policy

Article Contents

e-Submission

Vol.14 No.4

Citation Share

The cutoff criterion and the accuracy of the polygraph test for crime investigation

Korean Psychological Journal of Culture and Social Issues / Korean Psychological Journal of Culture and Social Issues, (P)1229-0661; (E)1229-0661

2008, v.14 no.4, pp.103-117

& (2008). The cutoff criterion and the accuracy of the polygraph test for crime investigation. Korean Psychological Journal of Culture and Social Issues, 14(4), 103-117.

copy

Abstract

The polygraph test administered by the Korean Prosecutors Office for crime investigations customarily uses the score of -12 as the cutoff point separating the subjects who lie from those who tell the truth. The criterion used by the KPO is different from the one (-13) suggested by Backster (1963) who invented the particular method for lie detection. Based on the signal detection theory applied to the real polygraph test data obtained from real crime suspects by the KPO, the present study identified the score of -8 as an optimal criterion resulting in the highest overall accuracy of the polygraph test. The classification of the subjects with the score of -8 as the criterion resulted in the highest accuracy (83.17%) compared with the accuracies of classifications with the Backster's criterion (76.24%) and the KPO's criterion (80.20%). However, the new criterion was also found to result in more false-positive cases. Based on the results from the present study, it was recommended to use the score of -8 as the criterion when the overall accuracy is important but the score of -12 or -13 when avoiding false-positive is more important than securing the overall accuracy.

keywords: polygraph test, cutoff point, signal detection theory, ROC curve, 거짓말탐지 검사(polygraph test), 판정기준 점수, 신호탐지 이론, ROC 곡선

Reference

대검찰청, (2008) 2007년 종합 심사 분석, 대검찰청

엄진섭 ; 지형기 ; 박광배, 폴리그라프 검사의 정확도 추정, 한국심리학회지: 사회문제

Albert, P. S., (2001) Latent class modeling approaches for assessing diagnostic error without a gold standard: With applications to p.53 immunohistochemical assays in bladder tumors, Biometrics

Backster,C., (1963) The Backster chart reliability rating method, Law and Order

Capps M., (1992) Analysis of Federal Polygraph Charts By Spot and Chart Total, Polygraph

Driscoll, L. N., (1987) The validity of the positive control physiological detection of deception technique, Jornal of Police Science and Administration

Ginton, A., (1982) A method for evaluating the use of the polygraph in a real-life situation, Journal of Applied Psychology

Goodman,L.A., (2002) Latent class analysis: The empirical study of latent types, latent variables, and latent structures. In : Applied Latent Class Analysis, Cambridge University

Honts,C.R., (1996) Criterion development and validity of the control question test in field application, The Journal of General Psychology

10.

Honts, C. R., (1988) A field study of the validity of the directed lie control question, Journal of Police Science and Administration

11.

Honts, C. R., (1994) Mental and physical countermeasures reduce the accuracy of the polygraph tests, Journal of Applied Psychology

12.

Horowitz, S. W., (1997) The role of comparison questions in physiological detection of deception, Psychophysiology

13.

Kircher,J.C., (1988) Human versus computerized evaluations of polygraph data in laboratory setting, Journal of Applied Psychology

14.

Kraemer H.C., (1992) Evaluating medical tests, objective and quantitative guidelines, London, Sage Publications

15.

Lazarsfeld, P. F., (1968) Latent Structure Analysis, Houghton Mifflin

16.

National Research Council, (2003) The Polygraph and Lie Detection. Committee to Review the Scientific Evidence on the Polygraph. Division of Behavioral and Social Sciences and Education, The National Academies Press

17.

Son-IlPak ; Hee-SeungKoo ; Cheol-YongHwang ; Hwa-YoungYoun, (2002) Application of Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) Curves for Clinical Diagnostic Tests, Korean Journal of Veterinary Clinic

18.

Patrick, C. J., (1991) Validity of the control question polygraph test: The problem of sampling bias, Journal of Applied Psychology

19.

Podlesny, J. A., (1978) Effectiveness of techniques and physiological measures in the detection of deception, Psychophysiology

20.

Podlesny, J. A. , (1993) Validity of the expanded-issue(modified general question) Polygraph technique in a simulated distributed-crime-roles context, Journal of Applied Psychology

21.

Raskin, D. C., (1978) Psychopathy and detection of deception in a prison population, Psychophysiology

22.

Raskin, D. C., (1989) Recent laboratory and field research on polygraph techniques. In : Credibility Assessment, Kluwer

23.

Rovner, L. I., (1979) Effects of information and practice on detection if deception, Psychophysiology

24.

Spencer,B.D., (2007) Estimating the accuracy of jury verdicts, Journal of Empirical Legal Studies

25.

Swets J.A., (1986) Form of empirical ROCs in discrimination and diagnostic tasks: Implications for theory and measurement of performance, Psychological Bulletin

26.

U.S. Congress, (1983) Scientific Validity of Polygraph Testing: A Research Review and Evaluation?A Technical Memorandum. OTA-TM-H-15, U.S. Government Printing Office

바로가기메뉴

Article Contents

Vol.14 No.4

The cutoff criterion and the accuracy of the polygraph test for crime investigation

Abstract

Reference

Korean Psychological Journal of Culture and Social Issues