Cultural ‘Tightness-Looseness’：A Multilevel Theory

Over the last two decades, there has been an explosion of research concerning the influence of culture on social psychological phenomena. The dimension of individualism and collectivism has been the focus of much empirical investigation, as evidenced in the abundance of published articles as well as books devoted to this dimension. As a result of the immense success of research on individualism-collectivism, there has been a dearth of research on other dimensions of culture. Thus, the central goal of this research is to expand upon cultural theories in social-organizational psychology by introducing theoretical approach to and empirical evidence for another cultural dimension, cultural tightness-looseness. Tightness-looseness has been defined as the degree to which norms are clearly defined and reliably imposed within cultures (Pelto, 1968). Specifically, a multi-level theory is reviewed, which examines cultural tightness-looseness in modern and complex societies, and integrates research from a variety of disciplines, including anthropology, sociology, and psychology, and illustrates the dynamic interplay between ecocultural and historical factors, the structure of situations, and psychological processes in tight and loose cultural systems. Finally, empirical evidence for this theory was covered.

keywords: 문화의 차원, 개인주의-집합주의, 사회규범, 경직성-유연성. 다차원 이론, dimensions of culture, individualism-collectivism, social norm, tightness-looseness, multilevel theory

Reference

김기범, (1995) 갈등과 중재：대인간의 갈등 상황에 대한 중재에 영향을 미치는 요인,

나은영, (1998) 한국문화의 이중성과 세대차의 근원에 관한 이론적 고찰 및 기존조사자료 재해석,

이종한, (1992) 공동체의식에 관한 개인주의-집단주의 관점에서의 비교문화적 분석,

정양은, (1976) 심리구조이론의 동서비교,

정태연, (2004) 문화의 새로운 차원 Tightness와 Looseness 분석,

조긍호, (2003) 한국인 이해의 개념틀, 서울：나남출판

조영호, (2002) 조직구성원의 개인주의-집합주의 성향과 심리적 계약에 관한 연구 ,

차재호, (1993) 현대 한국 사회에서의 집합주의 한국심리학회지：사회 및 성격, 한국심리학회

최상진, (2000) 한국인 심리학, 서울：중앙대학교 출판부

10.

한규석, (1991a) 집단주의-개인주의 이론의 현황과 그 전망,

11.

한규석, (1991b) 사회심리학 이론의 문화특수성：한국인의 사회심리학 연구를 위한 고찰,

12.

한규석, (1997) 사회심리학에서의 문화 비교 연구：현황 및 세계화 속의 과제 , 한국심리학회 학술위원회

13.

한규석, (2003) 사회심리학의 이해,

14.

한성열, (1994) 개인주의-집단주의와 지각된 소외감의 관련성 연구,

15.

(1981) Win- nipeg：University of Manitoba Press,

16.

Au,K.Y, (1999) Intra-cultural variation：Evidence and Implications for international Business Journal of International Business Studies,

17.

Berry, (1976) Human ecology and cognitive style：Comparative studies in cultural and psychological adaptation,

18.

Berry, (1997) Handbook of cross-cultural psychology,

19.

Bond, (1994) Into the heat of collectivism：A personal and scientific journey,

20.

Bond, (1996) Annual Review of Psychology,

21.

(1962) Intolerance of ambiguity as a person- ality variable Journal of Personality,

22.

Cha, (1994) Aspect of individualism and collec- tivism in Korea,

23.

Chan, (1998) Language use in Hong Kong at century's end, Hong Kong：Hong Kong University Press

24.

Chan, (1996) Tightness-looseness revisited：Some preliminary analyses in Japan and the United States International Journal of Psychology,

25.

Choi, (1994) We-ness：A Korean discourse of collectivism Psychology of the Korean people, Seoul：Dong-A Publishing & Printing Co Ltd

26.

Choi, (2001) Cheong：The socio- emotional grammar of Koreans International Jour- nal of Group Tensions,

27.

Choi, (2003) A conceptual exploration of the Korean self：In comparison of Western self Progress in asian social psychol- ogy：Conceptual and empirical contributions Volume 3, CT：Greenwood Publisher

28.

Douglas, (1982) Risk and culture：An essay on the selection of technical and environ- mental dangers Berkeley：University of California Press,

29.

London, (1954) The psychology of politics,

30.

(1949) Intolerance of ambiguity as an emotional perceptual personality variable Journal of Personality,

31.

In J, (1999) Psychological anthropology and the “levels of analysis” problem：We married the wrong cousin Latest contributions to cross-cultural psychology,

32.

Gelfand, (1998) Theory and empirical assessment of the cultural construct of tightness- looseness in the US and Japan Poster presented at the conference of the International Association of Cross-Cultural Psychology,

33.

& Berry, (1995) An ecocultural taxon- omy for cross-cultural psychology,

34.

Goffman, (1963) Stigma：Notes on the management of spoiled identity, NJ：Prentice- Hall

35.

Hannan, (1971) Aggregation and disaggregation in sociology, Lexington MA：Lexington Books

36.

Higgins,E.T, (1996) Sense-making as a method of prac- ticing a critical pedagogy in the multi-cultural classroom Paper presented at International Commu- nication Association annual meeting,

37.

Higgins, E. T, (1997) Emotional responses to goal attainment：Strength of regulatory focus as moderator Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,

38.

Beverly Hills, (1980) Culture's consequences：Interna- tional differences in work-related values,

39.

Jamieson, (1989) Need for structure in attitude formation and expression,

40.

In J, (1997) Handbook of cross-cultural psychology：Vol 3,

41.

Kandel, (1995) Essentials of neural science and behavior,

42.

Kim, (1998) High- versus low-context culture：A comparison of Chinese,

43.

Kim, (1997) ingroup and out- group distinction and mediation：Comparison of Korean and American students Progress in Asian social psychology Volume 1,

44.

Kim, (2004) Cultural tightness and looseness：A comparative study between Korea and the United States Paper presented at the International Congress of the International Association for Cross-Cultural Psy- chology,

45.

Matsumoto, (1997) Individual and collective processes in the construction of the self：Self- enhancement in the United States and self-criticism in Japan Journal of Personality and Social Psy- chology,

46.

Kurian, (1997) The new book of world rankings,

47.

Lomax, (1972) The evolutionary taxonomy of culture,

48.

Markus, (1991) Culture and self：Implication for cognition,

49.

Mischel, (1977) The interaction of person and situation Personality at the crossroads：Current issues in interactional psychology,

50.

& Newson, (1993) Personal need for structure：Individual differences in the desire for simple structure Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,

51.

Osgood, (1975) Cross-cultural universality of affective meaning IL：University of Illinois Press,

52.

Pelto, (1968) The differences between “tight” and “loose” societies,

53.

Price, (1974) Behavioral appro- priateness and situational constraint as dimension of social behavior Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,

54.

Roberts, (1978) Developing an interdisciplinary science of organi- zations, San Francisco：Jossey-Bass

55.

Rousseau, (1985) Issue of level in organizational research：Multilevel and cross-level perspectives Research in organizational values,

56.

Schwartz, (199419-45) Are there universal aspects in the structure and contents of human values Journal of Social Issues,

57.

Segall, (1997) Introduction to volume 3 In In J Handbook of cross-cultural psychology：Vol 3,

58.

Smith, (1993) Social psychology across cultures：Analysis and perspectives,

59.

Sternberg, (1982) Development lessons from the Korean experience：A review article Journal of Asian Studies,

60.

& Higgins, (1987) Automatic acti- vation of self-discrepancies and emotional syn- dromes：When cognitive structures influence affect Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,

61.

(1989) The self and social behavior in differing cultural contexts,

62.

Berman, (1990) “Cross-cultural studies of indi- vidualism and collectivism ” In J Nebraska Symposium on Motivation 1989 Lincoln：University of Nebraska Press,

63.

Triandis, H. C. , (1995) Individualism and collectivism., CO：Westview Press

64.

& Suh, (2002) Cultural influences on personality Annual of Review of Psychology,

65.

37th Ed, (1998) Dept of Economic & Social Development Statistical Office, United Nations NY：United Nations

66.

& Singer, (2002) The myth of individualism-collectivism：A critical review The Journal of Social Psychology,

67.

Webster, (1994) Individual differences in need for cognitive closure Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,

68.

Whiting, (1975) Children of six cultures：A psycho-cultural analysis, MA：Harvard University Press

69.

Yu, (1994) The nature of achievement motivation in collectivist societies,

바로가기메뉴

Article Contents

Vol.19 No.3

Cultural ‘Tightness-Looseness’：A Multilevel Theory

Abstract

Reference

Korean Journal of Social and Personality Psychology